4 ms·
Does anyone else occasionally spend an unreasonable amount of time deciding how to name a variable ? :)
by huhtenberg 17y ago
Does anyone else occasionally spend an unreasonable amount of time deciding how to name a variable ? :)
- edw519 17y agoYour question may infer more than you may have meant. Yes, I occasionally spend an unreasonable amount of time deciding how to name a variable. But what is "unreasonable". If 30 minutes of agonizing over a name (and a standard) saves me 6 hours of debugging next month, was it really unreasonable?
- huhtenberg 17y ago> Your question may infer more than you may have meant. Of course, it does. It is a simpler version of "Do you care enough to write elegant code ?".
- edw519 17y agoElegance was the last thing on my mind. I was referring to maintainability.
- huhtenberg 17y agoElegance of the code typically implies its maintainability. Not every maintainable code is elegant though :)
- icey 17y agoAt a certain point, if it's that hard for me to reason about naming something, I like to step back and make sure I'm thinking about the problem at hand the right way. Of course, I don't work on very hard problems, so I'm sure that's different for everyone.
- holygoat 17y agoSelecting a variable name is actually very meaningful, and not just for maintainability reasons. If you have difficulty naming a variable, it could be because you don't have a good grasp of either the problem or your solution, or concepts are conflated. It could be because you don't yet have a vocabulary that provides the terms you need -- imagine if you didn't have the words "result" or "set", but were trying to name a variable to hold the output of a query. It could be that your functions don't do just one thing. It could even be because your language isn't expressive enough. I can generally tell when I'm doing things 'right' because decomposing the problem into functions, naming them, and composing them into a solution is easy: it feels like I'm cutting with the grain, not against it. In this way, coding is like writing a speech or a poem. Deliberating on precisely the right words to use is a key part of the process, and the better your grip on the domain and your arguments, the easier it is to find the words.
- BigZaphod 17y agoOh God yes.
- edu 17y agoYes, last week I spend a lot of time to decide what name to use for a method and some vars. The bad thing is that I was extending the system and the existing names for related methods where... wrong.
- tome 17y agoYes, when I'm programming alone, which is a microcosm example of why I really like pair programming.