4 ms·
The use of malware in police enforcement is truly a unique event in society. At what other point in history has police distributed a completly illegal tool onto
by belorn 13y ago
The use of malware in police enforcement is truly a unique event in society. At what other point in history has police distributed a completly illegal tool onto unsuspected and non-targeted civilians? It feels like a total unexplored area of liability laws, so I look with excitement to when the first lawsuit starts.
Some people have compared malware with guns. This is to me a very bad comparison, since guns actually have legal usage like hunting or self defense.
A better example would be a under cover cop, selling real drugs to real people with the intent to impress a local drug cartel. It has to my knowledge never happen, but it would be interesting to know if the cop could be held liable if someone dies from a overdose from those drugs.
Let say that a police virus spreads out of control, and infects millions of computers. What if this specific firefox exploit get copied by a botnet, and is used to execute credit card stealing software on unsuspected users. How liable can the police become when millions of people are effected? I really have no clue.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- noselasd 13y ago>At what other point in history has police distributed a >completly illegal tool onto unsuspected and non-targeted >civilians? For quite a while. Law enforcement have installed physical surveilance and tracking devices since as long as they have existed - and unsuspecting innocents have been caught on those tapes and recorders. It's also a question of whether those tools are illegal - there may be laws against them , but the government can get special permissions
- greenyoda 13y agoFor a wiretap, they'd definitely need a warrant. And I think there was a recent court decision that says that police need a warrant to put a GPS tracker on someone's car. What they did here was to install malware on thousands of machines, without any probable cause to believe that any specific machine owner was involved with child porn. If I understand the law correctly, they would need to obtain a specific warrant for each machine they wanted to search. Let's say that there was a store in a neighborhood that was known to sell child porn. No judge would sign a warrant that gave police permission to put a GPS device on every car in that neighborhood to track whether they ever visited that store (and they may have visited but bought only legal merchandise). So why is it different if you do it on the internet?
- richardwhiuk 13y agoThat's a pretty poor analogy. A better one would be 'Would a judge give a warrant to allow the FBI to place a GPS tracker automatically on everyone who visited a store that was known to sell child porn?' The answer to that might be yes.
- greenyoda 13y agoI think my analogy is more accurate. There were many independently owned web sites (stores) hosted at Freedom Hosting (neighborhood), and not all of them carried child porn. You could visit one of the legal sites without even knowing that there was child porn being hosted by Freedom Hosting (or even knowing where the site was being hosted). From the article: Freedom Hosting was a provider of turnkey “Tor hidden service” sites — special sites, with addresses ending in .onion, that hide their geographic location behind layers of routing, and can be reached only over the Tor anonymity network. Tor hidden services are used by sites that need to evade surveillance or protect users’ privacy to an extraordinary degree – including human rights groups and journalists. But they also appeal to serious criminal elements, child-pornography traders among them.
- pkinsky 13y agoThe government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition.
- MichaelGG 13y agoThey still poison medicines. Hydrocodone, a Schedule II substance, drops to Schedule III when sold with acetaminophen, a substance toxic to the liver.
- polyfractal 13y agoThis is ridiculous. Acetaminophen is Tylenol. Are you seriously trying to make the argument that Tylenol is a poison? Arsenic is a poison. Lead is a poison. Cyanide is a poison. Tylenol becomes toxic at a certain threshold (like every other substance on the earth for that matter). Sure, it is toxic to your liver in large doses. That isn't why Tylenol 3 is Schedule II while pure Codeine is Schedule II. The difference is in dosage. Tylenol 3 tends to come in doses of around 5mg Codeine to 300-500mg Tylenol. You get T3 when you have a tooth taken out, or maybe some minor stitches. You are also only given a few pills. You get pure Codeine when you break a bone or stick a pencil through your eye. Or one of the stronger codeine-derivatives (oxycodeine, etc). These come in larger doses and are more prone to abuse. Hence Schedule III. I'm no fan of the DEA or the schedule system...but the "Government" isn't poisoning anyone. That's pure FUBAR and true tin-foil-hattery. Its a classification system for the abuse potential of perfectly legal drugs.
- josh2600 13y agohttp://www.medicinenet.com/tylenol_liver_damage/article.htm#do_the_recommended_doses_of_tylenol_cause_any_liver_damage http://www.medicinenet.com/tylenol_liver_damage/article.htm#... Yes, but in rare cases. Acetaminophen is not the easiest thing in the world for your body to deal with. But this is technically correct and in the 99 percent case you're correct so this is kind of belaboring the point. Nevertheless, I thought it was worth mentioning.
- 13y ago
- greenyoda 13y agoIt's possible that installing malware on a machine could be legal if the police have a warrant to wiretap that specific machine. However, in this case, they indiscriminately pushed malware to thousands of users on that site, many of whom were probably not doing anything illegal. So how does this not violate the Fourth Amendment? The Fourth Amendment says: "No Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Text https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United...
- moutarde 13y agoI think the most troubling aspect of this case is that the FBI modified the computers systems before Ireland seized them as evidence. It seems absurd that law enforcement can effectively tamper with evidence before it is secured, then use that tainted evidence as part of a prosecution.
- chopin 13y agoIs there any indication that this evidence is used? This was under discussion around the Bundestrojaner in Germany whether such a computer can be used as evidence. I doubt that this won't come under severe scrutiny at least in Germany.
- almondsays 13y ago> At what other point in history has police distributed a completly illegal tool onto unsuspected and non-targeted civilians? It might be a stretch but.. "LSD was one of the materials tested in the MKUltra program. The final phase of LSD testing involved surreptitious administration to unwitting non-volunteer subjects in normal life settings by undercover officers of the Bureau of Narcotics acting for the CIA." - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_MKUltra http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_MKUltra
- belorn 13y agoThank you. It was a covert human research operation experiment rather than police enforcement, but it still bear some meaning on this issue. The government offered one victims family an out-of-court settlement of $750,000. If the government release a virus and it cause damages, government might be found liable. Still, an out-of-court settlement is not exactly a predicate, so its hard to know what would happen.
- joshmlewis 13y ago> It has to my knowledge never happen, but it would be interesting to know if the cop could be held liable if someone dies from a overdose from those drugs. From some quick researching, it seems the government in the US is more and more prosecuting the dealers, or even the person who gave someone the drugs if there is a death. You give your friend Bob some methamphetamine, and Bob dies, you're more than likely getting charged with second degree murder if they can prove you are the source.
- madaxe 13y agoCops have been picking locks for as long as both have existed.