8 ms·
This is one of those moments where I learn something I had no idea about, and am very glad someone wrote the Guardian story, and that someone posted it here. I
by peterwwillis 13y ago
This is one of those moments where I learn something I had no idea about, and am very glad someone wrote the Guardian story, and that someone posted it here.
I bought the civet coffee off ThinkGeek for a coffee snob friend of mine years ago. She said it tasted watery and bland, but thanked me for the thoughtful novelty anyway. Now I realize I not only gave her crappy coffee, it was crappy coffee created through abusing animals for a stupid gimmick. I feel like an asshole.
- pdenya 13y agoAt least you learned about the treatment and now won't buy any more. Seems like better conditions than animals get in most US factory farms and there's plenty of awareness campaigns but they're still in business.
- javajosh 13y agoDon't beat yourself up too badly. How were you supposed to know? It's hard for an individual consumer to understand the full impact of his purchase decision in the aggregate and over long periods of time. As a rule, consume what you want more of in the world. (The exception are naturally rate-limited goods, like fish or wild animal droppings, or absolutely limited goods, like fossil fuels.) Consider this: if civet coffee had not ever become popular, then your purchase would have been fine - if anything, you could feel good about yourself since you just injected a tiny bit of cash into a poor area of the world.
- nawitus 13y ago>How were you supposed to know? It's safe to assume all animal products are unethical.
- enraged_camel 13y agoWhat is so unethical about eggs or cow's milk? edit: The point I am trying to make is that not all of our food comes from unethical industrial factory farms. There are a lot of farmers who use ethical and sustainable methods. It is not too difficult to do research and find out how your food is produced.
- jghrng 13y agoIt gets unethical pretty quickly as it is produced at industrial scale.
- rosser 13y agoApparently, you're not very familiar with modern factory farming. One word: "debeaking".
- cromulent 13y agoDepends on your ethics. 9 chickens per square meter for free-range, it's a bit tight for me personally. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-range_eggs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-range_eggs
- antsar 13y agoHuh, wow. It never even crossed my mind that "free-range" and "cage-free" might not mean what it sounds like it means. That was naive of me. 9 hens/meter does not sound very "free" to me either.
- asciimo 13y agoMan, do not worry about naivete. It's actually very difficult to learn the truth about the products we consume. That you are openly expressing your enlightenment is remarkable, and worth celebrating.
- Tyr42 13y agoIn addition to these requirements, free-range systems must also provide the following: One hectare of outdoor range for every 2500 hens (equivalent to 4m^2 per hen; at least 2.5 m^2 per hen must be available at any one time if rotation of the outdoor range is practiced) From the wikipedia page you linked. That's not too bad, is it?
- prof_hobart 13y agoDepends where you live. "In the EU each hen must have at least 4 square metres of space."
- blahedo 13y ago> It's statistically reasonable to assume any particular animal product, that was bought in a store, in the US, and doesn't advertise any particular affiliation with ethical-treatment or other specialty causes, is unethical. I think this is roughly what you meant, right? There are lots of exceptions to the totally blanket assertion, although I think the underlying sentiment (as carefully caveatted above) is basically correct.
- nawitus 13y agoI don't think there's lots of exceptions. In fact, the exceptions are exceedingly rare.
- asciimo 13y agoOne exception that comes to mind: A cow approaches you and graciously hands you a gallon of milk it excreted from its own udder, expressly as a gift to you.
- 4hthth4 13y agoThat's just silly, they don't even have opposable thumbs. It would have to squirt the milk into your mouth.
- tedks 13y ago...so it's safe to assume all animal products are unethical. According to that statement, the ethical value of any animal product is a function of some huge number of variables, and the upper bound on that value is the minimum of that set. So, it's safe to assume that all animal products you encounter as a human are unethical. Regardless of where you buy them, or what their advertising is, you should assume they are unethical and be very, very difficult to persuade. Anything else is just unsafe.
- blahedo 13y agoI agree, and I understood the careful phrasing ("safe", "assume") in the original remark---but given the number of people who apparently didn't understand, I wanted to give a clarified version.
- venomsnake 13y agoAlso eating plants is unethical. For them to be developed we needed to destroy habitats, displace species and cause suffering too. We are invasive species. What we should aim is low impact farming. To extract the most food with the least possible amount of suffering caused and resources expended.
- nawitus 13y agoTechnically speaking my point was "it's more unethical to consume animal products than it is to consume plant-based products".
- venomsnake 13y agoThat is interesting question. Is it more unethical to torture a species and ensure its survival because it is tasty, or to push a species to extinction to farm on its former habitat? And why? This is one of those questions that drink a lot of beer and lead to violence among friends late in the evenings. With no good answer.
- tedks 13y agoDo you think a species as a unit has preferences? It seems like your friends are conflating genetics and utilitarian ethics. There's a way of explaining genetics in terms of preferences, but genes don't really have preferences. Species, by extension, don't have preferences. Cows as a species want nothing. Individual cows do. So personally, as a vegan, I wouldn't see the death of the last cow on earth as a huge loss, as long as the cow was safe, happy, and comfortable.
- refurb 13y agoI never understood the "humans are an invasive species". If a beaver builds a dam and floods a habitat forcing out the native species thats "natural". Humans do the same thing and it's "invasive". I take the view that humans are as natural as any other animal on the planet. We obviously have a goal to sustain the ecosystems we value, but we're just as much a part of the ecosystem as any other animal.
- peterwwillis 13y agoThe original way this was marketed was (paraphrasing): "civets roam the forest, eat cherries, poop, and we collect the poop." In other words, not farmed at all. Sounded ethical to me at the time.
- theorique 13y agoWhat about some kind of artisanal steak, locally-curated by genuine Brooklyn hipsters? Or Kobe beef - those cattle get massages!
- abalone 13y ago>How were you supposed to know? Not to get all philosophical over a story on poo coffee, but this is one of the downsides to free markets. They hide information on the conditions of production unless compelled to by regulation or consumer demand, neither of which typically happen without an awareness campaign (such as this exposé). All you see is marketing and a price.
- iacvlvs 13y agoThere is no true free market in the world. One of the defining characteristics of a free market is perfect information. This is one of the downsides of market imperfections.
- abalone 13y agoErgo, it is a downside of all unregulated markets. I would avoid the term "imperfection" for something that is fundamental to markets. The information on conditions of production usually has to come from the seller and there is usually little incentive for them to provide it unless compelled to.
- icebraining 13y agoErgo, it is a downside of all unregulated markets. Unregulated? Do regulated markets have perfect information?
- abalone 13y agoDidn't say that. Poor information on the conditions and effects of production is fundamental to unregulated markets. Much like externalities, they are not mere "imperfections" or footnotes which is usually how they are presented in pro-free-market Econ 101 texts. They are fundamental; e.g. much of the environmental threat the planet faces can be contributed to externalities and poor info. Nevermind the poor animal-poop slaves. Regulations and activism (such as this type of journalism) are some of the non-market forces that can compensate.
- smoyer 13y agoDon't beat yourself up, but also try to be aware. There are places where people are abused to produce coffee too ... you wouldn't buy blood diamonds, so try to buy fair-trade coffees.
- jerryr 13y agoI tried it directly from Edible[1] (which, I think, was the ThinkGeek supplier for Civet Coffee and Monkey-picked tea--though ThinkGeek seems to no longer carry either). I thought it tasted only slightly better than Folgers. Several of my coworkers also independently arrived at the Folgers conclusion. Except for the novelty, there doesn't seem to be any reason to buy this stuff. Even more so given the animal cruelty angle. I suppose if you must try it, Animal Coffee[2] claims that they do not farm civets. They also offer a stick of the "raw" coffee encased in Lucite[3], which I find a better novelty than mediocre coffee. [1] http://www.edible-shop.com http://www.edible-shop.com [2] http://animalcoffee.com http://animalcoffee.com [3] http://animalcoffee.com/proddetail.php?prod=Souvpw http://animalcoffee.com/proddetail.php?prod=Souvpw
- alexqgb 13y agoBefore the whole civet-poo coffee thing blew up, a friend got me a pound of the stuff. It was beyond amazing. It had a really creamy quality, without the bitter or acidic qualities. And while it was clearly coffee, it didn't taste like any coffee I'd had before. Like coffee from a not-quite parallel universe, perhaps. I truly loved the stuff, but I can't imagine getting it again. Due to the insane prices, it's likely to be heavily cut with regular beans. Worse, the limited number of beans that are real are likely to come from abused animals, which, no way. Locking them in cages and force feeding them beans not of their own choosing has clearly ruined both the creatures and the product. Fucking humans.
- dsr_ 13y agoHave you tried cold-brewing coffee? It extracts flavors without much acid and no bitterness. Good beans become excellent; mediocre beans become nice.
- alexqgb 13y agoAt one point, yes, but the caffeine content was off the charts, presumably because of the extended soak that the method required. One large cup of that and I needed an even bigger spatula, just to scrape myself off the ceiling.
- peterwwillis 13y agoYou can adjust things like using a more coarse grind, lower temperature and shorter brewing times to affect bitterness. Chlorine in your water can also make for more bitter coffee. If all else fails, add a tiny, tiny amount of salt or saline solution.
- ValentineC 13y ago> At one point, yes, but the caffeine content was off the charts, presumably because of the extended soak that the method required. I've heard this anecdotally, went ahead and searched [1], but I haven't found conclusive proof that cold brewing extracts more caffeine than normal brewing. I'd love to see someone measure the levels and write about it somewhere. [1] http://cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/1859/caffeine-content-of-cold-brewed-coffee-higher-or-lower-than-hot-brewed http://cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/1859/caffeine-con...
- GigabyteCoin 13y agoWhy would you feel like an asshole for giving your friend a thoughtful gift? You didn't know any better, you were only trying to bring joy to someone's life. Don't be so hard on yourself.