7 ms·
2. As a result, less people will have jobs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_unemployment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_unemployment Th
by jseliger 13y ago
2. As a result, less people will have jobs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_unemployment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_unemployment
This isn't true, though people keep writing about it in various contexts: Babbage in the 19th C, and David Ricardo: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Ricardo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Ricardo. The jobs people do change. No one in 1800 worked as a video-game designer or social media marketing specialist. Few people today work as farrier or milliners.
I have no idea what the book situation is like in China, but if you can, get a copy of Tyler Cowen's recent book Average Is Over.
5. Richer people will get richer. Poor people will get poorer.
The entire world has been getting richer for centuries, and in the last couple decades the world has seen unprecedented wealth creation due to the fall of Communism. See Cowen, noted above, or something like Why Nations Fail by Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson.
- svachalek 13y agoThings never change, until they do. Think about the extreme case, where a $10,000 machine can do any job that humans currently do, better than they do, 24 hours a day. Would the entire world find new jobs, everyone doing things that no one up until 2013 had ever done before, things that machines are still not capable of, things that are valuable to the economy? I doubt it. At some point, the machines will win, and everyone that doesn't have the means to own machines and/or integrate them into their body is going to have a really hard time of things. Just how soon is debatable, but the way things are going I won't be surprised to see it in my lifetime.
- tomrod 13y agoWhen you assume the outcome, of course it's inevitable. But consider: machines are still dumb. At the end of the day, someone automates the process. If all work that is necessary for the function of life can be automated, how wonderful! But, consider the dishwasher. It saves time, but is often misused by dirty dishes going in without pre rinse and disposal. So technically the work has been automated, but parts of the work still require manual operation. But now we pay people to pre wash instead of wash.
- RyanZAG 13y agoIf we make a better dishwasher that does not require pre-rinse, what happens to your argument? Is your argument that there will now be some other task, maybe loading the dishes? Consider: washing the dishes across a town employs 1000 people. Pre-washing the rishes employs 300 people. Loading the dishes employs 100 people. The factory creating the dishwasher is automated and employs 10 people. 50 people are involved in designing and marketing the dishwasher. We have now gone from employing 1000 people to employing 150. Those 850 people are now unemployed and must seek or create new employment. Whether they succeed is irrelevant though, the dishwashing process now needs fewer employees and economic benefit has moved from the employees to the smaller number of people creating the dishwashers. So your argument doesn't work for a simple reason: automation (by definition) reduces the number of people required to complete a task.
- tonyedgecombe 13y agoThe paradox is if the jobs are eliminated by the machines then so are the customers for the products produced by the machines.