4 ms·
Apache has had an FAQ about this for years that deals with exactly this issue: http://www.apache.org/foundation/license-faq.html#PatentScope http://www.apache.
by DannyBee 13y ago
Apache has had an FAQ about this for years that deals with exactly this issue:
http://www.apache.org/foundation/license-faq.html#PatentScope http://www.apache.org/foundation/license-faq.html#PatentScop...
Almost every company that has adopted the CLA (which is a lot) takes this view.
This is essentially a non-issue in practice.
- ScottBurson 13y agoThat does seem to address the matter. IANAL, but I would expect that a court would take the published FAQ entry into account if the question were ever raised, given that the ASF is here interpreting its own agreement.
- jwecker 13y agoI don't believe a single stated "No" in the FAQ will be very meaningful, except to point out that even the creators of the license failed to notice the loophole. Edit: Also, the fact that the interpretation can exist and is in written form is what suddenly makes it an issue, at the very least for anyone going forward. (IANAL)
- twotwotwo 13y agoIANAL. Seriously, IANAL. The language limits itself to cases where a patent is necessarily infringed by combining the contribution with the product. The scenario in the guy's PDF (also--PDF?) is that an infringement is created later that has nothing to do with his contribution. Also, as others said, 1) if Apache wrote the agreement and says that others' future contributions can't give them a license to other patents, and indications are that people rely on that interpretation, it doesn't seem like a court would read it otherwise, and 2) generally, courts aren't dumb, and they're going to look at the purpose and context of the agreement and realize this is essentially about ensuring you can't taint a project with your invention and then sue for patent infringement, and avoid reading in broader meanings. Going a little further, maybe too far, the paragraph is in the present tense--"you hereby grant," etc. Nothing in there about your future work like you might find in, say, the IP part of an employment contract. Given that, I have a hard time seeing how your contribution in Sep 2013 binds you to license an idea that, since it didn't exist yet and nobody talked about future inventions, neither you nor the other party could've been contemplating. (On the other hand, if there was an idea embodied in your Sep 2013 contribution that merely wasn't patented or assigned to you yet, both parties could have been considering potential patents of the idea when reading the language. So Apache's answer A2 is justifiable.) Finally, I have little sympathy with people's desires to be able to enforce patents against open-source projects anyway, so yeah. While the language is friendly enough to patentholders, I almost wish it weren't. :)
- DannyBee 13y agoLots of IANAL comments here. IAAL :) My statement of "non-issue in practice" was based on being an open source lawyer and having talked with a large number of companies who use Apache based CLA's (including the one i work for, though i'm not speaking for them here) over the years. While there are questions about "claims that later become licensable", i have not seen any lawyers question the scope of the grant and claim it would cover patents implicated by the work except as it existed at time of contribution (and folks are generally aware of the 'ambiguity' that exists here). There are good legal reasons to believe the interpretation would be "as the work existed at time of contribution", and no good legal reasons i'm aware of to believe otherwise. If it actually goes bad at some point, sure, it should be modified. There are no indications it's worth doing any more than wordsmithing any other part of the agreement. Hence, my view: This is not a problem in practice.
- itistoday2 13y agoFeel free to join the discussion on the ASF legal list! :) https://twitter.com/taoeffect/status/379227928573124608 https://twitter.com/taoeffect/status/379227928573124608
- DannyBee 13y agoSure, but you must realize the ASF changing things would not impact much of anything, since the agreement is reused (with very slight differences) by hundreds of folks. In fact, in some ways, you are better off with them not changing it, because if they do, now you have to argue they changed it but they didn't really think that change mattered ...
- VanL 13y agoGlad to see DannyBee here. IAAL too, also specializing in open source. Danny is correct about the prevailing interpretation. I don't see this as an issue.