3 ms·
Handel's Messiah dates to 1741, Beethoven's 9th to 1824. Almost certainly neither one was copyrighted by the composer, or his employer(s), as a work for hire.
by bediger4000 13y ago
Handel's Messiah dates to 1741, Beethoven's 9th to 1824. Almost certainly neither one was copyrighted by the composer, or his employer(s), as a work for hire.
Those two pieces (and other famous classical works) may not have been a product of participatory music, but they certainly were not products of some exactingly strict copyright regime, either.
See: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1336802 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1336802
In fact, copyright appears to have had the wrong effect on classical music composers: it caused them to coast, to live from their monopoly rents. See:
http://books.google.com/books?id=8-4catWPy84C&pg=PA36&lpg=PA36&dq=effect+of+copyright+on+verdi%27s+career&source=bl&ots=kgoSK9KvLF&sig=DQiYctKs7RnIynphfFYGdTIX-aU&hl=en&sa=X&ei=AgI3UoDUNcGRqQHhq4HwCQ&ved=0CDAQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=effect%20of%20copyright%20on%20verdi%27s%20career&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=8-4catWPy84C&pg=PA36&lpg=PA...
- snowwrestler 13y agoThose composers did not need copyright since they were paid upfront by rich patrons to write their music. Artists who did not write what patrons wanted to hear, were not able to find full-time employment creating their art. And people who did not know the patrons, or who could not afford tickets to the few public performances, did not get to hear that music. Once music notation was fairly standardized, artists and patrons could sell sheet music for their works, which allowed them to performed more widely. Sheet music was indeed protected by copyright. In more modern times, copyright has enabled artists to find success by appealing directly to popular audiences. Modern music labels make their investment decisions based on what they think will be popular, not their personal tastes. Granted, labels do tend to pick a genre, especially smaller labels--I would not expect Righteous Babe Records to sign Korn. But within their genre they are looking for music that they think will resonate with their fans. Digital technologies make it possible to get this proving process out of the club and directly into recorded music. Owl City is a great example--his recorded music (which he chose to distribute for free online) got very popular, leading to a recording deal. That deal will allow him to focus on his music full-time, hopefully leading to more complex, sophisticated compositions. Without copyright, the recording company could have just downloaded his recordings off MySpace, pushed them into iTunes, funded a huge marketing campaign, and make a ton of money without sharing any of it back to the artist. Copyright forces labels to sign legal agreements with artists in order to sell their works.
- bediger4000 13y agoYou're all over the map: first, participatory music can't produce a Messiah, or a 9th Symphony. Now copyright is neccessary to get artists to create. Which is it? Or is there a third concept, that confuses the argument further?
- snowwrestler 13y agoLet me simplify: It takes significant investment to create high-quality, innovative, original music. In the good ol' days, the only way to get that investment was from a few rich folks. Today, copyright enables more options.
- bediger4000 13y agoSpoken like a true gentleman. Now, let's move along to the real issue: copyright is a government granted monopoly. People generally regard monopolies as a bad thing, economically, they distort markets, they encourage rent-seeking (rather than actual production), they have a host of ill effects. Does the high-quality, innovative, original music that we're getting from the Major Labels right now justify all the drawbacks?
- res0nat0r 13y agoIf the big music labels are so terrible, why do artists continue to sign deals with them? It is because the benefits they afford outweigh the drawbacks.
- bediger4000 13y agoArtists are not society as a whole: they're a special interest. Monopolies effect the entire market, both sellers and buyers. Monopolies have bad effects mostly on those who don't own the monopoly. Artists signing with major labels become part-owners (in a way) of the monopoly good. Of course artists will continue to sign with major labels. That's a simplistic economic analysis: major lables mostly screw the artists as well, but still, I think my analysis holds a little truth. But let's get back to the real question: are the market distortions, etc arising from the copyright monopoly worth enough to society in general (not merely some particular set of special interests) to justify it?