2 ms·
As part of my research on estimations I've been working through Edward Merrow's book Industrial Megaprojects. It's based in part on a large database of megaproj
by jacques_chester 13y ago
As part of my research on estimations I've been working through Edward Merrow's book Industrial Megaprojects. It's based in part on a large database of megaprojects that his firm consulted on.
He considers Monte Carlo-based methods to at best pointless, at worst harmful to outcomes (p 324):
The average megaproject cost estimate when Monte Carlo simulation
was used overran by 21 percent, with a standard deviation of 26
percent and with a sharp right skew. When Monte Carlo simulation
was not used, teams were actually more sensitive to basic risks as
they set contingency.
... The use of Monte Carlo simulation has no relationship to success
of megaprojects or any of our other five figures of merit of projects:
cost growth, cost competitiveness, schedule slippage, schedule
competitiveness or production attainment.