4 ms·
I'm an Australian who recently became a Canadian Permanent Resident using a "sponsorship" process not unlike the H-1B. I've also had a few work visas for the US
by grecy 13y ago
I'm an Australian who recently became a Canadian Permanent Resident using a "sponsorship" process not unlike the H-1B. I've also had a few work visas for the USA, and applied for a H-1B (The rules changed before it could even be looked at).
I personally think the idea of bringing in foreign labor is a very bad thing for the sponsoring country.
For example, where I live in Canada has a very high cost of living (very far North), but stupidly the minimum wage is lower than other parts of Canada. Many local businesses pay $14-$18 / hr as a starting wage for menial jobs, even though minimum is legally ~$10/hr, because otherwise nobody would do the the job up here.
When Walmart, McDonald's, KFC, Canadian Tire, etc. (who all have a pre-approved process with the govt. BTW) want to hire someone cheap, they just bring in a foreigner from a second world country. Those foreigners live 20 to a house and make $10/hr. They can't work anywhere else, and if they quit they are deported. So those business can bring down the overall standard of living here by paying less than an average Canadian would actually be willing to do the job for.
If supply/demand was allowed to run it's natural course, those companies would have to pay a little more ($14-$18/hr), their profits would go down a little, but Canadians would be employed and the overall standard of living would not decrease.
Make no mistake about it, bringing in foreigners lowers the quality of life for the original citizens, and only helps increase corporate profits.
(Yes, I know I'm not supposed to bite the hand that feeds me, but I think I have a good perspective on the situation, given that it just happened to me)
- dragonwriter 13y ago> they just bring in a foreigner from a second world country Since the end of the Cold War, the "Second World" (which was a geopolitical rather than an economic distinction) is largely meaningless (First and Third World, from the same model, have sort of migrated to mean "developed" and "less developed".)
- cantankerous 13y agoThat's to say, the second world referred to the Soviet Union and the Warsaw Pact nations. None of which really exist in that form any more. Being from Australia/Canada, the OP was still part of the First World by the old nomenclature.
- JPKab 13y agoYou have just nailed it. I used to work construction in western North Carolina. The large crews paid far, far less than the crew I worked on. Nobody who didn't live in a home where all the bedrooms were shared could make a living on the wages offered by these large crews. The big argument is whether the cost savings passed onto the people buying the homes (construction is a notoriously low margin business) benefit the economy more/less than the wage reductions for the people building them. In this part of the country, the homes were huge mansions for the 1%ers. I doubt it is a net gain for the economy, and certainly results in neighborhoods where there are not-quite developed world living conditions. But what about produce? American born citizens are not willing to pick produce for the wages currently offered, so farmers turn to illegal immigrants. (Why pick vegetables all day when McDonalds pays more per hour?) If farmers were forced to use Americans, they would have to pay significantly more per hour in wages. This cost would be passed on to consumers. Not sure how much more tomatoes would cost in this scenario, but it would be more. Personally, I think I'd rather have significantly higher wages for a larger portion of the population combined with marginally higher prices for a huge portion of the population, rather than the opposite, which is in effect the WalMart model. When money gets concentrated into a smaller and smaller percentage of the population, you start to get similar effects to a Soviet style planned economy. Rich idiots who delegate management of their money to the Morgan Stanleys of the world, while the working classes can't make enough to start a savings account and maybe start a business one day.
- rayiner 13y agoThe idea that increased labor costs would be passed onto consumers glosses over the relevant economics. In reality, the increased labor costs will result in both increased prices and decreased corporate profits, with the precise split being determined by demand elasticity. And even to the extent that increased labor costs are passed onto consumers, we have to ask ourselves: what does the economy need? Cheaper products or better-paying jobs?
- gdilla 13y agoDrucker famously said that the price of something has nothing to do with it's cost. The market doesn't care how inefficient you are at picking tomatoes. The fact is, you'll be out of business because there will be other farms that can and will get cheap pickers. Also, consumers idea of a fair price of tomatoes does not factor in how much it cost to pick and ship, as is true with anything they buy.
- Jayschwa 13y ago> I personally think the idea of bringing in foreign labor is a very bad thing for the sponsoring country. [...] They can't work anywhere else, and if they quit they are deported. It sounds like a vicious cycle: Immigration is bad -> Limit immigrants or deport them on a hair trigger -> Employers leverage/exploit the circumstances -> Bad results -> Immigration is bad.
- grecy 13y agoI'm not saying immigration is bad, at all. I'm saying that bringing in foreign labor to keep wages low and therefore manipulate the local market to increase corporate profits is bad. Very bad. Where I live, there can be a genuine shortage of labor (i.e. there are just not enough people living up here to do all the jobs - it is -40 in the winter after all) So in that case, it makes sense to try and recruit from within Canada, at a wage that Canadians are willing to do the job for ($14-$18/hr. right now). If you still can't get enough people at that, then go to immigration, but critically, you MUST pay them the $14-$18/hr. The controls and rules around how much immigrants are being paid are extremely lax, and in my experience, are grossly exploited in the very vast majority of cases, because it leads to higher corporate profits, which at the end of the day is the goal of all this anyway.
- acchow 13y agoProduction and employment is a not a zero-sum game.
- GhotiFish 13y agoI think I've being unconsciously viewing it as such, and I think that's almost the way our culture treats it. It's strange, the more productive we get as a society, the more unbalanced we become, as if there's less to go around. Shouldn't we reach a point where people are on average working 4 hours a day instead of 8?
- zeteo 13y ago>I'm an Australian who recently became a Canadian Permanent Resident using a "sponsorship" process [...] Make no mistake about it, bringing in foreigners lowers the quality of life for the original citizens, and only helps increase corporate profits. Beyond the hypocritical aspects of your argument ("the ladder I used is too easy to climb, take it away now"), you're also leaving out a few minor benefits that accrue to "original" citizens in your scenario: 1. Increased profits help shareholders. 2. Profits are subject to tax, and increased tax receipts fund more public programs. 3. Lower costs are at least partially passed to customers. So it's not as simplistic as you make it sound. Also maybe it's just me, but saying things like "those foreigners live 20 to a house" sounds rather xenophobic.
- grecy 13y ago> Beyond the hypocritical aspects of your argument ("this ladder I used is too easy to climb, take it away now"), Absolutely, no doubt. I'm very aware that's what I am saying, but yes, that is what I am saying. (hence the don't bite the hand that feeds me comment) > 1. Increased profits help shareholders. So the rich people get richer. Not what the world needs. > 2. Profits are subject to tax, and increased tax receipts fund more public programs. Not for the big companies that get around it with off-shore stuff (apple, google, walmart, etc. etc.) > 3. Lower costs are at least partially passed to customers. Do we need more cheap stuff (Walmart) or higher paying jobs for everyone? > Also maybe it's just me, but saying things like "those foreigners live 20 to a house" sounds rather xenophobic. I agree it does, but the fact is it's true. Being an immigrant here myself, I go to the weekly immigrant social night, and tons of my friends are those '20 to a house' people I speak of. The cost of living up here is so high it's impossible to live on $10/hr., which is why no Canadian will do the job and where this mess comes from. The truth hurts sometimes.
- bqe 13y agoWho are you to decide what the world does and does not need? This is a very complicated issue and it's not useful to speak in such sweeping generalizations.
- 13y ago