5 ms·
Because nuclear power comes with plenty of short/medium term problems as we are seeing today in Fukushima. Much better to exhaust every ounce of potential out
by threeseed 13y ago
Because nuclear power comes with plenty of short/medium term problems as we are seeing today in Fukushima.
Much better to exhaust every ounce of potential out of safe, clean renewable sources first.
- waps 13y agoI thought the point was to reduce carbon emissions ?("renewable" sources, due to the fact that the equipment must be made and transported and maintained, are still using more fossil fuels than they save) And please skip the "but this one version now in the lab ..." speech.
- eru 13y ago> ("renewable" sources, due to the fact that the equipment must be made and transported and maintained, are still using more fossil fuels than they save) I don't think that's true. Do you have anything to substantiate that claim?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoCompared to nuclear, far more people die because of renewable energy per megawatt. It is not better to exhaust the potential of renewable sources, since they lead to more excess deaths. There are a lot of sources that demonstrate this, so I just searched for one: http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Magazines/Bulletin/Bull211/21104091117.pdf http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Magazines/Bulletin/Bull211/...
- grannyg00se 13y agoThat article is written by a scientific adviser to the Atomic Energy Control Board, Ottawa, Canada. If that doesn't bother you, consider that the facts cited come from a "recent" report published in 1978.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoConsidering that is only one of many different articles I have seen on the occasion, yeah, it doesn't bother me. If you wanted to bother me, you'd post something that debunks the claim. I made a search (albeit, a brief one) for the same and didn't find anything.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoFukushima used a more than 50 year old reactor design, it has very little bearing on either the risk or feasability of building new nuclear plants. Moreover, even factoring in the risk of extremely outdated or outrageously unsafe by design reactors and the accidents that have occurred at them such as Fukushima and Chernobyl the overall damage caused by nuclear power plants is still far, far lower than that of coal, oil, or even hydropower. The Tohoku earthquake caused the failure of a dam which killed 4 people, more than have died due to the Fukushima disaster. Overall dam failures have killed hundreds of thousands, which is well above even the upper limits of early deaths due to cancer related to the Chernobyl accident. Meanwhile, the world health organization estimates that coal burning causes as much as a million excess deaths per year worldwide. If CO2 emissions are truly an existential threat to humanity then we should be building nuclear plants like crazy. People who reject the idea of nuclear power but embrace the idea of man made climate change as a catastrophic threat to mankind are either incapable of sane risk assessment or do not truly believe their own claims.
- andrewflnr 13y agoI'm with you on nuclear, but we still don't know how many people are going to die, or rather have their deaths somewhat accelerated or quality of life strongly affected, because of Fukushima. Are we going to be able to get reliable information about an uptick in cancer rates in Japan?
- InclinedPlane 13y agoIt's almost certainly not going to matter. Go back and read my post above and ask yourself whether there is any chance whatsoever that the Fukushima disaster could possibly cause 50 million deaths. That's fifty million deaths. Why 50 million? Because that's about how many excess deaths have been caused by coal power over the lifetime of nuclear power. If Fukushima fails to cause 50 million deaths then the entire nuclear industry will be that much behind in the category of ending human lives. Are new buildouts of fission power plant capacity likely to cause enough deaths to even the balance scales between fission and coal? Extremely unlikely. Even if people build irresponsibly outdated designs like the Fukushima daichi plants or even criminally unsafe designs like the Chernobyl plants it's extraordinarily unlikely that the reduction in threat to human lives caused by being able to shut down coal plants will more than make up for the much smaller risk added due to operating nuclear plants. Edit: a much fairer assessment of relative risk of coal vs. nuclear would delve into deaths and injuries per kw-h, and it would also compare modern first world coal or gas plants vs. modern first world nuclear plants. But that math has already been done and shows that nuclear power is overwhelmingly one of the safest methods of producing power that has ever been created by mankind. And that remains unchanged even if you factor in Chernobyl and Fukushima (which in many ways are equivalent to allowing Chinese unfiltered coal plants into the equation on the other side). And even if you imagine some speculatively high number of deaths, even as many as tens of thousands, as the potential impact of the Fukushima daichi disaster there is just no way that the track record of the fission power industry to date could fall below the level of any other major power source that could potentially serve as base load power for a large industrialized country. It would take multiple Fukushima disasters happening every few years for the fission power industry to finally become as hazardous as gas or coal.