4 ms·
I reject moral relativism. I have no problem saying "The government shouldn't be able to kill you and your family when you complain about them in public." As y
by jerf 17y ago
I reject moral relativism. I have no problem saying "The government shouldn't be able to kill you and your family when you complain about them in public."
As you might imagine, I'm rather familiar with the arguments in favor of moral relativism, but I can't quite seem to forget that they are, in part, an argument that it's ok for some governments to kill people who disagree with them, merely because they disagree with them. It makes me worry that perhaps someday they'll get around to telling me that now my government is one of the privileged governments.
So, even if I'm perhaps stretching the truth about my private beliefs, in public, I'm going to stand up and say that free speech is a right of all humans without shame.
(BTW, there's a number of subsets in here. I am aware that free speech is not the sum total of morality, for instance. Moreover, you'll find that my morality is permitted to be more complicated than you might think; an absolutist can freely incorporate relativism when desirable, whereas a true relativist can't let even one absolute in or the whole thing comes down and they are back on absolutist grounds. The moral question of "how much respect should be shown for elders?" is much more flexible than "can you murder someone for arbitrary reasons?".)
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoI don't think he's arguing in favor of moral relativism so much as saying that we need to remember when dealing with other cultures that they don't have the same set of expectations as us. One of the reasons we are so anti-censorship is because there is a strong tradition of anti-censorship in the US. As much as we like to think we are inherently moral, the truth is that a lot of it does stem from culture. This isn't to say that anti censorship isn't objectively good. Just that we don't necessarily support it merely because it is objectively good. So you may get weird responses when you transplant such a value to a culture that has thousands of years of history where the issue of censorship was never really important. When you say censorship is bad to another westerner you are signaling a value and you expect a certain response. Your communication is predicated on a shared set of connotations. If you forget that others might not share your connotations and forget to argue from the ground up you might run into problems.
- endtime 17y ago>As much as we like to think we are inherently moral, the truth is that a lot of it does stem from culture. These aren't exclusive. You're both right. Moral norms are influenced by culture, but that doesn't mean that some cultures can't have moral norms closer to an absolute morality.