3 ms·
It's possible someone could've - just the diff in itself was fishy, because it commented out two lines which added entropy, yet it was obvious from the diff alo
by makomk 13y ago
It's possible someone could've - just the diff in itself was fishy, because it commented out two lines which added entropy, yet it was obvious from the diff alone that that the OpenSSL developers only thought one of them should be disabled to keep memory checkers happy.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoBut "could have" is the theoretical defence. "Did" (or rather "didn't") is the real world test. This is the whole point - OSS offers the potential to be safer but if there aren't qualified people with the skills and expertise digging into every nook and cranny of every bit of code. Ironically it's like the security services say - they have to win every time to win, the terrorists only have to win once. The community have to spot and fix every exploit to secure the system, the NSA only have to get one in to compromise it - and these aren't like accidental flaws, they're things the NSA will know are there, know the extent of and know precisely how to take advantage of them.
- jedbrown 13y agoThis is an argument for vanilla distributions. The most sensible place for expert code review (a limited resource) is the upstream project. By comparison, distro modifications receive relatively little review. If the Debian patch had been mailed to openssl-dev, I doubt it would have quietly gotten "LGTM" replies and been picked up by a maintainer.