4 ms·
Sometimes, yes. But there are a lot of services where you do need an account to try it at all -- how are you going to try out Mint, or Duolingo, or Path, or OkC
by crazygringo 13y ago
Sometimes, yes. But there are a lot of services where you do need an account to try it at all -- how are you going to try out Mint, or Duolingo, or Path, or OkCupid, without creating an account first?
Obviously you can create "dummy accounts", but they often won't actually give a decent idea of the site's experience (browsing profiles on OkCupid doesn't give you anywhere near the experience of having people message you), and then how is the person going to convert their dummy account into a real one later on, if they never even put in their e-mail or password?
There are certainly plenty of times when sites go overboard in asking too much of you up-front, but it's not always the case.
- fonziguy 13y agoAbsolutely. I think Chartbeat does a good job of showing you the product before signing up https://chartbeat.com/demo https://chartbeat.com/demo and also https://www.intercom.io/ https://www.intercom.io/ have a great gradual engagement flow (where they actually need data to work effectively).
- dredmorbius 13y agoI can think of examples of most of those or similar services where either anonymous or test-account demos were available. Which is also, incidentally, a good way to test/check your own code.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tedsanders 13y agoActually, I think OkCupid would be a good candidate for gradual engagement. Letting you browse profiles before creating an account could make it easier to see what sort of people are on the site, what sort of work you'll have to do to write a profile, and generally set your expectations for what it's like to have an account there.
- jmtame 13y agoFor this to work, you'd have to let your users opt-in to making their profiles public. Nothing stops a search engine crawler at this stage from caching everything, and most dating site users want their privacy. I don't think this would work.
- smtddr 13y agoMost(not all) search engine crawlers seem to obey robots.txt's "Disallow: /" in my experience. But beyond that, maybe the preview mode of the site should be done in a way to make crawlers/webscrapers return worthless results. Like make the no-sign-up site not work without javascript or constantly request captchas with annoying frequency. For a dating site, I'd assume no-sign-up mode shouldn't show any detail about the signed-up people beyond city/state, age & profile-picture.
- darkstar999 13y ago> constantly request captchas with annoying frequency That's an anti-pattern that would annoy me more than the few minutes it would take to create an account.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jaredsohn 13y agoLike this? http://www.okcupid.com/online-dating/san-francisco/california/ http://www.okcupid.com/online-dating/san-francisco/californi... I just don't see it linked to for people who visit the site without accounts. (A user has the option of making their profile public or private.) I've heard they are working on a site redesign, though, so maybe it will show up then.
- crucialfelix 13y agoFemales do not want their dating profiles visible by anybody except genuinely intersted and verified visitors. A major part of ok cupids system is that it tracks views and informs the people WHO checked you out. The other dynamic is that people are shy and they need to be pushed to set up a visible profile quickly before they lose confidence. At that point they are contactable and datable. So no guest mode for OK Cupid.
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoMint could let you use a couple calculators, you'd just have to enter all the information each time. Duolingo could let you do a lesson before signing up. OkCupid could let you browse a limited number of profiles - it's better than nothing, and certainly useful in giving you an idea of the clientele.
- daemin 13y agoThe problem with having gradual engagement in something like OkCupid would be that the threat of a scammy bait and switch happening to you. For instance you'd be browsing the limited (curated / highest voted) list of people in your area, and then when you go to sign up they are no longer there or unavailable.
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoGiven how much word-of-mouth business they must get, I'd hope that there would be strong disincentives against scumminess of that sort.