3 ms·
Participatory music is great, and continues to this day, but it didn't produce Handel's Messiah or Beethoven's 9th. High-quality original music has been somethi
by snowwrestler 13y ago
Participatory music is great, and continues to this day, but it didn't produce Handel's Messiah or Beethoven's 9th. High-quality original music has been something people buy for many hundreds of years. It's just that until recently, the only people who could afford to buy it were rich patrons.
Copying technologies (first printing, then audio recording) have made such music available to the general public. Copyright has created the financial means to create such music specifically for the public's tastes.
It also protects amateurs or indie artists from exploitation, by preventing big companies from just stealing the songs and re-recording them with their manufactured stars.
Manufactured stars are not collapsing, by the way. Music piracy has been rampant for over a decade and we're still stuck with Myley Cyrus and Justin Bieber and One Direction.
The exact opposite is actually happening--piracy is hurting middle-class artists and their indie labels, while big labels just force their manufactured stars into 360 deals. So they don't care if they lose half their sales to piracy. They're getting a slice of everything else: every tour ticket, every sync license, every TV appearance, every endorsement deal, every t-shirt, everything.
- quadrangle 13y ago"Copyright has created the financial means to create such music specifically for the public's tastes." Hypothesis there, I don't accept it, and there's little controlled empirical evidence for it. Piracy is hurting artists is also a baseless assumption that is grounded really strongly in a bunch of reactionary people's minds who can't yet realize that the economic assumptions they had from an earlier time were actually flawed to begin with. "Losing sales to piracy" is a tenuous hypothesis. Some evidence shows that piracy increases sales more than it reduces them. At any rate, we have enough music now for everyone to listen to neat things for the rest of all lifetimes on the planet. There's no need to subsidize it anymore with these schemes to criminalize sharing.
- sally88 13y agoIf that were true, shouldn't music sales be exploding instead of decreasing?
- sirwitti 13y agoNo, as there's more going on than piracy in the music business.
- bediger4000 13y agoIf you look at the entire music industry, rather than just sales of shiny plastic disks, it is exploding: http://www.techdirt.com/skyisrising/ http://www.techdirt.com/skyisrising/
- xerophtye 13y agoExactly. the manufactured star system still works but that industry has grown smart enough to not rely on the sales of the albums for revenue. They found a hundred other ways to make money and all that is only possible if you have a manufactured star. So the big players still earn big bucks, but the amateurs earn pretty much nothing from their time and talent. PS: I think piracy kinda supports the star economy as a wider circulation of the music results in higher appeal of the star. If the records by big stars couldn't be pirated, people would mostly stop listening to them, and THEN the star industry would collapse
- bediger4000 13y agoHandel's Messiah dates to 1741, Beethoven's 9th to 1824. Almost certainly neither one was copyrighted by the composer, or his employer(s), as a work for hire. Those two pieces (and other famous classical works) may not have been a product of participatory music, but they certainly were not products of some exactingly strict copyright regime, either. See: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1336802 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1336802 In fact, copyright appears to have had the wrong effect on classical music composers: it caused them to coast, to live from their monopoly rents. See: http://books.google.com/books?id=8-4catWPy84C&pg=PA36&lpg=PA36&dq=effect+of+copyright+on+verdi%27s+career&source=bl&ots=kgoSK9KvLF&sig=DQiYctKs7RnIynphfFYGdTIX-aU&hl=en&sa=X&ei=AgI3UoDUNcGRqQHhq4HwCQ&ved=0CDAQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=effect%20of%20copyright%20on%20verdi%27s%20career&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=8-4catWPy84C&pg=PA36&lpg=PA...
- snowwrestler 13y agoThose composers did not need copyright since they were paid upfront by rich patrons to write their music. Artists who did not write what patrons wanted to hear, were not able to find full-time employment creating their art. And people who did not know the patrons, or who could not afford tickets to the few public performances, did not get to hear that music. Once music notation was fairly standardized, artists and patrons could sell sheet music for their works, which allowed them to performed more widely. Sheet music was indeed protected by copyright. In more modern times, copyright has enabled artists to find success by appealing directly to popular audiences. Modern music labels make their investment decisions based on what they think will be popular, not their personal tastes. Granted, labels do tend to pick a genre, especially smaller labels--I would not expect Righteous Babe Records to sign Korn. But within their genre they are looking for music that they think will resonate with their fans. Digital technologies make it possible to get this proving process out of the club and directly into recorded music. Owl City is a great example--his recorded music (which he chose to distribute for free online) got very popular, leading to a recording deal. That deal will allow him to focus on his music full-time, hopefully leading to more complex, sophisticated compositions. Without copyright, the recording company could have just downloaded his recordings off MySpace, pushed them into iTunes, funded a huge marketing campaign, and make a ton of money without sharing any of it back to the artist. Copyright forces labels to sign legal agreements with artists in order to sell their works.
- harshreality 13y agoWhat historical classical music demonstrates is that we don't need the lure of becoming independently wealthy from a few hits to motivate talented artists to produce good music. This can be seen in other media as well. Many painters and now-famous authors were poor, never having been appreciated in their lifetimes. Shakespeare wasn't poor, but the money he made wasn't from copyright royalties, and he would have been a copyright infringer[1]. Your other concern (in a subcomment) of the music industry ripping off and selling artists' music in the absence of copyright merely demonstrates that there might need to be copyright protection against commercial resale, and perhaps commercial advertising or rebranding, as opposed to the wide net of current copyright law which criminalizes a significant portion of the population and puts an even larger proportion at risk of lawsuits. Consumers will buy music even if it's available for free, because even with complete discographies of the most popular modern artists available for free online, those artists are still getting rich despite piracy and despite the music industry's creative accounting. I think part of the blame for less popular artists not making a decent living lies with the major record labels for focusing public attention so narrowly on the music of a few pop stars, to the exclusion of other music that's less polished and perhaps less catchy, but (arguably) musically superior. [1] https://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/02/18/shakespeare-and-copyright/ https://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/02/18/shakespe...
- GFischer 13y agoI was extremely impressed by the way producers milk their manufactured stars... One Direction's latest tour has a ridiculous number of shows (130? over a hundred for sure), and I've heard the boys themselves don't make all that much per individual show (multiplied by a few hundred shows it definitely adds up, but nowhere near what the producers make!). The producers/labels take the lion's share - OTOH they definitely are the ones that "created" the boys' fame, so it might be fair.