3 ms·
Once you have the second envelope in hand, since you don't actually know what's in it, the exact same expected-value argument applies to switching back: there m
by andrewflnr 13y ago
Once you have the second envelope in hand, since you don't actually know what's in it, the exact same expected-value argument applies to switching back: there might be $10 or $40 in the other (first) envelope, "so it's in your interest to swap since the benefits outweigh the risk".
While the second swap would reverse any advantage possibly gained, it would also reverse any possible harm sustained
You dont know. The situation is perfectly symmetric; picking and switching is the same as just picking the second one at first. So just pick one.
- colomon 13y agoEnv A has $20 (we have it and know). Env B has $10 or $40 (equal chance). We swap. Now we hold Env B, which has $10 or $40 in it. We know the other envelope (Env A) is $20. Why would we switch again?
- andrewflnr 13y agoThe original statement of the problem says you're offered the choice before you open the envelope. I guess I was sloppy about the $20 assumption too. As for the case you do know, I still feel wrong about the conclusion that you should switch, but I can't formalize it.