16 ms·
Pushed to the limit as a banking intern
- marco-fiset 13y agoThis is stupid behavior from the banking people. Don't they realize that they are less productive working all-nighters?
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoThe product is billable hours in a lot of cases. Productivity doesn't matter.
- andrew_gardener 13y agoThat actually makes a lot of sense then. They have an overabundance of interns who are willing to work pointless exhausting hours to prove their mettle allowing them to make bank on man hours. The question become then, why do clients allow them to get away with it? Do they satisfy their clients to such an extent that they don't care about bloated costs or do the clients just not know? Edit: changed metal to mettle >_<" thanks
- jackgavigan 13y agoBankers don't charge by the hour. Lawyers are the ones with billable hours. Bankers make fees or commissions on a "per deal" basis.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Pxtl 13y agoFYI, it's mettle. Stupid homophones. And for a client, the deadline is more important than the money sometimes. I mean, when you see what these firms bill, it's obviously money is no object for the customer... because damn. If the job market keeps worsening and huge unemployment/underemployment/unpaid work becomes The New Normal, it will become time to have a hard conversation about hard caps on working hours as a means to improve quality of life for the workers and provide more jobs to the non-workers. You want to put in 100 hours? You'd better be co-owner.
- consultant23522 13y agoWelcome to Bank of NoLife. As a new employee and co-owner, here is your complimentary 1 share of BoN. You now own 0.00000000000001% of the company.
- alan 13y agoSounds like an industry ripe for disruption then....
- ramchip 13y agoInterns don't need to be efficient (they're cheap and disposable), and they don't do very intellectually taxing work, in general. Think making powerpoints, not designing investment strategies or coding. There's little incentive for the more senior bankers to treat their interns properly.
- 001sky 13y agoIts not about productivity. the people doing the work are junior and replaced every 3-5 years. they are disposable, in that sense. Since the repsonsibility gets quite steep quite quickly, its more efficient to haze the junior staff, to push them to the breaking point and see how they do, before promoting them. Many people enter banking who are not suitable to it, because of greed or social pressure. It would be a lot worse if those people were not weeded out. it might sometimes seem impossible that banks could be more poorly run, but there are many who would be far worse to put in these positions.
- notahacker 13y agoExcept that "hazing" arguably selects for those driven by [extreme] greed and social pressure, since anyone smart enough to get into a junior banking position has plenty of more palatable alternatives if they rate "quality of life" higher than "net worth age 30". In theory, if not in practice, ability to rationally appraise alternatives ought to be more important to people making billion pound decisions than energy and sheer bloodymindedness. The only way "hazing" works as a selection effect is if junior analysts' actual work tasks are generally so easy that it won't mentally tax even the below-average ones without sleep deprivation. It's harder to fake competence when you're tired. It's also harder to fake competence if standards are set higher... The more general excuse for overworking bankers is to limit the number of people accountable for a particular project, meaning no sharing of workload even when it would be efficient to do so.
- w1ntermute 13y agoIsn't this all just a matter of supply and demand? There are a lot more young people willing to work in this industry than there are positions, so those people who actually get the jobs have to put up with all kinds of stupid shit. I've never understood why these employees (who are clearly quite intelligent) don't just pursue another career where they have more leverage. After all, I don't think they have any particular love for banking. Being on HN, the obvious suggestion would be software development (not a bad choice, considering the current state of the market), but there are a lot of other options out there as well.
- Mikeb85 13y agoBecause banking makes a hell of a lot more money.
- danielrmay 13y agoThe intern was set to make £45,000 / pa (not including bonuses) as an Analyst, but I suppose it opens doors.
- adam-a 13y agoFor an entry level position that's probably 1.5-2.5x what a software dev could expect to make in the UK. In my experience at least.
- danielrmay 13y agoLondon is different in this manner - an entry level software developer position (at a consultancy, bank, hedge-fund, etc) can go from 35k-45k. Outside of London (as I'm sure you're aware), this could be offered as a senior developer salary.
- adam-a 13y agoI'm in London, albeit not in a bank or hedge-fund. Perhaps I should be asking for a raise :)
- cliveowen 13y agoThis is all really, really wrong. I wonder how we, as a society, have managed to lower our values this much. Working days and nights and for what? Even if you do become rich, then what? You can't have your health back and you wasted years of your life chasing a dream. When you're on the patio of your beach house with your high blood pressure, anxiety and depression, what have you accomplished? Is reality like the dream you once chased? I don't think so.
- jmduke 13y agoWas it intentional or unintentional that your comment also describes the life of entrepreneurs/startup founders?
- coolnow 13y agoThrough a startup, most times at least you can say you provided a service (like Dropbox). With banking, you're pretty much a devil in a lot of people's eyes and you're working purely for the profit of your employer.
- rayiner 13y agoSilicon valley types are the devil to the unwashed San Francisco hippies. As an investment banker you also provide a service. When Google buys a startup for $50 million, that transaction doesn't make itself happen.
- tanzam75 13y agoNo -- but the banks are overcompensated for their work on M&A. You could hire a strategic consulting firm -- McKinsey, Bain, BCG -- to do M&A due diligence for half of what the investments banks charge. They hire from the same pool of 25-year-old Ivy League graduates. I doubt they'd do a worse job than the banks. IPOs? You shouldn't need an underwriter to do an IPO. That's the whole idea behind OpenIPO -- which is how Google itself went public. It's true that the investment banks have access to a larger pool of investors. But that's circular reasoning. If the investment banks didn't exist, then these capitalists would be investing in IPOs through a Dutch auction like OpenIPO. Structured products? The investment banks earn a 50% profit margin on structured products. The people who buy structured products could double their returns by constructing their own structured products on the options and future markets. And if they're not sophisticated enough to do that without an investment bank, then they probably don't understand what they're buying!
- zobzu 13y agoWell,I'm not taking that job.
- nickthemagicman 13y agoWhat does a banker even do during those long hours? I'm genuinely curious.
- JonnieCache 13y agoSnooze on the toilet apparently.
- Mikeb85 13y agoDrugs. Sneak sleep. Throw Blackberries. Write canned reports. More drugs...
- cs02rm0 13y agoKeep up appearances.
- vstm 13y ago... while trying hard not to die.
- robertha 13y agoI worked as an analyst in Investment Banking for a while. To me it seemed that the analysts who worked the really long hours worked on projects in teams, where each team member was responsible for a part of a project. No one can start or continue until that part is done, so they just sit and wait. There were many times when people just wouldn't respect other people's time. At 5PM I would get an email: "Hey, I need this done for tomorrow morning"..."So why didn't you just tell me earlier? I know you knew about it in advance."
- nickthemagicman 13y agoWhat did you do as far as projects that would have such a intense timeline? Was it basically deals going on that needed to be analyzed quickly so they could make a decision?
- 13y ago
- bambax 13y ago> Lots and lots of people, particularly Americans, will use Adderall, Ritalin and Modafinil. I don't understand. Are we supposed to feel sorry for them?
- yogo 13y agoNaively when I see a job ad asking for a rockstar programmer I assume there will be a supply of coke :P. Asking for a ninja... well that doesn't seem as much fun.
- consultant23522 13y agoI had a gig once where the manager pulled us into a meeting and with a straight face told that in order to finish this project on time (really a week early) we were expected to work 12 hour days and be on call. If we got a call and had to respond we were still expected to come in and work the 12 hour shift. I politely raised my hand and with a straight face asked if the company health benefits would include meth-amphetamines.
- yogo 13y agoHahaha, that's the thing, companies expect employees to do whatever they have to for results. In many ways I feel like professional athletes that do the same by doping should get a pass. It's not an even playing field but at the end of the day everyone wants results.
- rayiner 13y agoPeople like to dramatize this a bit, I think. First, I'll quibble with the definition of all-nighter: "I ended up doing an all-nighter in my first week as an intern, which is when you start work at nine, you stay until five or six the next morning, you go home, have a quick shower and then head back into the office and continue working." If you leave work at 5 and start at 9, and are sensible and live within 20 minutes of work (which you can on a banker's salary, at least in NYC), that's like 3 whole hours of sleep. Second, how many times did you pull a few all-nighters in a row during college? I can't even count. I certainly didn't die. Third, he's leaving out the part where a deal dies and you find yourself with nothing to do for days. You may not experience that as an intern, but once you're actually working the 100-hour weeks will be interspersed with very dead weeks.
- JonnieCache 13y ago>3 whole hours of sleep >100-hour weeks will be interspersed with very dead weeks That still sounds pretty dramatic man. Would you want your doctor on that schedule? Your bus/cab driver?
- jmduke 13y agoWould you want your doctor on that schedule? Doctors in their residency have notoriously awful hours, so bad that they had to legislation was crafted merely to cap the hours at a four-week average of 80 hours (meaning that, yes, they could work 3 one hundred hour weeks and one 20-hour week). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_resident_work_hours http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_resident_work_hours
- JonnieCache 13y agoGood point. It used to be like that here in the UK too, thankfully we now have the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_Time_Directive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_Time_Directive
- nc 13y ago
- JimmaDaRustla 13y agoGlad I work for a Canadian/American bank...
- danielrmay 13y agoThe bank referenced in the article is Bank Of America Merrill Lynch.
- JimmaDaRustla 13y agoOh crap.
- sklivvz1971 13y agoYes, and they are still on IE7, poor souls. Doesn't sound like a place I'd work for... nope.
- JimmaDaRustla 13y agoWe got upgraded to IE8 from IE6 last year! :rollseyes:
- Mikeb85 13y agoCanadian banks aren't too bad from what I hear. In the radio episode referenced by the OP, it's mentioned that the worst offenders are Wall St. Banks, and the worst departments are M&A...
- mordae 13y agoIt's sad when the brightest and most competent people end up treated like that, but when they are abused and used against the rest, it's when I start feeling like putting up a guillotine.
- 7952 13y agoI think its sad when anyone is treated like this, and pretending that some people are different with "best and brightest" bullshit just makes things all the worse.
- jackgavigan 13y agoWhen Google was a young company, she worked 130 hours per week and often slept at her desk. "For my first five years at Google, I pulled an all-nighter every week," Mayer said in a recent talk at New York's 92Y cultural center. "It was a lot of hard work." Source: http://www.entrepreneur.com/blog/223723 http://www.entrepreneur.com/blog/223723
- ajmurmann 13y agoWhat makes this comparison not applicable is that the interviewed intern said that they were really just adding warm bodies. I am sure Mayer added far more than that.
- obstacle1 13y ago>I am sure Mayer added far more than that. Eh, depends on who you ask.
- kenster07 13y agoBusinesspeople exaggerate and even outright lie all the time. You should always keep a grain of salt around.
- wavefunction 13y agoI'm sorry but that's bullshit and unsustainable imo. I say that as someone who has worked nearly 100 weeks of 80+ hours over my career and has worked 100 hour weeks for a month or two. It's not believable that Mayer worked 130 hours per week for 5 years.
- 31reasons 13y agoIts technically possible, all you have to do is put sleep in your task list.
- nostrademons 13y agoMayer apparently has the gene that makes you not require (much) sleep. About 3% of the population carries a genetic mutation that means they only need about 3.5-4 hours of sleep a night. I had a friend back in college that was like this (her father was too), and apparently a number of famous achievers have "suffered" from this.
- mason240 13y ago>I ended up doing an all-nighter in my first week as an intern, which is when you start work at nine, you stay until five or six the next morning, you go home, have a quick shower and then head back into the office and continue working. That really doesn't sound any different from doing field operations the military. Except without the shower.
- 31reasons 13y agoComputers have increased people's productivity through the roof and still we see people working more than 100 hour/week. Are they working on something that can't be automated or they don't want to automate ? Are they doing something that can't be done by two people instead of one ? Something is not right.
- jbooth 13y agoThey do small bits of work that would be hard to automate, accompanied by metric shitloads of reporting and process so that the people at the top can look at an oversimplified graph of what's going on.
- static_typed 13y agoYou have to experience working in an IB to appreciate the article. They are very very much swamped down in politics process and paperwork (albeit electronic these days). It takes ages to do small things, forever to do the rest. No one has a long-term view beyond the next quarter, and most believe in doing just enough to grab some bonus and run. You will encounter big swinging dicks who like to lord it over the interns, making them stay late, just because they can. You will see many many unhappy faces everyday, and you will feel a little bit more lost with each day you remain there.
- mcdougle 13y agosounds like grad school....
- asdf2 13y agoBut just think of all the important and valuable work they are doing...oh wait...
- johngalt 13y agoMeanwhile someone who learned to become a plumber or electrician at community college is making more per hour.
- nknighthb 13y agoThese comparisons never work for me. There's literally no amount you could pay me that would make me willing to be a plumber or electrician, and I'm grateful every day that there are a subset of people out there who will do those jobs competently without completely bankrupting me.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoWhile I understand the hesitation to become a plumber, why would working as an electrician be so unpleasant?
- ffn 13y agoThere is inherently nothing wrong with those jobs; both give you adequate skills one needs to not only survive in a company, but also strike out on one's own. In addition, both are positions that will always and forever be needed for as long as women have long hair that clog drains and men build houses with electricity without killing themselves. However, both jobs are stigmatized against by major corporations and government precisely because how necessary yet independent they are. People with money and power are constantly in need of more peons to help them maintain stability and so brazenly flaunt their fabulous wealth in front of us, alluring us with the hope that we too can become like them if only we'd go submit ourselves to their devices. Blinded by this hope and seeing only so many other young brilliant people doing the same, we find ourselves pursuing careers in finance, STEM, business, etc., oblivious to the fact we're playing right into the hands of the corporations. Oh no doubt they'll treat us well, the people at the top are generally good kind folk, but the fabulous wealth, dazzling fame, etc., that they seeded into our imaginations will never materialize in our realities... and before you know it, you're 30+, married with children, and you've come to accept the fact you'll only ever live an (upper) middle class life and the only thing still meaningful in your life is watching your kids grow up and providing for them.
- jordanthoms 13y agoNever understood what the obsession is with long hours in finance - I highly doubt it actually leads to any more productivity, and certainly reduces the quality of decision making. Surely the better way to impress is to do 40 hours of great work, not 110 hours of being barely awake.
- millstone 13y agoas an intern, you're almost functionally useless to your desk. You're not really adding anything, you're not really doing anything, you're just one more warm body. The article makes it sound as if the interns could just play FarmVille all night, as long as they’re at their desk. A lot of people would be doing that anyways at home. Is that a correct assessment?
- sam_bwut 13y agoI've had other interns vary there description between doing loads and not doing anything - people aren't going to micro manage you (or manage you at all half the time...).
- Fando 13y agoThis incident is tragically comical.
- No1 13y agoWhat I find most intriguing is that the whole banking intern hours thing is that it's not the result of a resource constraint - they have plenty of money and plenty of intern applicants. It's also not about getting particularly difficult work done - intern-level spreadsheet and PowerPoint work isn't the sort of thing that only a select few can handle. It's entirely about filtering for people who will submit to abuse.
- fibbery 13y agosee also: bootcamp, fraternity hazing
- yetanotherphd 13y agoAnd, if "The Internship" is at all accurate, big tech companies are no better.
- sneaky_ruds 13y agoIt's not.
- lewispollard 13y agoInterned at IBM for a year and a half and it was one of the most laid-back work environments I've ever been in.
- csmatt 13y agomy thoughts exactly.
- rayiner 13y agoThe point of an internship is to give candidates an idea of what the job is really like. At the analyst level, bankers will be subject to abuse. Not because of resource constraints, but because the job itself is demanding. Deals are fragile creatures that need to be completed quickly, and F500 C-suite executives are demanding clients. They need everything to be perfect and they need it done yesterday. That's what leads to having less people work more hours and the extreme focus on availability.
- yason 13y agoIt makes sense if you get enough money out of it. You can do that for some time. If you don't get paid enough in correspondence to the shit they throw at you, then you must remember that nobody forces you to be there and you can just leave if you think it's stupid.
- lhh 13y agoIn case you're interested and missed it, I wrote about my time as an analyst a few weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6255290 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6255290
- Pro_bity 13y agoThis type of environment is not exclusive to banking. Both doctors (during internship and residency) and lawyers (during the first few years at big firms) go through similar experiences.
- qq66 13y agoThis kind of horrible lifestyle is well-known to everyone applying for a job on Wall Street. Nevertheless, people still apply, and not out of desperation -- all of the successful applicants could get great jobs elsewhere. There's no deceit here -- the investment banks clearly articulate what the lifestyle will be like, and people sign up for the pay. I know, I did an internship at Lehman Brothers and saw it firsthand -- people staying till 3am just to impress. I managed to keep my weekly hours under 40 by automating my job in Visual Basic, and then decided I wanted to make productivity tools for the general market instead of in-house.
- Nicholas_C 13y agoI'm curious which processes you automated in VBA? I'm currently an analyst in an FP&A role. I use VB for a lot of things but I'm not sure I could automate that much of my job. I do a lot of smaller tasks, taking the time to write a macro for each one just doesn't seem to add value. Especially when processes change frequently. Perhaps IB is more suited for VBA automation.
- qq66 13y agoIt was pulling in coupon payment data from Bloomberg for an array of securities (by CUSIP number) and aggregating them to create a payment schedule for the combined portfolio.
- aaron695 13y agoNo one has to be a banker, if they take you in it means you're smart enough to go elsewhere. It's no secret how hard it is. Why do people feel the need to put down the jobs of others? Is it because they are different? Is it jealousy because they are not smart enough or don't themselves have the will power? I don't get it.
- sklivvz1971 13y agoI think it's a way of rationalizing the insane amount of money they make and fighting off the guilt they have for basically not deserving most of it. But of course, I'm not a banker.
- Mikeb85 13y agoOur economy doesn't reward workers based on merit, but on dynamics like supply/demand, risk, scarcity, etc...
- sklivvz1971 13y agoOur economy certainly doesn't reward one based on hours worked, however it's clearly implicit in this behaviour that extra hours are expected of people because they make more. Why? Clearly that's nor justified by economics...
- michaelochurch 13y agoI might sound like a dick here, but I'm just trying to be matter-of-fact about it. If you have depression, anxiety, or panic disorder, you probably shouldn't consider an analyst program to be a viable career option, just as being a pro basketball player isn't viable for 99+ percent of people. Sorry, but it's just not going to work; those typically manageable conditions become crippling disabilities in the crucible of a 100-hour work week. You should probably find another way; if you're smart, you can do something more interesting than analyst dreck, get an MBA, and move in as an associate-- or, perhaps even better, stick with technology and move in as a quant and have a ~10-hour day. This person had epilepsy, which is potentially fatal. He never should have taken on an analyst gig. I'm not saying this isn't horrible and wrong-- obviously, it is-- but I wish in general that young people were more aware of the reality of health risks. It's one thing to go into a job like that knowing what the risks are, but a lot of people have no clue.
- Kudzu_Bob 13y agoThis is just like how the North Koreans used humiliation and sleep deprivation to brainwash American POWs.
- gerhardi 13y agoThis kind of work in investment banking sector seems quite sad - you are no longer doing work for living, but the other way around. I have absolutely no experience on what particular type of tasks are done in these positions. Could someone provide more insight? Maybe there could be opportunity to automate this work, at least partially?
- axilmar 13y agoAlthough his death was a sad fact, the truth is it was his choice. In a free world, every adult is responsible for his/her actions. If he did not feel nice working such long hours, he should have quit. The real issue is if he was paid for overtime and what was his contract details about overtime. Nowadays, a lot of employees demand overtime from their workers without properly compensating them.
- nnoitra 13y agoWorking more than 40 hours in a week is not something to be proud of. In fact, people should be ashamed of it because it displays that they seriously lack intelligence or discipline.