6 ms·
How Not to Hire
- dpanah 13y agoTop notch!
- moron4hire 13y agothanks!
- jlebron2 13y ago> That could be 15 years of hiding behind far more competent teammates at a company that has a pathological problem with not firing under-performers Funny that you mention that. It turns out it costs the company a pretty penny to replace "under-performers" so they just keep them around instead. http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/labor/report/2012/11/16/44464/there-are-significant-business-costs-to-replacing-employees/ http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/labor/report/2012/11/...
- moron4hire 13y agoThis doesn't seem to account for anti-productivity at all, i.e. people who create more work by the end of the day than they complete. It's hard to quantify anti-productivity, let along get anyone reviewing work to admit that anti-productivity has occurred. Our work culture tends to value activity over all else, so the common sentiment is that a warm butt in the chair is better than nothing, even if that warm butt is making more work for everyone else. I'm hoping that my method will actually ameliorate much of this. By starting the person part-time, perhaps their familiarity with the project builds "faster" over a unit-work-time than it would otherwise (I've personally found my comfort level with a project to be in some part a function of calendar time). In this way, I'm also not spending a lot on the candidate search itself. The idea is to spend less time on much-higher-yield methods of finding people who are better suited to the job crossed with people who are happier with the environment of the job. It is about avoiding turn-over, but not in this perverse way of "ignore the problem because the alternative is worse", but by trying to avoid the hiring of a bad worker in the first place. In this system, you'll never see a job notice from me. You won't know I have a need for an employee unless I ask you to come work for/with me. You'll only ever get a job offer from me if A) I know you're not an idiot, and B) I know you're available. Yes, that means I have to know the person very well already. If I have an opening that needs to be filled and I don't currently know of someone that fills it, then it is likely to be a long time before it gets filled, if I do nothing. But then again, it's not like sifting through resumes is providing quality applicants. The resume and job interview are so poor of a selection process that I'm willing to try just about anything else. There is also an element of respect for the worker involved in what I'm doing. I don't think I have a right to monopolize a person's time. I think people should have the time to be engaged in many pursuits. I want it to be up to them to choose how much they work. I want them to have the ability to find other work as well. The idea being, people who are happier in their work-life balance will be more productive. Of course, we'll see.
- busterarm 13y agoMuch respect for what you're doing. I think this is exactly the right approach to take. I might be willing to take a little bit more risk than you would but I'm also a lot more willing to fire people early (see here: http://www.defmacro.org/2013/07/10/firing.html http://www.defmacro.org/2013/07/10/firing.html) So many companies and their HR departments desire to just fill seats for the short term needs of the company rather than invest in efficiency and protect the long-term needs of the business.
- jlebron2 13y agoGreat points, I definitely agree. Anti-productivity of one employee can become a plague and affect numerous employees and the resume and job interview process is indeed broken. Good luck with your system and look forward to hearing how it turns out.
- muhuk 13y agoSpot on. Job boards need to fail more than they successfully place people, so that employers and job seekers keep trying. Similarly it's not in the dating sites best interest if everybody finds their soul mate. They need losers. Losers with money to spend. Same is true with your personal trainer in the gym, she/he only wants you to keep training safely and continuously. In all these examples the incentives with the primary actors and the middlemen doesn't align.
- robotcookies 13y agoCan anyone else verify the '2 out of 600 applicants could actually do the job' statement. I've heard something like 1 in 100 but I just can't believe numbers like these.
- sokoloff 13y agoSadly, it's more true than you can probably imagine. Realize though, that the pool of people actively applying to jobs is, on average, FAR worse than the total population. Even companies who are pretty bad at hiring can make some kind of selection for quality, and great engineers get fired way less than terrible engineers, so in theory, the very worst engineers in the world would continually apply for jobs and never be hired, or would be quickly fired. My experience suggests that it's very rare to get a superstar from any passive method (that finds active job seekers). That pool is just to dilute with talent. To get the strong candidates, you have to be active (to have a shot at the passive candidates) or extremely lucky. It's no surprise to find only 1 in 100 of unemployed engineers are truly good. If you just post openings, you're unlikely to interview even a representative sample of the population, let alone an above-average sample.
- kunil 13y agoIf that is true, I can relate the HR or hiring people. It must be bad when majority of applicants are not suitable to job at all. ~2 months ago I started searching for a new job. I only applied that actually suits to me and I am capable. I only applied 3 places and all interviewed me, in the end I got 2 offers (I am starting next week!). I guess that is just me.
- sokoloff 13y agoThat's not surprising to me (that you got offers from 2 of 3). Congrats on the new role, and have confidence that if it turns out not to be to your liking, that you have options. You're likely to go 2-for-3 in your next job search as well; it probably wasn't random/dumb luck; you're a bigger/better fish in that pond than you probably think...
- 13y ago
- jackschultz 13y agoI'm currently in the job hunting situation out of college and, along with sending out resumes, I'm working on a bunch of different side projects to try to show that I can a) actually execute, and b) learn new things. Not sure if it's the best way to work on getting hired, but I don't want to practice "interview questions". I know I don't do as well in interview because of my lack of specific preparation, but I feel like I'd be a better candidate than someone who just prepares for an interview. Curious to see how that might affect potential employers.
- vinceguidry 13y agoYou don't need to "show" that you can learn new things, you just need to learn new things. And keep doing it. At first you have to do it on your own, but eventually you'll get paid to do it. The biggest trick to getting there is inspiration. You need to be excited about the possibilities. You'll get ten times farther in an interview if you can enthusiastically tell your interviewer how much fun you're having with Angular.js. Or that project that kept you up til 3am because you just couldn't put it down. You need to stop looking at your career as some set of criteria you have to fill and start looking at it as the most fun you're going to have, like ever. Seriously, building shit is fun.
- jackschultz 13y agoI think you have to show that you can learn new things. How else can someone justify hiring someone if they haven't demonstrated that they're capable of picking up a new piece of technology? I was trying to say that I wanted to show my value by producing actual things rather than being able to write code on paper. It's also funny that you mentioned Angular since I wrote launched a little app using it today.
- vinceguidry 13y ago> How else can someone justify hiring someone if they haven't demonstrated that they're capable of picking up a new piece of technology? Demonstrations are nice, but you're generally not going to get the chance to. I interviewed four times in the past year for jobs and got three offers, and I'd have gotten an offer on the fourth if I'd shown more interest in the position. The people interviewing me never took more than a glancing look at my portfolio website. I've never written code on paper. I've never had to live code. It's only very few pure-software shops that do things like that. Chances are you'll be interviewing at banks, or marketing companies, or at any of the vast majority of coding jobs that aren't supporting businesses in the technology sector. The people that run these businesses don't care half as much about technical chops. They do want to know if you can do your job, but in the non-technology world, attitude is more important.
- polemic 13y ago> "He will know exactly what I charge the client and what I give to him out of that." In my experience this is exactly how traditional engineering firms work. It seems to work for them, I'm not sure why a software consultancy would work differently. Do they? Regardless, if you give people the power to manage their work, to bill their clients appropriately, to take ownership for the work, then the right people will thrive and the rest will find it far too transparent to hide behind.
- ams6110 13y agoI've worked as an employee of a consultancy a few different times, and I've never been informed about the rates at which I was billed to clients.
- moron4hire 13y agoYes, neither have I. On a few occasions, I accidentally stumbled on the numbers and was quite shocked to see that it was whole-number multiples over what I earned. Large, whole-numbers. Especially on government contracts.
- busterarm 13y agoPretty much always this. I don't think I've ever seen that multiplier been less than 4x.
- polemic 13y agoAFAIK 2.5% - 4% is about normal. A lot of that goes into marketing, bidding on projects, etc. It's not actually that shocking when you look at where the cost goes: it's not just "your time * multiplier", more like "how many hours of other work are required to support one hour of actual work".
- moron4hire 13y agoNo, I get the need, as you described it, but one place was charging 1000%.
- educating 13y ago> So we will see. This could be a complete failure... There you go guarding yourself from a possible bad decision. The trick in hiring is to trust your gut. Your gut might be wrong, but it is often better than everything else. A simple up, down, or sideways (which is usually down) vote by the interviewers without having to give a reason is much better than trying to rationalize and enumerate the pros and cons. It isn't perfect, because an interviewer could be a racist, sexist, etc. but the cultural fit is much more important than what is on paper to hire and it is hard to judge much else during the interview, other than the ability to interview well. I'm a big fan of the 90-day trial period. If the person coming in knows right away it is a bad fit, they'll be looking for a job right away to avoid being laid off on the 90th day.