3 ms·
Sorry but many many many so called artists cant play or compose anything to save their lives. P-diddy never played an instrument. Plenty of popular singers are
by ThomPete 13y ago
Sorry but many many many so called artists cant play or compose anything to save their lives.
P-diddy never played an instrument. Plenty of popular singers are mediocre to say the least. And many many many very talented musicians make no money what so ever.
Musical talent have very little to do with whether you can live from your music.
- mehwoot 13y agoMusical talent have very little to do with whether you can live from your music. For some genres of music yes, for others, no. There are genres where sound design is of the utmost importance. I'm not saying competition isn't a factor universally- I'm saying genres without significant competition still have the same problems, so it clearly isn't the dominant factor.
- ThomPete 13y agoThe genres where it matters are not genres where you can make a lot of money and are not the genres we normally talk about when we talk about piracy.
- uniclaude 13y agoA few electronic music acts might disagree with you here. Daft Punk? Skrillex? The Prodigy? A lot of importance on sound design here, and it is major enough to be on topic on most of those debates.
- ThomPete 13y agoLets not confuse things here. It is not because of their skills around sound design that they or any other become popular. It has to do much more with timing, culture etc. Again there are many great great sound designers and and composers out there that will never see any fame at all. It's much more complex than just the music itself.
- lgieron 13y agoSo you're saying that their music isn't actually outstanding, they just got lucky? If so, I'd be grateful for a list of artists who makes as good stuff as Daft Punk or Prodigy does, but who didn't make it because of "timing, culture etc.". They can very well be my next facourite bands.
- ThomPete 13y agoNo I am not saying that. I am saying it's a much larger chain of events than simply their skills and talent that makes someone popular. Luck is one of them the same way it is for startups. Timing is another again just like startups, network and so one.
- lgieron 13y agoYeah probably, but also a lot of the stuff that is acclaimed is just really good. Luck plays a factor, but I'd be surprised if there were guys who make music as good as say Radiohead's, who are toiling away in obscurity because they were unlucky. My point is, a a lot of the indies make music which, while being solid and obviously requiring tons of work, still can't compare to the output of the few talented guys who made it. For the most part it's not luck, just skills gap. Almost nobody wants to listen to decent music if they can enjoy masterpieces.
- ThomPete 13y agoThere are. Believe me there are. Great bands are built over time, they are not inherently great.
- uniclaude 13y agoMusical talent does not equal being able to play an instrument. Or maybe are you willfully leaving composition and music theory out of the equation for some reason? (note: I'm not defending diddy here).
- ThomPete 13y agoI can assure you that diddy has absolutely no musical theory background nor any composition skills in any meaningful way. You don't need to be good with theory to be good with composition. But again the point is that there is absolutely no correlation between being great a musical theory, talented performer or experienced composer and the ability to make money from music. The ability to make music has to do with the ability to be an entrepreneur.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI wholly agree with the above.
- Shish2k 13y ago> But again the point is that there is absolutely no correlation between being great at [...] theory, talented or experienced and the ability to make money [...]. > The ability to make money [...] has to do with the ability to be an entrepreneur. So much like every other industry then? :( </prolific indie software developer with no marketing skills>
- snowwrestler 13y agoAll right, so it's only ok for you to pirate music that you think is terrible.
- ThomPete 13y agoYou like strawmen huh?
- snowwrestler 13y agoNo, my reading was that you were making an argument about artistic merit or legitimacy in a thread about piracy. I guess I don't understand what point you were making.
- ThomPete 13y agoPerhaps you should read what I was commenting on so you get the context.