6 ms·
Two things: 1. The data lines can be very important in regulating power output for different devices, and there are different maximums for different versions o
by peterwwillis 13y ago
Two things:
1. The data lines can be very important in regulating power output for different devices, and there are different maximums for different versions of USB. Some devices require data communication to charge. Some require proprietary protocols. Implementing Apple product charging is somewhat convoluted, for example, and has changed over time.
2. A friend of mine is a computer engineer, and tells me that correctly implementing USB in hardware is incredibly difficult. It's possible that devices like these might be skimping on parts of the spec to more easily get a working product out the door.
- charliesome 13y ago> Implementing Apple product charging is somewhat convoluted, for example, and has changed over time. It is? I've never had any problems with cheap AC to USB power adapters.
- mbreese 13y agoI think they are referring to the higher power ipad charging that pushes more amps down the line than the spec calls for. There is some kind of trigger used to tell the charger to send more juice. This device will probably cause that to not work. So, an ipad on this would only charger at the standard/lower rate.
- megaframe 13y agoThe trigger is just grounding the two inner data pins together. This is ok since the data pins are loose pull up so even if the device tries to send data on something with those shorted no damage will occur.
- mbreese 13y agoRight, but my point is that this device won't work with those 'high current' charging devices (at the high current, it will only will only send the standard amps). Unless they included the logic to test this, which, I suppose, is possible.
- kalleboo 13y agoProbably because those cheap AC to USB power adapters are specifically designed to charge iDevices http://learn.adafruit.com/minty-boost/icharging http://learn.adafruit.com/minty-boost/icharging
- njharman 13y ago> Implementing Apple product charging is somewhat convoluted, for example, and has changed over time. If that and other things you claim are real issues then, every dumb usb power brick, every old computer/old charger, every non-apple charger, and others would all have problems.
- megaframe 13y agoI used to design these things. Yes they are difficult to design in the sense of RF engineering to pump that much data on a data line, but the power end of it is a very simplest design. It has a current cap to prevent damage to the regulator circuit and USB regular spec is 0.5A. Which isn't very much if you've ever tried to charge a phone off of that. Without the inner pins it'll default to the low spec (on a well design USB Host) but no damage or risk to having those inner pins float since they have internal pull up resistors. If the device decides to provide more all the better for you as your device is what regulates how much current it wants when an infinite amount is available.
- MertsA 13y ago>If the device decides to provide more all the better for you as your device is what regulates how much current it wants when an infinite amount is available. If the host is capable of providing more power like 2.1A for example, how is that supposed to be signaled to the phone when the data lines are floating high? The way a USB charger that provides more current than the USB spec works is by pulling the data lines either to some voltage or shorting them together or to ground. Either way you need the data lines to negotiate that.
- megaframe 13y agoYeah there's normally a negotiation via pins being grounded or through the level of resistance on that pull up which tells the device what spec is being used. That goes on to tell the device how much power it can pull without causing a power droop. If the pins are missing most devices won't try to pull more, like my phone won't... but I have a cheap external USB HDD enclosure that will pull what ever it needs from the line regardless of the pin setup. Most Mother Boards actually put out 1-2A on those lines so I can run the thing as normal, but the drive comes with this add on extension to hook it up to two USB lines to get around the 0.5A limit. So it'll depend on how nice of a device you have.
- ambrop7 13y agoThe "condom" can be designed to be transparent with regard to one or more kind of power negotiation, though this would require a microcontroller, and possibly some analog circuicity for proprietary resistance-based negotiations.
- amckenna 13y agoYou're correct about the need of the data lines for power negotiation. The LockedUSB kickstarter is creating a USB condom but with power management: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1137339450/lockedusb-adapter-usb-charger-firewall-and-power-o?ref=card http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1137339450/lockedusb-ada... Note: I am in no way affiliated with the above kickstarter
- chacham15 13y agoI have created my own battery usb charger (it takes d batteries and gives a usb port). I simply placed a resistor to a data line and that was it. I understand the idea of power negotiation, but felt like it was way more work than it was worth. I didnt need any complicated circuitry; just a battery, resistors, a couple of wires, and a small dc-boost circuit (to drain the batteries as much as possible).
- gcb0 13y agojust like with a real one... it will be a boring experience and you will be limited to half Ampere of fun. But no harm.
- soravux 13y agoYou are right. I made a review of the USB Condom in my blog, talking about the shortcomings of their implementation: http://multigrad.blogspot.ca/2013/09/review-of-usb-condoms.html http://multigrad.blogspot.ca/2013/09/review-of-usb-condoms.h...