5 ms·
> a few years down the line it's mandatory That's just FUD. And saying baseless things like "that's never how it works", that's just fearmongering, not contrib
by crazygringo 13y ago
> a few years down the line it's mandatory
That's just FUD. And saying baseless things like "that's never how it works", that's just fearmongering, not contributing to the conversation. It doesn't even make sense.
There are millions (hundreds of thousands? you get my point) of fingerprint readers out there. Suddenly Apple builds one in, an additional feature, and people start inventing conspiracy theories. People are completely confusing real issues (recent NSA disclosures) with totally imaginary ones. It's getting tiring.
- tjtrapp 13y agowhen was the last time u saw people walking down the street playing w their fingerprint readers? readers are not as ubiquitous as iphones.
- coldtea 13y ago>That's just FUD. And saying baseless things like "that's never how it works", that's just fearmongering, not contributing to the conversation. It doesn't even make sense. It makes perfect sense -- you just need to follow the historical precedents, instead of looking for some inevitable logical reason why that would happen. Technologies introduced with the potential to control and restrict people (or users) have always expanded their scope and reach. CCTV was something banks used. Now it's all around modern cities. GPS tracking was once something exotic. Then millions could be tracked through their mobile phone. Then you even get people voluntarily participating in "location aware" services, transmitting their location 24/7. Walled garden software was few and far between all through 1980-2010. Now it's the sole standard on iOS, de facto on Android, and has crept in desktop OS too. There are tons of similar examples. >There are millions (hundreds of thousands? you get my point) of fingerprint readers out there. There were also "tens of thousands" of tablets before the iPad. Still noone cared about them. Mass sales are an enabler. It's another thing for "hundrends of thousands" (far fewer, I'd say) fingerprint readers to be out there in places and devices noone sees excepts when he travels or if he works in some special places that use them for security, and another thing to have fingerprint readers on 1 out of 3 or 4 americans (the iPhone market share IIRC). >Suddenly Apple builds one in, an additional feature, and people start inventing conspiracy theories. I don't care much about conspiracy theories (and I dislike the use of the term to ridicule legitimate concerns, as if we were talking about fake moon landings or UFOs). This comment thread was about some not far-fetched potential implications.
- anigbrowl 13y agoTechnologies introduced with the potential to control and restrict people (or users) have always expanded their scope and reach. Yes, that's why you can't get on the internet except through AOL any more. Walled garden software was few and far between all through 1980-2010. What nonsense.
- coldtea 13y ago>Yes, that's why you can't get on the internet except through AOL any more. I don't see any justification for your sarcasm. It might not be called AOL today, but between FB and Google you have a even more widespread and far reaching modern equivalent. Add Youtube, Android, Google Fiber and Glass to the mix and the control and information gathered is even more than what was there to AOL's wildest dreams. And between Google Search and Gmail, it's even less easy to switch to than from AOL. AOL was all disanvatages, whereas Google Search is best of class, as is Gmail. People are even afraid to leave FB (you see it all the time, even on HN threads) because of peer pressure and the effect on their social life. Leaving AOL never had that. >What nonsense. iTunes Store, Mac App Store, Windows Phone Store, Google Play Store, console software, etc etc. So called "post-PC" devices like the iPad have adopted the walled garden approach, that's not something to be argued, it's a fact. Do you have any counter-examples, or just wanted to insult my response with the content-less reply of "nonsense"?
- anigbrowl 13y agoYou're really equating apples with oranges with 'it might not be called AOL today...' All of your arguments are conclusory instead of evidence based, eg 'people are afraid to leave FB' - really? Afraid? Bullshit. Facebook has utility for them; if something of similar convenience and greater utility comes along, they'll use it. iTunes Store, Mac App Store, Windows Phone Store, Google Play Store, console software, etc etc. So called "post-PC" devices like the iPad have adopted the walled garden approach, that's not something to be argued, it's a fact. Do you have any counter-examples, or just wanted to insult my response with the content-less reply of "nonsense"? Yeas, but your claim was that this is a new thing. Go back and look at home computers in the 1980s or networking hardware in the 90s. Walled gardens have been around for ages: it was the basis of the AT&T monopoly that existed until the 70s (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walled_garden_(technology) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walled_garden_(technology)) and used to be the norm in the motion picture industry at one time before antitrust actions forced the studios to divest their theater holdings. Really, it's up to you to back up your own claims, not up to me to falsify them. You have a bad habit of drawing your conclusion first and then looking for evidence to support it. I personally find it helpful to begin by assuming I'm wrong and trying to falsify my hypothesis.
- DanBC 13y agoI agree that people are making idiotic claims But did you know how many fingerprints are currently being gathered and kept by US government? Here's a 2008 article. (http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/03/25/us-security-fingerprints-idUSN2538685320080325 http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/03/25/us-security-finger...) They take a lot of fingerprints, but don't seem to catch many people. > The U.S. government has been collecting digital fingerprints and photographs of nearly all non-citizens aged 14 and up entering the country since 2004, officials said, in a Homeland Security program called US-VISIT, at a cost of $1.7 billion. > [...] On an average day, almost 14,400 international visitors undergo the fingerprinting process at Kennedy, officials said. > More than 2,000 criminal and visa fraud cases have been detected by the screening process, introduced in response to security concerns following the attacks of September 11, 2001, U.S. officials said. Roughly they've scanned fingerprints for 36,792,000 visitors (who may be repeat visitors), and caught more than 2,000 people. (Between 2001/9/11 and 2008/9/11.)
- benologist 13y agoThe reason they don't catch many people is because they're fingerprinting tourists and most likely first time visitors to the US. I'm surprised they caught anyone at all.
- DanBC 13y agoThey're fingerprinting everyone who isn't a US citizen who enters the US. Repeat visitors are fingerprinted on each visit.
- benologist 13y agoYes I know, I've been fingerprinted a dozen or so times. I don't know statistics but I would guess the majority are first-time or just connecting which still classes as entering the US.
- r0h1n 13y agoI'm from India. And we are 450 million people into (by next year that will be 600 million, and a few years later, 1.2 billion) a mammoth ID project that makes it mandatory to submit your biometric data (all fingers plus iris) to get the 'Aadhar' card. Of course, technically the card itself isn't mandatory, but because it's linked with various govt services ranging from subsidies (educational scholarships, cooking gas), pensions, property sales/rentals and even marriage registrations, it is as good as mandatory for most people. Various countries and multilateral aid agencies/donors are studying the Indian model to see if it can be replicated in other countries. I agree it is not directly connected to Apple, or the US, but there is a progressive and gradual creep into the acceptance and use of biometric data. Links: - U.S. inquires about India’s UID project (http://secureidnews.com/news-item/u-s-inquires-about-indias-uid-project/ http://secureidnews.com/news-item/u-s-inquires-about-indias-...) The Evolution of India’s UID Program Lessons Learned and Implications for Other Developing Countries (http://www.cgdev.org/files/1426371_file_Zelazny_India_Case_Study_FINAL.pdf http://www.cgdev.org/files/1426371_file_Zelazny_India_Case_S..., Section 3: Implications for other countries) - Biometric Sensors in new iPhone Can be a Game Changer in India (http://www.nextbigwhat.com/biometric-sensors-new-iphone-in-india-297/ http://www.nextbigwhat.com/biometric-sensors-new-iphone-in-i...) [Clueless piece, but highlights potential connections b/w iPhone biometrics and other ID projects] - Opposition to the world’s biggest biometric identity scheme is growing (http://www.economist.com/node/21542814 http://www.economist.com/node/21542814)