3 ms·
Your last remark is true, but a bit falsely dichotomous. The choice isn't between perfect estimates and zero wastage. In practice all projects lie on a continuu
by jacques_chester 13y ago
Your last remark is true, but a bit falsely dichotomous. The choice isn't between perfect estimates and zero wastage. In practice all projects lie on a continuum between totally novel and pointless duplication. Within that continuum we can draft estimates of varying accuracy and I don't see a reason why we shouldn't.
- wpietri 13y agoThe amount of time we get is fixed. Estimation is, from the Lean persepective, muda (normally translated as waste). If I can be spending that time instead on an activity that reduces the waste of duplication, I'd rather do that. I should be clear that I'm not totally opposed to doing estimates. I've done a lot of them, I'm good at it, and there are circumstances where I would do it again. Some waste is temporarily necessary. What I'm pushing back against here is the common assumption (which maybe you don't have) that estimates are generally a good thing to do, or, often, the only way to do things.
- jacques_chester 13y ago> If I can be spending that time instead on an activity that reduces the waste of duplication, I'd rather do that. Estimates can prevent waste by giving us a better of idea where to redirect effort. Time is, as you say, doled out at a constant rate. The highest ROI possible for an estimate is to prevent wasteful effort from proceeding. Timeboxed systems still perform estimation, you just hold different variables constant. In flow-based systems you can perform estimates by taking an integral of the current output. My point is that estimation is always present, even when we go out of our way to say that it isn't. They lie on a continuum from gut feel to supercomputers and conference papers. Estimates are always present because humans must always reason under conditions of uncertainty; the future is strictly unknowable. Part of the confusion here is that I think there are two or three definitions of estimate in this thread. I am talking both about the universal case and the methodical estimate-with-an-E case. The universal case is that all decisions leading to action or inaction involve estimation. The methodical case is that estimation for software development is possible and tractable outside of genuine research.