4 ms·
You're all over the map: first, participatory music can't produce a Messiah, or a 9th Symphony. Now copyright is neccessary to get artists to create. Which is
by bediger4000 13y ago
You're all over the map: first, participatory music can't produce a Messiah, or a 9th Symphony. Now copyright is neccessary to get artists to create. Which is it? Or is there a third concept, that confuses the argument further?
- snowwrestler 13y agoLet me simplify: It takes significant investment to create high-quality, innovative, original music. In the good ol' days, the only way to get that investment was from a few rich folks. Today, copyright enables more options.
- bediger4000 13y agoSpoken like a true gentleman. Now, let's move along to the real issue: copyright is a government granted monopoly. People generally regard monopolies as a bad thing, economically, they distort markets, they encourage rent-seeking (rather than actual production), they have a host of ill effects. Does the high-quality, innovative, original music that we're getting from the Major Labels right now justify all the drawbacks?
- res0nat0r 13y agoIf the big music labels are so terrible, why do artists continue to sign deals with them? It is because the benefits they afford outweigh the drawbacks.
- bediger4000 13y agoArtists are not society as a whole: they're a special interest. Monopolies effect the entire market, both sellers and buyers. Monopolies have bad effects mostly on those who don't own the monopoly. Artists signing with major labels become part-owners (in a way) of the monopoly good. Of course artists will continue to sign with major labels. That's a simplistic economic analysis: major lables mostly screw the artists as well, but still, I think my analysis holds a little truth. But let's get back to the real question: are the market distortions, etc arising from the copyright monopoly worth enough to society in general (not merely some particular set of special interests) to justify it?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 13y agoIt doesn't take significant investment to create high-quality, innovative, original music - indie bands all over the world are creating such music without seeing any profit, as all the "capital investment" neccessary (good instruments, good recording gear, good software) can be afforded by mid-class people/students as an [expensive, all-consuming] hobby and the only thing needed is lots and lots of time from them and recording/audio folks, which can be obtained w/o cost, if the desire is big enough. No, the reason for copyright monopolies was that it took significant investment to mass-manufacture and distribute everything even after the creative work itself was written. Starting with books and ending with CD mastering. Now a million-copy album is not the only way, as it's just as economically feasible to do 10 000 "prints" of albums that get 100 copies each, since distribution is free on the net.
- snowwrestler 13y agoI just really strongly disagree with the concept that time has no cost for musicians, simply because they happen to like what they do.
- PeterisP 13y agoSure, it's a significant cost - but quite many people are both willing and able to pay that cost; as the cost mostly depends on the stage of your life (family, kids, other commitments) and the desired lifestyle. The point is, usually market prices are set not by your costs, but by the costs of your competitors. If sufficiently many others can undercut you because they are willing to do it for less or for free... then no matter what your costs are, the market won't pay you anyways. Trying to change such basic behaviors is simply futile, it simply won't work even if the goal is good.