3 ms·
G is notoriously hard to measure accurately. Wikipedia's entry on the topic suggests that you read a 1997 review paper at http://iopscience.iop.org/0034-4885/6
by dalke 13y ago
G is notoriously hard to measure accurately.
Wikipedia's entry on the topic suggests that you read a 1997 review paper at http://iopscience.iop.org/0034-4885/60/2/001 http://iopscience.iop.org/0034-4885/60/2/001 . That abstract starts:
> Improvements in our knowledge of the absolute value of the Newtonian gravitational constant, G, have come very slowly over the years. Most other constants of nature are known (and some even predictable) to parts per billion, or parts per million at worst. However, G stands mysteriously alone, its history being that of a quantity which is extremely difficult to measure and which remains virtually isolated from the theoretical structure of the rest of physics. Several attempts aimed at changing this situation are now underway, but the most recent experimental results have once again produced conflicting values of G and, in spite of some progress and much interest, there remains to date no universally accepted way of predicting its absolute value.
The Wired article confirms that it's hard to measure, with some examples of the difficulties.
However, G* M is not hard to measure accurately. We believe the Earth gains about 100,000 kg per year from meteors, and in any case, the Moon and the Earth have changed by much less than one part in a million over the last few decades. So any change in G* M should be due to a change in G, even if we can't measure G directly.
This is of course also why we don't know the mass of the Earth better than a few hundred parts per million.
- ISL 13y agoIt's precisely because almost all gravitational dynamics are controlled by G*M (for some M) that G is so poorly-known. We're forced to do terrestrial experiments, and they're extremely difficult. G is very seductive. It seems obvious that we should be able to measure a fundamental constant of nature to better than 14 ppm (or, if you take the scatter of current measurements, 100s of ppm), but it's really really hard.