3 ms·
I hope this works, but I'm skeptical for 3 reasons: Reliability: I've seen so many broken home buttons, they need to solve this problem otherwise many people w
by danpalmer 13y ago
I hope this works, but I'm skeptical for 3 reasons:
Reliability: I've seen so many broken home buttons, they need to solve this problem otherwise many people won't be able to use it, and many will be put off from using it. Also, what's the false-positive ratio, what's the false-negative ratio?
Security: traditionally fingerprint sensors have been pretty terrible at security given a photocopier and a few bits and pieces. You wouldn't need 10 attempts to get into the phone, you could theoretically get it in 1 if you have the expertise. A passcode on the other hand, you have a much lower chance of guessing that within 10 tries before a wipe. Also false matches are clearly an issue here too.
Practicality: This is a combination of reliability and security, but also a few other things. Siri takes ~1 minute to respond to my queries, I don't believe this makes network requests, but if it has a big performance problem or something similar, people won't use it. If my phone takes more than 3 seconds to unlock with a passcode it annoys me.
- rimantas 13y ago> Reliability: I've seen so many broken home buttons Have you seen any on iPhone5? That was mainly iPhone 4's problem, iirc. > A passcode on the other hand, you have a much lower chance of > guessing that within 10 tries And peeking 4 digits passcode is even easier. Also, this scanner may be a bit more sophisticated. > If my phone takes more than 3 seconds to unlock with a passcode it annoys me. It's all in hardware. And that's iPhone 5S' hardware, 64bit and all.
- danpalmer 13y ago> Have you seen any on iPhone5? That was mainly iPhone 4's problem, iirc. Fewer, but still yes. > And peeking 4 digits passcode is even easier. Also, this scanner may be a bit more sophisticated. Very true, I'm looking at this less from a position of preventing a friend from fraping you, and more from a business security standpoint where you would hopefully shield a passcode, and probably use a longer alphanumeric one anyway. Not sure that a fingerprint beats that. > It's all in hardware. And that's iPhone 5S' hardware, 64bit and all. Of course, I don't think performance will be the issue, but I'm just hoping that there isn't an issue with practicality. So many of Apple's things are good in theory, and not usable in practice, at least for me. (iCloud CoreData sync, Photo Stream, Siri, AirPlay, FaceTime...).