7 ms·
Every Maccard on the planet seems to think pirating OS X is an oh so terrible thing to do (to the point that parent post is bringing up poems about it like its
by josteink 13y ago
Every Maccard on the planet seems to think pirating OS X is an oh so terrible thing to do (to the point that parent post is bringing up poems about it like its a cute, non-weird thing). At the same time pirating everything else on the planet seemingly is OK.
I've never understood the rationale behind this.
Keep in mind I'm a software developer myself and run strictly non-pirated software, and open-source as much as possible. You could never make me replace a Linux desktop with a limited OS X experience, and I see no reason what so ever to put in the effort to pirate it.
But why is it worse to pirate a OS with bad hardware-support out of the box than pirating... say Microsoft Office? I'm just curious what's up with that.
- DominikR 13y agoAs an Android developer I had many discussions with Apple users/devs but I never heard anyone say something like that.
- rahoulb 13y agoIn my experience Mac users tend to be quite scrupulous about paying for their software.
- inthewind 13y agoApart from their Adobe suites... (In my experience). Note that I don't have any pirated software on my machine. Running Debian here.
- nicholassmith 13y agoWith OS X there's no license key you need to enter, they have a poem instead asking you not to steal it. That's a nice thing, rather than assuming you're going to steal it they have a poem to jokingly ask you otherwise.
- icebraining 13y agoSure, no license key, except for the key used to decrypt protected binaries only on authorized hardware. There is a license "key", it's the whole computer.
- derefr 13y agoWhat are protected binaries? This is something I've not heard of OSX having. As far as I know, as long as all the hardware is stuff OSX has drivers for (and you generate a DSDT to describe that hardware) then you don't need any special "authorization." You just put in the OSX installer USB/DVD and it works.
- nwh 13y agoIt's mentioned on the page 0x0 linked to — http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple%E2%80%93Intel_architecture#Dont_Steal_Mac_OS_X.kext http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple%E2%80%93Intel_architectur... > A Mac OS X system which is missing this extension, or a system where the extension has determined it's not running on Apple hardware, will be missing this decryption capability, and as a result will not be able to run the Apple-restricted binaries Dock, Finder, loginwindow, SystemUIServer, mds, ATSServer, backupd, fontd, translate, or translated.
- pcwalton 13y agoCertain apps, such as the Finder and the SystemUIServer, are encrypted and this kernel extension will only decrypt the executable pages if it considers your Mac to be genuine (consulting the TPM, I believe).
- spartango 13y agoThe TPM was used briefly at the beginning of the Intel mac days, but hasn't been used since. The decryption is now done through dsmos.kext in software. http://osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter10/tpm/ http://osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter10/tpm/
- spartango 13y agoOSX does have 'protected binaries', which refers to binaries that use encrypted pages[1] that require decryption via an anti-piracy kernel extension (Don't Steal Mac OS.kext). This extension can check that you're running on Apple hardware by checking with the System Management Controller(SMC), which is Mac-specific[2]. In the old days (10.4), hackintosh systems would patch the protected binaries to remove the page encryption/decryption. Over time kernel extensions were developed to replace the functionality of Don't Steal Mac OS.kext (dsmos.kext or AppleDecrypt.kext) without the hardware checks. The reason you no longer need either of these extensions is because a kernel extension called FakeSMC.kext was developed, which emulates as much of the functionality of the SMC as possible. This includes thermal and fan monitoring as well as the decryption key storage. In a modern hackintosh setup, you make use of EFI emulation (inc. DSDT support) included in the bootloader (a boot-132 derivative, most likely Chameleon) and the pre-boot loading of emulator kernel extensions like FakeSMC.kext. [1]: http://www.osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter7/binaryprotection/ http://www.osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter7/binaryprotection/ [2]: http://osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter7/tpmdrmmyth/ http://osxbook.com/book/bonus/chapter7/tpmdrmmyth/
- gizmo686 13y agoThey also have it (somewhat) tied to the hardware, which reduces the threat of piracy in the first place.
- tlrobinson 13y agoI'm not sure how you came to that conclusion. From your tone I suspect you're simply biased against Macs.
- Kudos 13y agoWhat is a Maccard? I've never heard anyone say that pirating OS X was more ok than any other kind of piracy.
- inthewind 13y agoI thought it was Mactard.
- josteink 13y agoThen you read it again and see that nowhere in that post was the phrase "tard" anywhere to be seen. Maccard = a word for a mac-user person thingie. There's nothing derogative about that. If people read it as you did though, that might explain the downvotes.
- josteink 13y agoMaccard = Mac user. And the attitude I've seen (especially in the OSX 86 community) is that general piracy is completely OK, but you have to buy OS X from Apple, otherwise you are doing something super-duper wrong. Then they move on to pirate Photoshop. It's a mind-bending sort of ethics, and I was curious about what the reasoning behind it was.
- simonh 13y agoI've never once come across this. I've come across Mac people that pirate stuff, and Mac people who don't and think that's wrong. That's fine, different people are entitled to their own opinions. But never once I have a come across anyone suggest that pirating other stuff is OK, but not Apple software.
- coldtea 13y ago>Every Maccard on the planet seems to think pirating OS X is an oh so terrible thing to do First, who are those "Maccards" you are reffering to? Perhaps you meant to say "OS X user" or "persons who likes Apple stuff". Second, a lot of us OS X user could not care less if you pirated OS X or not. Matter of fact, I know several people with genuine Macs that also run a Hackintosh (and I experimented with one a while ago). >(to the point that parent post is bringing up poems about it like its a cute, non-weird thing). The poem is placed by Apple developers, inside the OS X internels. IIRC, it's loaded in a .kext (a kernel extension). That's cute, especially it being a flippant poem and not some 20 page long legal text. In essense, it's a small easter egg. It's not like random Apple users write poems about not pirating OS X, which seems to be your impression. >At the same time pirating everything else on the planet seemingly is OK. "Maccards think pirating OS X is very bad" (wrong) "At the same time pirating everything else on the planet seemingly is OK" (wrong again). Even if "Maccards" (sic) thought that pirating OS X is bad, who told you it's the same persons that think pirating everything else is OK? >I've never understood the rationale behind this. The problem might be that what you believe goes on is not happening in the first place.