7 ms·
This gives us four possibilities: 1. This geared creature must be considered part mechanical. A cyborg, if you will. 2. A "gear" is no longer (and was never)
by teddyh 13y ago
This gives us four possibilities:
1. This geared creature must be considered part mechanical. A cyborg, if you will.
2. A "gear" is no longer (and was never) a "mechanical" device, but instead an organic one. Using gears is no longer (and was maybe never) doing mechanics.
3. Whether something is mechanical or organic depends on the process which created it. This is the "colored bits" or "patent" view. (If I build something using intuition instead of reason, am I no longer doing mechanics?)
4. A gear is no longer (and was never) either mechanic or organic, and is simply a physical process. The whole "mechanical" and "organic" division is a false dichotomy.
- andrew_gardener 13y agoI think option 4 is most accurate. Bones and joints basically act as levers and pivots so why can't gear like body parts be found in other lifeforms.
- igravious 13y ago5. All dichotomies are false dichotomies. 6. Creatures like this shake my faith in evolution.
- brianpgordon 13y agoCreatures with cool adaptations strengthen my faith in evolution. It's creatures like the panda or the koala or the sloth that shake my faith in evolution.
- EvanKelly 13y agoThe sloth's evolutionary advantage is that they are so fucking cool.
- maxerickson 13y agoDid you do that on purpose?
- EvanKelly 13y agoNot sure what you mean, so I guess not.
- maxerickson 13y agoThey have a slow metabolism, this requires less energy for survival but also generates less heat.
- crusso 13y ago6. Creatures like this shake my faith in evolution. Why? It's easy to imagine a couple of touching pieces in the ancestor of the issid that aided in synchronizing the jumping mechanics. Over time, mutations in those touching pieces interlocked more firmly until they resembled what we think of as gears. There was pressure on those mutations to proceed toward gears since the gear mechanism is a potentially successful one for achieving the goal of survival through jumping very far, very quickly. Evolution has yielded some astoundingly more impressive structures. Take a look at this video that explains your own muscle contractions: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJ309LfHQ3M http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJ309LfHQ3M The fact that our brains can pattern match the semblance of gears in the issid with gears that we created is a much more impressive development than the gears of the issid themselves.
- astrodust 13y agoExactly. A single bump on each leg might convey a slight advantage, and then the creature that gets two pairs of bumps that mesh together would be even better off. From there it's just a matter of time before creatures with multiple bumps emerge. Being able to jump quicker than your less-able siblings could convey a huge evolutionary advantage. This quickly weeds out the less-able and strongly encourages this kind of structure to develop once the process has started for whatever reason.
- boldfield 13y agoIt's easy to imagine a couple of touching pieces in the ancestor of the issid that aided in synchronizing the jumping mechanics. Over time, mutations in those touching pieces interlocked more firmly until they resembled what we think of as gears. If this were the case, would you not expect to observe these evolutionary steps in other organisms today? As noted in the article: ...there are many jumping insects like the issus... [though] most other bugs synchronize the quick jolt of their leaping legs through friction... If there are "many jumping" insects, how does it come to be that only a single specie (that we know of, granted) that has evolved this feature, and why have we not observed others undergoing the evolutionary process that could/would yield them in others?
- 13y ago
- astrodust 13y agoDo airplanes shake your "faith" in gravity?
- john_b 13y agoFour. A gear is just a piece of geometry that happens to be useful for a number of practical purposes. Same with rods, rings, and so on. People apply labels to it according to how they perceive it.
- wslh 13y agoAnd what's the limit for such innovation? can microprocessors be developed naturally?
- john_b 13y agoBrains developed naturally, so I'd imagine evolution would be capable of developing a natural analogue to a microprocessor if there was sufficient and sustained evolutionary pressure for such an adaptation.
- astrodust 13y agoThe natural processes that drive this sort of "innovation" never work as cleanly as we do when being intelligent about such things. There are elements of "microprocessor-like" components in creatures, things that will do AND, OR, NAND and NOR type logic computation through neurons, but they're not packaged into an integrated circuit. If there was evolutionary pressure to produce an integrated circuit, some form of one would undoubtedly evolve eventually.
- nfg 13y agoI get your meaning obviously, but fundamentally tis a strangely Manichaean outlook: they were developed naturally.
- jlgreco 13y agoWheels/axles at a macroscopic scale seem rather inaccessible to evolution. The problem is keeping two sections of one animal alive across the wheel/axle boundary. You could imagine different ways to grow a wheel/axle structure out of a horn-like material, but it isn't clear what advantage intermediate forms of this would provide. Perhaps it could happen with two separate symbiotic animals though... Microprocessors (aka, brains) seem pretty straightforward though. Even a little coordination and planning is better than none.
- bitwize 13y ago5) Organic creatures have mechanical systems as part of their physiology. "Mechanical" doesn't mean "made of metal", it means "uses movement and friction to achieve some effect". Some mechanical devices, such as levers and swivels, are seen frequently in the animal kingdom; others, such as gears, pulleys, and wheels, are almost never seen in nature. Discovering one of this latter category is a fascinating find.
- sliverstorm 13y agoPulleys are not that rare. Block and tackle is, but you have pulleys in your hands.
- jlgreco 13y agoWikipedia defines pulleys as "A pulley is a wheel on an axle that is designed to support movement of a cable or belt along its circumference", though I think the wheel/axle requirement is probably shouldn't be considered a hard requirement. On the other hand, I don't think I would call the loops that fishing line passes through along the length of a fishing pole "pulleys". I guess I'd say that block and tackle is not common, and neither are "wheeled pulleys", but "friction pulleys" are.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIf your line is out, and you take up slack and the fishing pole starts to bow, the loops are indeed functioning as pulleys.
- jlgreco 13y agoAbsolutely, in the technical sense, though I would hesitate to actually describe it that way. It seems strange. Alternatively, shoelace eyelets are pulleys ('block and tackle' in fact) , but describing them that way seems odd.
- sporkologist 13y agoe.g. Our arms are levers. Bacteria flagella are rotary bearings. Etc.
- mikeash 13y ago5. The concepts of "organic" and "mechanical" are purely human inventions used to conveniently categorize the world, and there is no reason the world has to obey our desire to fit neatly into categories we devise. Any discussion of the meaning of "mechanical" and "organic" is a discussion of language, not of anything outside humanity.
- gph 13y ago"The map is not the territory" Very well stated.
- bcgraham 13y agoIsn't this the same as #4?
- mikeash 13y agoThat occurred to me, but I think it's fundamentally different. "False dichotomy" still admits (and IMO implies) the possibility that these are real actual things, but that the same entity can be both. This is not a false dichotomy, nor is it a true dichotomy, but a misunderstanding of just what concepts like "mechanical" are.
- nether 13y agoTop comment is pretty much, "this changes my whole theory of nonsense which I just invented." It's a pseudoscientific strawman and I can't believe it was upvoted. As a mechanical engineer I see tons of mechanical components in the human body. Diaphragm pumps, ball and socket joints, pinned joints, tensile supports. None of this makes you a cyborg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong
- shabble 13y ago> As a mechanical engineer I see tons of mechanical components in the human body. Diaphragm pumps, ball and socket joints, pinned joints, tensile supports. The chemical engineer points at the vast complexity of enzyme catalysed reactions and intricate supply chains of nutrients. The electrical engineer observes the networked structure of the nervous system, the myriad signal processing pipelines built all from similar, near-standard components, yet ultimately giving rise to consciousness. ...and the civil engineer gets the blame for routing a hazardous waste pipeline through a recreational area.
- jlarocco 13y agoYour use of "mechanical" makes no sense. The definition of "mechanical", according to Webster's dictionary is: Pertaining to, governed by, or in accordance with, mechanics, or the laws of motion. Everything that moves can be considered mechanical. There is no "mechanical" vs "organic" division. It doesn't even make sense.
- cma 13y agoAn electric motor, complete with stators, etc. has been known for a while and it didn't change our concept of 'mechanical': http://www.arn.org/docs/mm/flag_dithani.gif http://www.arn.org/docs/mm/flag_dithani.gif
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoWhat is this?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Kliment 13y agoA flagella. Bacteria use them to move around.
- sengstrom 13y agoOrganic vs. Mechanic is a false dichotomy. There is some latitude in how you define either of those terms, but I think you have to be rather extreme to put them in complete opposition.
- jonnathanson 13y agoThere's never been a dichotomy between organic and mechanical. All things that move are mechanical. 'Mechanical' simply refers to motion. 'Organic' is a similarly blurry categorization. The terms you're looking for are 'natural' and 'artificial,' as in "of nature" and "of artifice (created by man)." These are natural gears, which are so surprising because we'd long assumed the gear itself to be an artificial concept. Notes: 1) I don't use 'artificial' in the more modern connotation, meaning roughly "fake" or "not genuine." Rather, I use 'artificial' in the original sense of the word, deriving from the Latin artificium, or 'craft.' 2) To be fair, 'mechanical' has increasingly taken on a connotation of artifice or man-make ever since the Industrial Revolution (cf. 'mechanic,' 'mechanism'), but in the truest sense of the word, this is not necessarily the case. 3) My semantical nitpicking aside, I admit you raise some interesting points. I want to acknowledge that.
- niels_olson 13y ago> All things that move are mechanical. How is that blurry? > 'Organic' is a similarly blurry category I thought "organic" was restricted to carbon chemistry. Seems pretty specific to me. > The terms you're looking for are 'natural' and 'artificial,' It may be that his choice of words conflicts with his meaning, or at least conflicts with your interpretation of his meaning, but doesn't make his original word choices less specific in their inherent meaning. > 'mechanical' has increasingly taken on a connotation of artifice or man-make Maybe I'm too far down the rabbit hole, but the Industrial Revolution hadn't even occured to me. There is plenty of mechanical action in the human body, and those have certainly been solids long before Latin came around.
- jonnathanson 13y agoWhen I'm talking about "blurry" categorizations, I'm talking about how connotation has blurred what was once a very clear denotation. As in, the literal meanings of words like "organic" and "mechanical" -- which, as you've put it, are not ambiguous in the least -- are being challenged by modern associations of these words outside their original definitions. (A good case in point would be the grandparent comment, which used these words in connotative form to make a point about their denotative meaning). "It may be that his choice of words conflicts with his meaning, or at least conflicts with your interpretation of his meaning, but doesn't make his original word choices less specific in their inherent meaning." Not sure I understand what you're saying here. My point is that the words he used were used to frame a false dichotomy, and that the use of more precise words for what (I interpret) he was trying to get at would have improved his thought experiment. As I mentioned, I think he raised some good points, regardless of word choice. As I also mentioned, "mechanical" (literal) and "organic" (literal) do not form a dichotomy; they are not mutually exclusive categories. Surely you would agree here, as you seem to be saying as much. "Maybe I'm too far down the rabbit hole, but the Industrial Revolution hadn't even occured to me. There is plenty of mechanical action in the human body, and those have certainly been solids long before Latin came around." Again, see my point about connotation vs. denotation. The IR is roughly when connotations about the word "mechanical" started muddying the waters. (We should note that the ancient Greeks, from whom the word 'mechanics' descends, were certainly prolific engineers in their own right -- but they were careful not to blur the lines the way English has). At any rate, I brought up this point simply to give the OP some credit, i.e., that I can see how it's easy to use the word "mechanical" to refer to "artificial," given that modern-day connotation is heading in that direction. This was a side point at best, though, and not the focus of my post. I apologize to you, and to the OP, and to any unfortunate readers of this discussion, for dragging us down what is indeed a rabbit hole.
- ShellfishMeme 13y ago5. A gear is no longer (and was never) either mechanic or organic, it's simply a pattern for solving a certain type of problem. Humans and evolution both found it, but it's more useful for humans.
- dragonwriter 13y ago5. "mechanical", in the sense used here (roughly, "performing a function involving physical as distinct from (bio)chemical, nuclear, etc., mechanisms") is orthogonal to any sense of the word "organic", plenty of other biologically-produced structures are "mechanical" in teh same sense; its not that there is a false dichotomy at issue, the senses of the words are well-understood to not form a dichotomy at all, though there are other senses of the same words that might be part of something understood (rightly or not) as a dichotomy.
- cb18 13y agolenses
- kriro 13y agoMakes me wonder. Suppose someone holds some sort of gear-patent and it turns out the gear-structure is used by organisms that predate mankind (or are older than the patent at least)...would said patent become null and void due to "prior art" or is it sufficient that the manmade gear lives in another application domain?