3 ms·
Raising and providing for your kids is the most important thing in life I've heard a fair number of people say this, as a social piety line - one of those thin
by gruseom 17y ago
Raising and providing for your kids is the most important thing in life
I've heard a fair number of people say this, as a social piety line - one of those things everyone nods their head at, with which you're not supposed to disagree. But I do disagree. Certainly it's important. But there's nothing more important than reproduction and the endless family trance? I refuse to accept that.
I observe a lot of people doing a passable job of raising and providing for their kids and using that as an excuse for never pursuing what they really wanted. It is the socially acceptable way to plug the existential void (for twenty years, anyway). Apart from its obvious flaws is the ironic fact that in the end, it's a lousy, dispiriting example to set for one's kids.
I applaud your defense of responsibility. But after years of struggling with this, one thing I am sure of is that it's not as simple as TV moralists want to make it.
- endtime 17y ago> But there's nothing more important than reproduction and the endless family trance? I refuse to accept that. I think there are two interpretations. One is that having and raising kids is the most important thing you can do. This is, as you say, questionable (which is not to say that it's not extremely important to me, personally). The second, however, and the one I think tjic meant, is that if you do have kids, then raising them and providing for them is your primary responsibility. I think that's a lot harder to dispute.
- gruseom 17y agoIt's clear that he didn't mean the first interpretation, because he said "your" kids, i.e. presupposing that you have them. Primary responsibility? Sure, up to a point. Where that point is is what's in question. "Most important thing in life" is far too absolute. Is anything more dangerous than a socially acceptable opiate?
- endtime 17y agoThere's a difference between "most important thing" and "only important thing".
- silentbicycle 17y agoIf you have kids, be responsible and raise them well. If you don't want to have kids, be responsible about that. I don't read a moral judgment about the necessity of having children in the quoted sentence, although many people seem to.
- justin_vanw 17y ago> But there's nothing more important than reproduction and the endless family trance? We all have 4 Billion years of ancestors who lived short and brutal lives. They sacrificing everything for their children in the total poverty of nature. Often they would have to watch more than half of their children die in order to raise some that made it to adulthood. Now, I'm fat and lazy, I don't have to search for food, and none of my children are likely to die. If I said raising children was too much work, or my time was too important, or I had more important things to do, I can almost imagine some old german farm woman from 500 years ago rolling with laughter. Fortunately for you your ancestors disagreed (if you enjoy existing). Either you will change your mind when you hit the right point in life, or your genes will drop out of the gene pool and be displaced in the next generation with genes which are slightly more likely to produce a person who wants to reproduce. I agree with you, though, that most people end up not really taking care of their kids, and just letting the TV raise them. That is very annoying. Kids really do require endless attention and time, but I've done both (had kids and previously didn't have kids) and I can tell you that something clicks in your brain, and you wouldn't want to go back. I suppose I could hit you with the categorical imperative or something :)
- HeyLaughingBoy 17y agoIf you have kids then yes, it is the most important thing. But it's just as important to have a balanced life, not just to feel good because you sacrificed for your kids. Martyrdom doesn't help anyone and feeling resentful because you can't do what you want because of children won't help either. Balance your needs with theirs, but realize that in the final decision, what's in their long term best interest comes first. If you don't have kids, then the statement is pointless. Having kids you don't want just to meet some societal standard isn't just stupid, it's cruel to them.