4 ms·
This doesn't seem to add anything new to the article about drug addiction and "Rat Park" that was posted and extensively discussed two days ago: https://news.y
by greenyoda 13y ago
This doesn't seem to add anything new to the article about drug addiction and "Rat Park" that was posted and extensively discussed two days ago:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6379522 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6379522
"So, if Rat Park is to be believed, drug addiction is a situation that arises from poor socioeconomic conditions. From literally being a rat in a cage. If you're a rat in a park, you'd rather hang out with your friends and explore the world around you."
It's a pretty big leap to extrapolate from research on rats in cages to socioeconomic conditions in human societies. For one thing, poor humans don't live in cages, and thus have a lot more freedom and much richer environments than rats in a lab. Also, poverty doesn't seem to lead to drug addiction across all human societies and cultures, so there are probably other factors involved.
- cardiffspaceman 13y agoThe argument should be, is the DARE propaganda misrepresenting the science or not? The "other" FA actually covered some nuance, but the news, for those of us who did not know about this study 35 years ago even though they were actively reading things, is that rats might need a bad environment to be prone to prefer morphine to food. Which is not what the prevalent message was over the past 3 decades.
- BIair 13y agoSource: My brother died of chronic alcoholism at 42, and http://www.drugscience.org/dl/dl_comparison.html http://www.drugscience.org/dl/dl_comparison.html Addiction rates: Marijuana 9-10%, Alcohol 15%, Cocaine 15-20%, Tobacco 20-30%, Heroin 23-25% Dependence (ordered higher to lower): Nicotine, Heroin, Cocaine, Alcohol, Caffeine, Marijuana When first seeing these stats, I was surprised how low the additication rates were for heroin and cocaine. Growing up in the DARE era, I thought simple consumption was enough for everyone become an addict. Instead it appears a game of roulette based in genetic makeup. The more one researches, the more one realizes the the legal drugs of nicotine and alcohol are more dangerous than those targeted by the "war on drugs".
- astral303 13y agoThe difference (from what I remember from an NPR interview) is that cocaine is a drug that is used much less frequently (a few times a week) than nicotine (which is used several times a day). Frequent use leads to the brain getting that much more frequent reinforcement of the drug.
- gnaffle 13y agoYet, nicotine don't destroy families and make people lose their jobs (unless they smoke it for many years), so there is a real difference in the consequences for the people who do get addicted to alcohol or the harder drugs. So grading drugs on a simple "danger scale" isn't very helpful.
- chimeracoder 13y ago> Yet, nicotine don't destroy families and make people lose their jobs (unless they smoke it for many years) That's a pretty big "unless". As for the immediate effects, nicotine is easier to come by - you don't have to go to a sketchy dealer in an alley to pay an outrageous markup to get your cigarette fix. Also, heroin doesn't have this effect either, contrary to popular belief. Look up the success rates of diacetylmorphine maintenance programs - programs in which chronic drug users are given a steady supply pure, uncut heroin (ie, no fiberglass/etc.). These people are able to hold steady jobs while using heroin only at night, the same way a habitual drinker might have a shot of whiskey every night. The incidence rate of negative social externalities (such as crime) has actually dropped for people who are enrolled in such programs.
- waps 13y agoEver since I was 8 I've seen both of these camps every now and then. One side claiming drugs are extremely evil and you can never touch them even once. Other side claiming that any kind of addiction is perfectly fine to indulge in, some of them even if it hurts others to varying degrees. These were long stupid discussions, and like every 8 year old, I was on the side of "why not ?". And then, you know, you start studying, never giving it a second thought. And then I visited a "home" (a prison, really) for the mentally ill (where they keep addicts here, perhaps that should be mentally ill and criminal), and had a few (mandatory - grmbl) talks with them to see and analyse their reaction patterns (lots of paper writing after the visit). They had an addict that had only arived the day before, which we had to talk to. There was no more doubt after that in my mind. Cocaine heroin and other opiate addictions are indeed evil itself. You get addicted and overdose, or you lose interest. If you get addicted. Either that kills you, or it leaves you addicted, attempting to cure yourself. Even if you manage to "cure" yourself (not really possible, but yes you can learn not to touch the drug, you can't learn not to crave it), you will leave with a seriously handicapped brain, and nowhere near the emotional control you had before you started on the drug. The fresh arrivals in the clinic, fresh off the drug, are ready to kill, or rape themselves, and worse just for one more ml of the drug (a fact they claim is frequently exploited by prostitution and crime). Yes alcohol addiction is bad. Especially the medical effects are not fun. Psychologically they're not much fun either. However to claim that an alcohol addict is anywhere near the same level of addiction/danger as an opiate addict is insanity, and only illustrates your complete lack of experience on the subject. And nicotine addicts detoxing are downright pleasant people, in firm control of their emotions, nothing at all like recovering opiate addicts. And these numbers ... they're not going to convince anyone who's ever worked with these people. If they claim any opiate is harmless, or even on par with alcoholism, then there's quite simply something very wrong with your measurements.
- hollerith 13y agoThe claim is not that poverty leads to drug addiction; the claim is that the lack of "social integration" leads to drug addiction. Many very poor communities throughout history have had very good social integration. Social integration means a sense of belonging to a community or a tradition and regular contact with people who know you and who know they are going to continue to have regular contact with you. The significant part of being stuck in a small cage is the absence of the things that usually given "meaning" to the rat's life, particularly the ability to interact with other rats.
- AznHisoka 13y agoMaybe that lack of social integration leads to less dopamine, which makes us seek drugs/alcohol/sex. I know I often feel naturally "high" when I feel like I belong to a group/community. Things such as hanging out with close friends, achieving something with a friend, celebrating things together really do make me feel great about life. I mean.. why would I want to seek drugs if that was the case?
- collyw 13y agoBecause they can enhance it even further. They can give you insights that you wouldn't otherwise have. Many famous musicians and artists are inspired by drugs, and I think it is unlikely that they have a problem with social integration (though others probably do).
- rsheridan6 13y agoAnd being a non-poor human is not exactly playing in the park, since, unless you're born rich or have your dream job, you have to make some sort of sacrifices that involve doing non-fun work.