4 ms·
Is the best strategy here to leave your devices at home and just bring a burner phone on holiday or other travels and no other devices? It's strange as an ordi
by grey-area 13y ago
Is the best strategy here to leave your devices at home and just bring a burner phone on holiday or other travels and no other devices?
It's strange as an ordinary citizen who might choose to contribute to someone like Manning's defence fund, or post statements supportive of Snowden online, to have to consider that GCHQ or the Homeland Security might put your name on a list for questioning and confiscation at the border, requiring drastic action like this.
Given the abuse of them in many countries including the US and UK (which was inevitable), I can't see any case for these powers of arbitrary detainment and confiscation to be given to the police in any country.
- TheCraiggers 13y agoI leave mine behind whenever I travel outside the US, not so much because I am afraid to be on a list (although after reading this article, that fear has risen somewhat) but because I employ encryption on my laptop. If they do search my device for anything illegal, they will inevitably ask for my password, which I don't want to give for philosophical reasons. Then it's pretty much guaranteed that I'll be detained and/or my laptop will be taken. You are right that, as a US citizen, this is a very strange revelation to have when packing for an overseas trip. Personally, this very real possibility opened my eyes on just how far we've fallen.
- m_ram 13y ago"I don't remember my password."
- jlgreco 13y agoThat is when they detain/harass him and steal his computer anyway.
- andrewpi 13y agoAnd probably use the NSA backdoor to peek at the hard drive, right?
- grey-area 13y agoIt's illegal not to provide your password in the UK, not sure what the rules are under these special powers in the US.
- notdrunkatall 13y agoThe more I read about the laws in the UK, the more I appreciate the laws in the USA. We don't have everything right, but at least our system is rooted in the notion of the sanctity of individual rights. Or was.
- aqme28 13y agoIIRC the 5th amendment allows you to not divulge your password, unless they can prove that there is illegal content .
- haakon 13y agoWhat if you genuinely don't remember your password? Is it in effect memory loss that's been made illegal?
- aplusbi 13y agoThen change your password to something that you don't actually know. Generate a random password before your trip and print out a few copies. Take one with you and secure the remaining ones. Before you fly through the UK, change the password on your computer to the random one and destroy the printout. When you get back home use the remaining printouts to change your password back and then destroy them.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoAt this point, why are you even bringing your computer along, if you have no way to log into it?
- aplusbi 13y agoThis obviously depends on your travel plans. For the US, for example, CBP can only search your belongings on entry into the US. If you are traveling from the US -> wherever -> US then you only need to secure your laptop for your return flight.
- w1ntermute 13y agohttp://xkcd.com/538/ http://xkcd.com/538/
- ensignavenger 13y agoLook into Hidden Volume technology. Then you can give them the "password" and they can look around all they want.
- TheCraiggers 13y agoI have. However, my fear is that it will either not work when it's needed, or that they may have some manner of technology that allows them to scan for such things, or possibly the footprints left behind by such software, or logging them into an OS that looks like a fresh install might be enough to illicit some suspicion. Politely declining to share your password is within your rights at the US border. However, giving them a "fake" password seems like it may be a crime. And even if it's not, it will certainly get you detained and your laptop taken. Thankfully, I don't need my laptop that much when traveling overseas and my stupid non-global Verizon phone won't work anyway. Much safer to leave it behind.
- rosser 13y agoYou aren't giving them a "fake" password, you're just not giving them all of your passwords.
- TheCraiggers 13y agoThe point is you might still be considered to be interfering with the investigation, should they find out. Everything I've ever read about topic stresses that you should be absolutely truthful with a border officer. At least in the US, lying to one is a serious offense. Your post encourages hiding behind semantics and technicalities- and while those might save you in a courtroom (if you have a good lawyer), they won't save you when you're face to face with an angry border agent who just discovered your ruse. Again, this is why I don't use this method. It didn't work on my parents when I was a kid, and I don't think it will work in this case either.
- ensignavenger 13y agoI understand- the software behind hidden volumes is relatively new. I think this is an area the open source/security community should really put some effort behind. It is recommended that you use the regular non-hidden volume OS for trivial tasks frequently to make it a normal OS. If you do this, you are giving them your password. You just use a differnet password and a hidden volume for all of your private stuff. Leaving it behind works as well, if that is acceptable to you! And is probably the most secure thing. :)
- notaddicted 13y agoCarrying a burner is itself also suspicious -- the safest course it to be as normal as possible which means having a regular computer/phone with some stuff on it, or nothing. Also, it isn't sufficient to focus the the border policies for re-entry to your own country, you also have to consider every country you would travel to, all of which have their own laws, all of which can change at any moment, even while you are in transit. Carrying around "sensitive" data, along with the password (which is in your brain, thus you are carrying it) is just overall a really bad idea.
- wiredfool 13y agoIt's not a "burner" phone, it's an "international quad band unlocked" phone for local sims.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]