4 ms·
Somehow, I don't see increases on municipal taxes (Which, all in all, make up a small part of our overall tax burdens) to the main cause of the exodus... Compar
by vkou 13y ago
Somehow, I don't see increases on municipal taxes (Which, all in all, make up a small part of our overall tax burdens) to the main cause of the exodus... Compared to the lack of employment - from, say, the demise of the Detroit auto industry.
It doesn't matter if your municipal tax bill is 0, if you don't have a job.
- dantheman 13y agoI don't have it the information at hand, but I believe many people moved to the towns just outside of detroit to escape the taxes. IIRC those towns/cities are doing fine.
- vkou 13y agoIn which case, I'd cite the ability, and the desire of the American middle class to raise their children in a gated suburbia to be a far more likely factor. Think of it as a typical parent - would you want your kid to go to school in Detroit? (The same school that Balanced Budget politics is more then willing to defund.)
- philwelch 13y agoThat trend lasted from the 50's through the 90's or so, but the trend now has been to move back into cities, except for Detroit.
- NoPiece 13y agoI think it is way too early to call a trend. And to the degree cities are growing just barely faster than suburbs (.2%) for the last couple years, that can largely be explained by the housing bubble and recession. While there is some data showing young people moving to cities, there isn't much showing families returning to cities. According to his analysis of the 51 metropolitan areas with more than 1 million people, the primary cities in those metros grew an average of 1.1 percent, compared with 0.9 percent growth in the suburban areas of those metros between July 2010 and July 2011.* http://www.theatlanticcities.com/neighborhoods/2012/06/urban-or-suburban-growth-us-metros/2419/ http://www.theatlanticcities.com/neighborhoods/2012/06/urban...
- philwelch 13y agoIt remains to be seen whether the trend among young people will continue as those generations have their own children.
- xradionut 13y agoThis is true of many metro areas. The overall decline in Dallas (Texas) schools began with the boom economy in the 70's and 80's and the flight of the middle class to suburbia, the Park cities and exurbia. It was sped up due to school integration and ever ongoing mass migration of poor and wealthy from out of state/county.
- JackFr 13y agoA little of both -- draw your own conclusions Census City Metro Region 1940 1,623,452 2,544,287 2,911,681 1950 1,849,568 3,219,256 3,700,490 1960 1,670,144 4,012,607 4,660,480 1970 1,514,063 4,490,902 5,289,766 1980 1,203,368 4,387,783 5,203,269 1990 1,027,974 4,266,654 5,095,695 2000 951,270 4,441,551 5,357,538 2010 713,777 4,296,250 5,218,852
- chiph 13y agoI thought Texas has high property taxes (no state income tax, so that's how government is funded), but $6700 per $100k valuation is steep. Plus a 2.4% local income tax, plus a tax on utilities, plus a tax on gambling. Just crazy.
- DamnYuppie 13y agoThe tax rate on property is closer to 1.8% and not 6.7%. So you would have to have a home over $300k to pay $6700 in property taxes. Also I am not aware of a income tax, at least not in Dallas. The sales tax is a bit high though at approximately 8%.
- anigbrowl 13y agoHe means that tax in Detroit is steep relative to Texas.
- ahlatimer 13y agoAre you talking about the property tax rates in Texas or Detroit? Detroit's property tax, at least according to the article, is 6.7%. That's what the GP was referencing.
- DamnYuppie 13y agoNo I was referring to the rates in Texas. I may have mistook what the original poster was saying.
- chiph 13y agoProperty taxes in Texas can vary by quite a bit depending on where you're located, since so many special districts are overlaid, and have taxing authority. One of the properties I'm looking at has City of Austin, Williamson County, Austin Community College, Williamson County FM/RM (roads??), Round Rock ISD, and Upper Brushy Creek water collection. Total tax was $1800 on $210k
- muzz 13y agoI agree this is the main take-away from the piece. The tax base has just collapsed. Surely there was some mismanagement, but even without that they would still be in trouble.
- comrade_ogilvy 13y agoBut the tax base did not collapse. It drifted downs to ~60% of peak, while the populace drifted down to ~40% of peak. Shrinking is always going to be a painful and not easy process, but the raw numbers suggest that it was doable.
- muzz 13y agoProperty Tax did collapse, and from 1960 to 1980. http://www.freep.com/graphics/financial-history/detroit-bankruptcy-four-taxes-3.gif http://www.freep.com/graphics/financial-history/detroit-bank... This begets the downward circle the article refers to, i.e., that because of lower property tax revenue, they have to raise other taxes which in turn cause further decline, etc.
- Shivetya 13y agoWell the 1967 riots didn't help much either, nor did the downward spiral in race relations in Detroit. It drove much of populace out who could move. Taxes weren't the old reason, just compounded on top of consistently corrupt administrations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1967_Detroit_riot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1967_Detroit_riot
- VLM 13y agoLooking at the actual figures, I don't think the 240K who moved out in the 00s, left because they just noticed the '67 riots. The population loss in the 70s was very small.
- colomon 13y agoSuggest you look at these figures -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6394464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6394464 -- and reconsider. (Or counter with better figures, if you have them.)
- AsymetricCom 13y agoJust another case of corporate socialism. The big three were just following the profit when they left Detroit a hollowed husk of an auto industry. Now the people they left to clean up the mess, they did the real harm by making sure normal people could afford to live.