3 ms·
Very very weak in perhaps the most important area: metadata collection for traffic analysis. Not that this is an easy problem, but it needs to be seriously add
by hga 13y ago
Very very weak in perhaps the most important area: metadata collection for traffic analysis.
Not that this is an easy problem, but it needs to be seriously addressed.
- Zigurd 13y agoIt's really only about his circumstances: He is a well known, high value, static target. So he has to live with metadata collection, but his correspondence partners are already known. He also points to what part technology can play in shutting down mass surveillance: If you blind enough of the dragnet surveillance that high value targets can't be selected, the whole structure loses effectiveness.
- hga 13y ago"If you blind enough of the dragnet surveillance that high value targets can't be selected...." Which is what I've been thinking about. E.g. maintain constant streams of apparently random data traveling hither and yon. Problems: Data caps, especially mobile ones. Could be mitigated by keeping the total bandwidth really low, and "constant" could be "1 packet per N seconds". Without something like a mesh network topology (or perhaps something like TOR, which I haven't studied), you gain nothing, and there's a high value on compromising nodes in-between endpoints. And at least early on, simply being participant marks you. Contra-TOR, I'm just thinking about basic communications, e.g. email and IM, I'm willing to give up low latencies. And my major point, this all boils down to a political problem: what would be the national security state's response to losing so much capability, justification for budgets, people, facilities, etc.? Nothing good unless we win the political battle, with a big loss resulting in it getting outlawed. Note my analysis is in the context of an expectation of serious ... messiness when the "free ice cream" runs out, when one way or another the US Federal government can no longer run an effective annual trillion dollar deficit. And I keep coming back to some of your earliest words on this, in reference to comments by RMS (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5840210 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5840210): "Until the early 80's there was no widespread use of mobile telephony and internet. It's not crazy to think that the surveillance state has ruined the internet and that there is more value in avoiding it than in using it. Maybe it's over. I can recall some TI managers looking at Stallman like he had two heads when he told them, over 25 years ago, that developers would make money with free and open software. The car industry is facing a generation of buyer who find cars a burden. It's crazy to think that we can't screw this up."