5 ms·
A lot things that seem like terrible ideas are not necessarily fraud, at least, not in the legal, criminal sense of the word, because it's not always illegal to
by snowwrestler 13y ago
A lot things that seem like terrible ideas are not necessarily fraud, at least, not in the legal, criminal sense of the word, because it's not always illegal to make bad decisions with money.
It's not illegal to loan money to someone who can't pay it back--which is the bulk of the documentary evidence that I've seen. If a bank knows I faked my income statement but lends me money anyway, that is a bad decision, but it's not criminal fraud (except maybe by me!).
It's not illegal to sell securities that might lose money. It's not illegal to buy securities that might lose money.
It would be criminally fraudulent to materially misrepresent the facts and risks--for example for a bank to say "we verified the income on all these mortgages", or "I guarantee this mortgage backed security will not fail."
But except for a few rare cases, that's not what happened. It was ratings agencies--3rd party companies--who decided to rate some mortgage-backed securities AAA without knowing what was in them. But again, that's not against the law because the ratings agencies are just private companies expressing an opinion.
NOTE - I'm not defending what happened because it was obviously stupid. And I'm not saying that no criminal fraud occurred, because some did.
I'm just an advocate for people understanding what is the actual state of the law, vs. what seems like it "should" be fraud.
- beagle3 13y agoThere are thousands of documented cases of actual fraud, which were not pursued - almost as if the AGs don't want justice. They investigate practically nothing, and when the truth comes out (accidentally or by way of a whistleblower), they move quickly to close it with a slap on the wrist which is usually amounts to a fine far below the damage to 3rd parties. Almost everything about the mortgage business is a fraud from one perspective: MERS. I don't have time to find the terse summary, but http://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=188061 http://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=188061 should give you some idea about what the problem is. The basic problem: without actually recording a transfer at the county registry, a mortgage cannot be given the preferential security treatment. Almost none of the mortgages sold had their title transfer registered -- this would need to be done every time the mortgage changed hands, and incurs a non trivial cost. Instead, the banks made their own law, created a corporation called MERS, which supposedly owns everything, and acts as an agent of the MERS-registered owner. However, this is not legal - not for foreclosing, not for the IRS, not for the counties. Congress' way to fix it is to make it retroactively ok for the banks to make their own law. I'm not following closely, so I'm not sure if that has indeed happened - but I am sure that the whole MERS thing is illegal, and that AGs (except perhaps in Louisiana) try to fix it by ignoring it.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoSo basically, you want banking CEOs prosecuted because they constructed an alternate mortgage registry that has lower transaction costs than the existing system? tl;dr; the financial crisis happened, here is something unrelated which might be technically illegal. Lets get em!
- chromatic 13y ago... an alternate mortgage registry that has lower transaction costs than the existing system? More like "an alternate mortgage registry that has allowed entities to initiate foreclosures even if they don't hold the mortgages".
- beagle3 13y agoIf you actually spend time reading, you'll see that they constructed an alternate mortgage registry that has lower transaction costs that the existing system, but violates (and fundamentally subverts) the law of the land, the tax code, and thus also defrauded investors because when (assuming it does) the IRS and the counties ask everyone to make things right, the investors are going to be the ones holding the bag. And that's just one relatively minor aspect of the mortgage business. Everywhere you look, there's significant violations of laws (robosigning, co-mingling of assets) with essentially NO law enforcement interest in finding the responsible parties. > might be technically illegal. Lets get em! "Technically" illegal? At the very least, they defrauded counties on registration fees (adding up to a few hundred of millions, perhaps billions).