3 ms·
As a pilot, I'm tempted to speculate on various crashes. I've learned that this is a bad habit. Best case, you get the cause right, and you look like a jerk.
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
As a pilot, I'm tempted to speculate on various crashes.
I've learned that this is a bad habit.
Best case, you get the cause right, and you look like a jerk. Worst case, you get the cause wrong, and you look like a jerk.
I will say that in general, flameouts due to ice ingestion and the complete fly-by-wire system of the Airbus have been generating interesting conversations in the aviation community for some time. Whether this has anything to do with the current situation is anybody's guess. I feel very sorry for all of those involved.
- jgrahamc 17y agoFor an interesting counterpoint on 'fly-by-wire-is-bad' read the Vanity Fair article about the Airbus that landed in the Hudson and how the fly-by-wire augmented the pilot's own ability. http://www.vanityfair.com/style/features/2009/06/us_airways200906 http://www.vanityfair.com/style/features/2009/06/us_airways2...
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI don't think anybody doubts the benefits of fly-by-wire. It's the failure modes that concern some. Not that this issue bears on this particular incident. I was just listing the topics of conversation that come up when talking about the airbus and turbines and T-storms.
- frossie 17y agoBoy, there is some fabulous choice of words in that Vanity Fair article. For example in the part telling the story of an Airbus 330 that ran out of fuel over the Atlantic. Both engines are going out, the flight attendants have instructed passengers to don life vests, the main lights have failed, the PA system goes dead and then finally "as the cabin pressure leaked away, the oxygen masks automatically dropped, and this caused another round of fussing." Yeah, I bet those passengers were "fussy" alright.
- quizbiz 17y agoDoes a gradient apply to fly by wire systems? You and others seem to imply that Boeing/other aircrafts can be less(?) fly-by-wire. How does that work? Shouldn't there always be redundant systems?
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoI'm also about halfway through my private pilot license and while I don't know enough yet to even speculate on crashes, I really enjoy reading the NTSB reports or crash reports in different aviation publications. It probably strikes many people as morbid, but I find it fascinating to try and learn from the mistakes of others so that I can be a safer pilot myself.
- asmithmd1 17y agoContinuing visual flight rules into instrument conditions is the pilot error most likely to kill you. If the weather starts to look bad land - now. Even on a golf course or a field if you have to http://www.humanfactors.uiuc.edu/Reports&PapersPDFs/isap01/gohwiegmannavpsy01.pdf http://www.humanfactors.uiuc.edu/Reports&PapersPDFs/isap...
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThe private ticket is one of the most exciting things I've ever done. Follow it up with some more training, like an instrument rating or some aerobatics (Emergency Maneuver Training) Aviation Safety magazine, in my opinion, has the best crash reviews and safety material. I think by reading those reports they can keep you alive -- it's a very good habit. Somebody once said that the first 1000 hours of flying are the time you're most likely to kill yourself -- especially in the 200-400 hour range, and especially if you let your skills lapse by a few months. I really wish that technology would learn lessons like aviation does. If we had the same feedback and crash analysis as aviation, perhaps so many projects wouldn't waste so much time and money.
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoSomebody once said that the first 1000 hours of flying are the time you're most likely to kill yourself -- especially in the 200-400 hour range, and especially if you let your skills lapse by a few months. I believe you're talking about The Killing Zone, by Paul Craig. Highly recommended. http://www.amazon.com/Killing-Zone-How-Why-Pilots/dp/007136269X http://www.amazon.com/Killing-Zone-How-Why-Pilots/dp/0071362...
- frossie 17y agoIt is human nature to speculate. But at least the article was an attempt at a thorough analysis rather than "it was lightning! It was a bomb!". I have nothing against instructive speculation, even if it turns out to be wrong. And anyway, there is very little opinionating really, all he really said is "turbulance was almost certainly a contributing [my emphasis] factor".