3 ms·
It certainly is a very dividing topic. I estimate that the comments on my personal trip to the bus [1] are split 50/50 between people that admire Chris' story,
by grecy 13y ago
It certainly is a very dividing topic. I estimate that the comments on my personal trip to the bus [1] are split 50/50 between people that admire Chris' story, and people that think he was a dumbass.
I think the argument boils whether Chris was unprepared (mentally and equipment-wise) to go into the Alaskan wilderness. If you read "Into the Wild", and the newer "Back to the Wild" book which has entries from his diary and photos from his cameras, I think it's clear Chris was very prepared mentally - he knew exactly what he was trying to do, and he knew exactly how dangerous it was. He spent months working out, climbing mountains with his heavy pack, and researching wild edible berries and game in preparation for what he wanted to do. This shows he had a clear mind going in.
So essentially, he was trying to do something dangerous, with the minimum amount of gear possible.
This is no different from the countless people that attempt to climb Everest or K2 without oxygen and perish in the attempt. Those people are not considered dumb asses. Neither are the countless thousands and thousands that perish getting out there and pushing themselves as best as they can.
A person's level of preparedness for any life adventure is clearly their own choosing. Who are we to say that someone was foolish for attempting to push the boundaries of what they thought they were capable of?
Even worse, if someone were to be the first to summit some mountain or other without oxygen, they would be hailed a hero. If they died, they'd be a dumb ass. The outcome should not have any baring on if they were "prepared enough" or not - only they can make that choice for themselves.
--
As a side note, have you even spent any time in Alaska or with Alaskans? I live up here. If you were to go more than 10 yards from a highway and didn't have a quad, rifle, chainsaw, axe, saw, three pairs of boots, sixteen gloves, spare everything, spare gasoline, 300lb wall tent & stove, sat phone and a spot satellite messenger and you so much as broke a fingernail, Alaskans would very quickly point out you're a complete dumb-ass for being so horribly unprepared. Even worse, you go by yourself.
[1] http://theroadchoseme.com/the-magic-bus http://theroadchoseme.com/the-magic-bus
- rosser 13y agoI'm sorry, but if you think you can climb Everest without oxygen, and die in the attempt, you were a dumb-ass. Full stop.
- grecy 13y agoLuckily there are plenty of people that don't agree with you, who are willing to try and push the limits of what humanity can do. We're all going to die, you know. Stats on deaths with/without oxygen: http://faculty.washington.edu/hueyrb/pdfs/jama.pdf http://faculty.washington.edu/hueyrb/pdfs/jama.pdf
- ballard 13y agoContemplating, or perhaps risking (at one's choice), death brings appreciation of life. And possibly, what's important.
- drcode 13y agoGiven that over a thousand people have climbed Everest at this point, it seems to me that climbing Everest is about the most boring/pretentious thing I could imagine doing (compared to all the other interesting things you can do in this world)
- dwaltrip 13y agoIronically, this post makes you sound rather pretentious
- chris_wot 13y agoYou're joking. It's still an amazing feat of endurance. People still die making the attempt. And there are 7 billion people in the world. So that means that 0.0000000142857143% of the world have done the climb.
- drcode 13y agoIn your case, I would focus on learning how to do math with percentages first, THEN climb Everest.
- chris_wot 13y agoOops, forgot to times by 100. My bad. That's 0.000014285571%. But then we can remove over 7 billion people who have never made a basic mathematical error, as you're right - the ability to do arithmetic is a critical skill in extreme mountaineering. This leaves us with a world population of 1. It must feel great to be the only inerrant mathematical mountaineer in the world - was that skill learned, or is it innate?
- rdtsc 13y ago> Those people are not considered dumb asses. Wait. Why exactly are they not considered dumb asses? I sure do consider them that.
- chris_wot 13y agoSuch a stupid insult.
- rdtsc 13y agoGuy goes into the wilderness unprepared. Dies. People say he is a dumb ass. Most agree. Other guy climbs a mountain that others have climbed, also unprepared -- hero, pushing the boundaries, expanding humanity's reach. Please...
- grecy 13y ago> Other guy climbs a mountain that others have climbed, also unprepared You're saying he's unprepared because he didn't take every single possible device to aid him (oxygen). What about all the people that take every single thing possible, spend years and years training, are extremely prepared, and still die anyway. Are they dumb asses?
- rdtsc 13y ago> Are they dumb asses? Less so. Depending how informed and prepared they are. Now people can kill themselves if they want to. Certainly only so much can be done to warn or stop them, but it also doesn't make them immune from being called dumb asses. For example I don't see how knowing the risks and choosing to ignore them while climbing a mountain and getting killed in the process is more noble or worthy of praise than getting drunk and wanting to launch fireworks from your shirt pocket and getting killed in the process.
- foxylad 13y ago> Even worse, you go by yourself. This. A lone human is many, many times more vulnerable than even a couple. There is a reason why we tend to stick together. In this particular case, the article seems to be trying to exonerate McCandless because the poison that killed him was unknown at the time. But if he'd gone with someone else, or even organised someone to drop in occasionally, he'd have survived. His loner instinct made his death almost inevitable, dumbass or no. Interesting aside: given the high price of loner genes, we still have loners. Evolution is an amazing process.
- _mulder_ 13y agoIt seems you've failed to understand why Chris McCandless went to Alaska in the first place. I'll give you a clue, it wasn't because of it's bustling social scene. What about Dick Proenneke [0], another notable 'Alaska Loner'. He spent 30 years living 'Alone in the Wilderness'. Albeit in the relative safety of a cabin he'd built and he did have semi-frequency supply drops. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Proenneke http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Proenneke