3 ms·
You're ignoring every contextual adjective in each of my sentences. I didn't say that CPM ads don't work; I said that CPM ads don't work on websites. They work
by derefr 13y ago
You're ignoring every contextual adjective in each of my sentences. I didn't say that CPM ads don't work; I said that CPM ads don't work on websites. They work in non-interactive media, because you are focused on looking, instead of on interacting. Your brain isn't put into an active searching/hunting/gathering tunnel-vision mode. You aren't thinking "is this paragraph worth tweeting." You're just passively consuming, and so your passive consumption can be paused to deliver a word from our sponsor.
> The best ads work when you don't even realize they are an advertisement.
To me, Reddit's ads are excellent because they are precisely the opposite of that: they are clearly ads, they clearly sell me something, I can clearly tell what it is, it's definitely something I want, and if I click it, I know I'll get it, quickly and cleanly. And because all those things are true, the ads can afford to be subtle and pretty, instead of harsh and eyecatching. Sometimes it's just a link to another subreddit, and what they're "selling" is more (loss-leading) free membership. Sometimes it's something that costs money. It's always something relevant.
And the thing is, CPC ads usually are relevant, because it's very easy to tell as the site-owner when they're "working" on a page, and to split-test different ad-providers to find out whose ads get clicked more (and thereby find out what ads people actually enjoy clicking.) In fact, you have to do this with CPC ads--because irrelevant ads won't get clicked, and so you won't be making any money! This doesn't apply to CPM ads, and so CPM ads are generally irrelevant; there's no feedback loop in place to make them relevant. They're not incentivized to be relevant. And yes, if I could, I'd block them as a "revenue source for websites"--because without the (stupid) option of CPM, advertisers would just switch to offering CPC all the time (it's not like they want to suddenly lose 90% of their placements and go out of business either), and the quality of ads on the internet would improve immesurably.
And, having done that, advertising on the Internet becomes as simple as "Do you click on ads? Here are some ads, then." The incentives of that make everyone -- the user, the site-owner, and the advertiser -- much happier.
(And no, I'm not using "CPM" to also refer to brand-associated sponsorship/PR like HN; that's fine, and works everywhere, because it works gradually instead of needing to hook you away from the content you're consuming. Instead, I'm using CPM to refer specifically to creatives that could be CPC, but aren't. Those, and those only, are what create the misaligned incentives for sites to run horrible ads their users have absolutely no interest in.)