3 ms·
Spoken like a true gentleman. Now, let's move along to the real issue: copyright is a government granted monopoly. People generally regard monopolies as a bad
by bediger4000 13y ago
Spoken like a true gentleman.
Now, let's move along to the real issue: copyright is a government granted monopoly. People generally regard monopolies as a bad thing, economically, they distort markets, they encourage rent-seeking (rather than actual production), they have a host of ill effects.
Does the high-quality, innovative, original music that we're getting from the Major Labels right now justify all the drawbacks?
- res0nat0r 13y agoIf the big music labels are so terrible, why do artists continue to sign deals with them? It is because the benefits they afford outweigh the drawbacks.
- bediger4000 13y agoArtists are not society as a whole: they're a special interest. Monopolies effect the entire market, both sellers and buyers. Monopolies have bad effects mostly on those who don't own the monopoly. Artists signing with major labels become part-owners (in a way) of the monopoly good. Of course artists will continue to sign with major labels. That's a simplistic economic analysis: major lables mostly screw the artists as well, but still, I think my analysis holds a little truth. But let's get back to the real question: are the market distortions, etc arising from the copyright monopoly worth enough to society in general (not merely some particular set of special interests) to justify it?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]