2 ms·
No, it's not silly. It's an attempt to really think through the threat tree that the NSA represents, which a good exercise. If your system is already compromis
by javajosh 13y ago
No, it's not silly. It's an attempt to really think through the threat tree that the NSA represents, which a good exercise.
If your system is already compromised, then backdoored hardware RNGs are the least of your worries, and "just generate the gpg key" might not be good enough. Consider the case where an attacker replaces your gpg binaries with ones that cc private keys to an external location.
In all honesty, I'd really love to see a formal threat tree with the NSA as the adversary and "an individual's private keys" as the target from someone as well-versed in security as you.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't think you're following my point. I'm not arguing that it's silly to consider whether NSA has backdoored your RNG. I'm stipulating that they have. I'm saying that's not how RNG backdoors work.