3 ms·
Do you have any evidence In-Q-Tel has ever done anything like that? I know the NSA disclosures have everyone all amped up, but if the only evidence for an accu
by eli 13y ago
Do you have any evidence In-Q-Tel has ever done anything like that?
I know the NSA disclosures have everyone all amped up, but if the only evidence for an accusation is that nobody can prove it didn't happen, then it's still a conspiracy theory in my book.
- jacquesm 13y agoNone whatsoever. That's why it is interesting. If someone throws around large amounts of money without asking for anything in return that's normally called charity. DOD does a lot of that (pretty much the whole internet came from there) and I'd happily assume this is just like that. So unless someone steps forward with something concrete that's where it stands. But given the latest batch of revelations investments like these will be scrutinized a lot more than in the past. We can ridicule these ties all we want but after it has become a documented fact that industry has received (substantial) investment in order to facilitate wholesale eavesdropping nothing else you could think of seems too far-fetched to possibly be reality. That's maybe one of the biggest bits of fall-out from all this media hype, conspiracy nuts suddenly seem to be fairly respectable and maybe a little bit gullible and naive. It's gone a lot further than I ever thought it would have. I'm not in a position to receive funds from a CIA backed VC but if I were they wouldn't be on my shortlist for ethical reasons, but for practical reasons I'd be happy to take the money. There is some irony in the CIA indirectly investing in HyTrust, if the NSA had used that product then Snowden wouldn't have been able to do what the did :)
- eli 13y agoAbsent any evidence whatsoever, I see no reason to doubt the official story: http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2012/07/16/156839153/in-q-tel-the-cias-tax-funded-player-in-silicon-valley http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2012/07/16/156839... I wish the government would do more to help fund research and innovation.
- jacquesm 13y agoI tried to address this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6393680 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6393680 Almost all technology is 'dual use', even a hammer. It is probably a lot harder to find something that does not benefit the CIA/NSA/Bogeyman than something that does. The tricky part is that three letter agencies are now toxic in a way they weren't before and that could easily hurt perfectly good entrepreneurs that took their money in good faith, if only because other entrepreneurs took such money in bad faith. Especially palantir will have a hard time with such associations.