5 ms·
No offence but people such as yourself really are the worst. It's clear that you have absolutely no scientific knowledge about the subject but yet believe you k
by threeseed 13y ago
No offence but people such as yourself really are the worst. It's clear that you have absolutely no scientific knowledge about the subject but yet believe you know enough to disparage experts in the field. If you don't know about the subject (and I don't) the only sensible position to take is an objective risk management one:
Chance of worse case scenario (10%) x Impact of worst case scenario (Severe) = Prepare Contingency Plans.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoAh, pascal's wager. So, which god do you believe in then?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoRisk-management of a risk for which there is evidence is not the same as picking among imaginary entities for which there is effectively no evidence. Plus, Pascal's wager suffers from the issue that for every god X, there is a possible opposite god who really hates people who mistakenly believe in X. This offsets the value of believing in X. Evaluating the wager under that observation leaves you with a net belief change of nil. Contrariwise, there's no evidence of a countervailing benefit to global warming that offsets the possible risk of doing nothing about it. That said, I do have one issue with the argument in that one possible outcome of global warming has effectively infinite cost. That is when everyone dies. I do not know how to multiply (low probability) x (infinity). Maybe someone can explain how a rationalist would handle this case. (Actually, I don't think it's right to call this an "issue." Point of confusion is more accurate.)
- InclinedPlane 13y agoYou're overlooking the opportunity cost that comes with spending effort and money on "forestalling climate change" today. Read my other post (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6388344 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6388344) for why this is likely an extremely bad idea.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoGood point, I did overlook that. Pascal's wager is still way too dismissive of a weighing of evidenced costs and benefits.
- graeme 13y agoYour argument in the other post only makes sense if economic growth per capita continues. That's not inevitable. We've grown using fossil fuels since the industrial revolution. Those let us use the stored solar energy of millions of years. Wind, solar, etc allow us to use the solar energy from single year, and at least currently require fossil fuels to build. It's possible we'll find a way out of our predicament, but the rapid growth we've seen in the past three centuries is not necessarily good evidence for the continuance of such growth.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoIn effect you are saying that we have a better understanding of the long-term evolution of the climate than we do of the long-term evolution of Earth's economy. There is absolutely no evidence that this is the case and considerable evidence that the exact opposite is true.
- DaniFong 13y agoI'd actually like to see the comparison. It seems to me that there is a case for us understanding the long-term evolution of climate. We have a decent record of atmospheric composition and temperature in ice cores, and, after all, we do know something about the effect of greenhouse gases -- the direct physics is not too complex. It's the feedback loops -- clouds, biology and so on, that are the challenge. Likewise with economics. But it seems that the details of the dismal science are even more turbulent...
- InclinedPlane 13y ago> It's the feedback loops -- clouds, biology and so on, that are the challenge. There's a name for those systems. It's called "the climate".
- smsm42 13y agoRationalist would first abandon that notion that cost of adjusting to different climate is infinite, as it flies in the face of all evidence - humans had adjusted to the very wide range of conditions - and would avoid promoting actions for which positive consequences can not be sufficiently substantiated but negative consequences are readily apparent. Once you postulate that global warming is the ultimate boogeyman which justifies any expense spent on preventing it, rationalism is going out of the window. One can not operate rationally within the framework that postulates irrational assumptions.
- VMG 13y agoDo you put your seat belt on when you drive?
- guelo 13y agoYou don't understand, dizzystar felt it.
- vixen99 13y agoHere are some figures on which to do that: http://topher.com.au/50-to-1-video-project/ http://topher.com.au/50-to-1-video-project/
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dizzystar 13y agoI said I hate the confusing rhetoric. I, as an individual, do feel some responsibility for the earth and the people in it, and I cited a few examples that show this belief. Not sure what the emotional explosions and misguided judgements are about.
- pg 13y agoYour comment would be better without the first two sentences.
- sseveran 13y agoIts just as valid for people outside of climatology to comment on this as it is for people outside of finance to comment on financial issues.
- andybak 13y agoIt's a cheap shot but shouldn't that be: > Its just as invalid for people outside of climatology to comment on this as it is for people outside of finance to comment on financial issues.
- SkyMarshal 13y agoWell the financial industry doesn't exactly have a perfect track record of understanding finance either. Even smart experts are just as susceptible to biases and herd behavior as anyone else.
- sseveran 13y agoIn fact people in many different walks of life are often incentivized to have herd behavior. I witnessed the same thing in medical research quite a bit.
- ryguytilidie 13y agoKind of. This guys point is basically "well I didn't do any research, but I believe X". There are plenty of people outside finance capable of doing basic research who are far more qualified to comment on finance than this guy is to comment on climatology.
- mkr-hn 13y agoI try to read opinions from a variety of experts before taking a position. No climate change denier I've met shares this habit.
- sseveran 13y agoI am not sure what a "climate change denier" is. If your scientific opinion requires you to demonize your opposition then something is definitely wrong.