3 ms·
"2. Al Qaeda uses 2048bit RSA for internal communications 3. Most corps, diplomats, criminals, and normal people use 2048bit RSA either directly (SSH keys, Web
by SwellJoe 13y ago
"2. Al Qaeda uses 2048bit RSA for internal communications
3. Most corps, diplomats, criminals, and normal people use 2048bit RSA either directly (SSH keys, Website Certs, VPNs) or indirectly (CA's still use 2048bit RSA certs valid until 2020)"
I don't see how this is evidence that NSA has the ability to compromise 2048 bit keys, at will. Only that they very likely desire that ability. Math doesn't respond to desire.
That's not to say I believe they don't. Just that I can't accept two of your three premises for why one should believe they do.
- drdaeman 13y ago> normal people use 2048bit RSA either directly (SSH keys, Website Certs, VPNs) Any reason for that? [Almost] all of my SSH and TLS (be it HTTPS or OpenVPN) keys are 4096 bits long. I wasn't woried about TLAs with supercomputers snooping on my wires, just heard that 4096 bit RSA keys are considered more secure than 2048 while not sacrificing performance much, so I just didn't have the reason to specify lower size.
- aroch 13y agoAny reason for that? OpenSSL's default keylength is 2048? ssh-keygen uses 2048 by default.
- reeses 13y agoWhen a lot of these tools were first implemented, to get enough entropy, you would have to type and move your mouse for a long time to generate a 1024-bit key. I remember really, really hating that process. Now, you kids these days with your entropy pools and PRNGs in your CPUs because you had an empty spot on the tape-out...get off my lawn!
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoGiven rumor of NSA crypto breakthroughs and fact massive expenditures, it's not unreasonable to believe they've compromised a primary target.