3 ms·
I do agree with this point of view, dislike having to write h/w emulation code for qemu, and have upvoted you; but two points: People do want to run Windows.
by rwmj 13y ago
I do agree with this point of view, dislike having to write h/w emulation code for qemu, and have upvoted you; but two points:
People do want to run Windows. More importantly (to me) they want to extend the useful life of ancient Linux distros (usually for software certification reasons) which no longer run on real hardware but could run indefinitely in a VM. For both of those you do need to emulate real hardware.
Second point is if you take it to the logical conclusion, a simple Unix process is the ideal VM: lightweight, secure, well-defined ABI to the OS. From that point of view, jails/cgroups/LXC/seccomp are likely to be even better than your hypothetical ideal-but-doesn't-work-in-the-real-world hypervisor.
Or to put it another way: If you define the goal as "want to run only a mix of recent Linux and FreeBSD guests which happen to have modern but slightly different kernels from the host", then BHyve is certainly the hypervisor for you (except for all the other hypervisors which are battle-tested and have had years of performance improvements, massive community and loads of documentation). If your requirements are even slightly different from that, then you'd be better off with KVM or LXC.