4 ms·
"The real risk is false alarms," The real risk is false flag ops. Say Tel Aviv vaporizes tomorrow and no one takes responsibility. Who do we nuke? They'll b
by VLM 13y ago
"The real risk is false alarms,"
The real risk is false flag ops. Say Tel Aviv vaporizes tomorrow and no one takes responsibility. Who do we nuke? They'll be demands we blast "somebody" of course. As everyone knows, the enemy of the day would probably be Iran. Now the Iraqis have no great love of the Iranians, so the logical thing for any upwind country to do, is when they obtain a special weapon, use it to frame a downwind country that's known to be further along the process than they are.
I believe this is a major part of the motivation for the Iranians to build their own nukes. Obviously their neighbors benefit by framing them, so their only hope is to build a deterrent force before they get framed.
Who benefits if Pakistan and India degenerated into a limited nuke war? Well whoever that is, is somewhat likely to want to encourage it, which wouldn't take much.
This is the hidden danger of the US/Russia MAD scenario, we could take onesie-twosie potshots at each other with no retribution because someone else would be blamed (probably China) The fact this fairly likely scenario hasn't played out is pretty interesting.
- hga 13y agoYou can deduce the source of the fissionables and the design of the weapon by analyzing the isotopes left over.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoOnly using science though. and Hans Blick, the UN weapons inspector, was able to determine that Saddam had no WMD capability. sadly we did not believe science, and I expect, in the afterglow of a nuclear explosion, that we shall not believe the tales told by isotopes either we are a dumb species
- hga 13y agoTo the best I can determine, he's a lawyer, not a scientist (no biography says what any of his non-terminal degrees were in). You're also welcome to explain what these bits from his Wikipedia entry have to do with "science": "Hans Blix personally admonished Saddam for "cat and mouse" games and warned Iraq of "serious consequences" if it attempted to hinder or delay his mission. In his report to the UN Security Council on 14 February 2003, Blix claimed that "If Iraq had provided the necessary cooperation in 1991, the phase of disarmament – under resolution 687 – could have been short and a decade of sanctions could have been avoided."" He also famously got tricked by Sadam prior to the 1991 war ... any particular reason he should have gotten extra respect when he said the same thing again?
- lifeisstillgood 13y agowell, my recollection of the press at the time, including the suicide of at least one whistleblowing phd / nuclear specialist, is that Blick was head of a group of experienced weapons and related scientists who used trace evidence and known production techniques to estimate what could be produced and what had been produced. whether Blicks was himself a scientist is unusual but not relevant I guess - its just following the trail of evidence that matters.
- hga 13y agoYou're invoking "science" in a cargo cult way, at least when it extends to the point you're trying to make. Yes, Blix and company had a set of methods that in theory could detect active WMD programs. But when put to the real world test before 1991, they utterly failed; per Wikipedia: "It was only after the first Gulf War that the full extent of Iraq's nuclear programs, which had switched from a plutonium based weapon design to a highly enriched uranium design after the destruction of [the] Osiraq [reactor], became known." So there was no reason their subsequent pre-2003 invasion opinions that said exactly the same thing should have been given much weight, let alone be allowed to end the discussion with an invocation of "Science!". (That was a particularly difficult situation, where Sadam himself believed he had some active programs but underlings where pocketing the money, and we still don't know exactly what he shipped to his neighboring Baath Party frenemies in Syria, just that there was a lot of it, and 1991 showed he was willing to send stuff that he'd otherwise lose to even his worse enemies (e.g. planes to Iran). For all we know, if Iraq was making binary munitions they could have been the source of the nerve gas apparently used by whomever in eastern suburbs of Damascus last month.) Whereas isotope analysis after a nuclear warhead has been lit off is a conceptually much more straightforward thing. You're not e.g. trying to prove a negative, you know there was a device and that it came from somewhere, you're just trying to figure out the somewhere.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI'm not invoking "Science!", just "Evidence".
- chiph 13y agoAssuming the public, politicians, and other leaders give the technicians + scientists enough time to perform the analysis.
- hga 13y agoI'm perhaps unreasonably assuming a lack of a death wish. Retaliatory attacks on the wrong nuclear power means you're now fighting a nuclear war against two nations. The first will likely still be striking you, and you'll likely get more cities slagged by the nation you've incorrectly gone to war with. I also tend to assume D.C. is a highest priority target, so who knows what the political situation would be.