4 ms·
Having lived in east Asia, I have to disagree with the idea that the government censoring news media is without harmful effect. Restriction of free speech has t
by tokenadult 17y ago
Having lived in east Asia, I have to disagree with the idea that the government censoring news media is without harmful effect. Restriction of free speech has the effect of keeping lousy governance lasting longer than it lasts in culturally similar places with more free speech. That, in turn, effects environmental pollution, rights of the accused in criminal trials (including show trials for political prisoners), the business climate for start-up investors, and even the availability of websites like this.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- bilbo0s 17y agoIs free speech restricted in the United States? Because we have had pretty lousy government the past 25 years or so. Culminating in the late financial system coup de grace. My point is that the issue of free speech does not seem to be related to the probability of having poor governance. And this is coming from a person who was a pretty big believer in free speech being a guarantor of good governance. On a related note, a story from Ningbo. This is a small place, about 2.5 million people south of Shanghai. If China has an Austin-Berkeley-Madison feel city, this is probably it. Anyway, the police chase down a guy for theft and the guy made a such a big stink about it that a crowd couldn't help but to watch. He protested, vehemently, that the police were brutalizing him. My Mandarin is good enough to understand that he also had some choice words about their collective character. Finally, he demanded to speak to his attorney. What struck me was this . . . the guy never said "there's about to be a gross miscarriage of justice!", or "You have the wrong man!", or "I didn't do it!" He said the police were brutal and he wanted his lawyer. That spoke volumes to me about the rights of the individual in China. It was my ah-hah! moment. I felt like the young Michael Corleone in the Godfather II. Realizing Fidel would win, after watching a confrontation in Havana between a group of rebels and Batista's army. The people of China will be fine. Maybe there are some wrinkles to iron out here or there, but if criminals feel free enough to cry "police brutality!" and "I want my lawyer!" when they get arrested, you're probably doing ok.
- Nwallins 17y ago> My point is that the issue of free speech does not seem to be related to the probability of having poor governance. And this is coming from a person who was a pretty big believer in free speech being a guarantor of good governance. I think it is rather that: free speech is a check against bad governance.