6 ms·
A licenced money transmitter can handle Bitcoins only if they handle them in a rather non-bitcoin-ish way - i.e., if the participants are not anonymous, and fra
by PeterisP 13y ago
A licenced money transmitter can handle Bitcoins only if they handle them in a rather non-bitcoin-ish way - i.e., if the participants are not anonymous, and fraudulent transactions can be reversed.
This can be done - bitcoin itself doesn't provide these features technically, but it can be done by paypal; the question is why would they - it probably is less profitable than their current transactions.
- rlpb 13y ago> ...and fraudulent transactions can be reversed. Is this strictly true? What do foreign currency exchanges and Western Union do?
- walden42 13y agoWire transfers aren't reversible.
- oleganza 13y agoWire transfers are harder to reverse than paypal or CC, but they are still based on mere agreement between banks. Bitcoin-central.net exchange had some fraud instances when wires were actually reversed after withdrawing BTC. Only two things are irreversible for real: 1. When you take a tangible thing in your own hands and go away. This can only be "reversed" by another party running after you. 2. Bitcoin transaction. See also: http://www.quora.com/Wire-Transfers/Can-wire-transfers-be-reversed http://www.quora.com/Wire-Transfers/Can-wire-transfers-be-re...
- maxerickson 13y agoThe bitcoin network can conspire to reverse a transaction. The accidental block chain fork demonstrated that the plurality of participants will do so when it is convenient for them.
- oleganza 13y agoThe accidental fork in March demonstrated that all transactions were included in both chains. One guy attempted a double-spend attack against OKPay (but then returned money). Only people who could have been hurt are those accepting transaction during the fork. Everyone else's money was just fine. Everyone should simply listen for alerts and simply stop trusting new transactions until the fork is resolved. To reverse some old transaction would require enormous amount of computing power and some serious motive. It's not even close to two banks disputing a wire transfer between each other.
- PeterisP 13y agoFraudulent wire transfers are "reversible" in the sense that in many jurisdictions the bank has to take the loss (i.e., return money to sender but not get it back from receiver) even if they can't reverse/block the payment. So from consumer's perspective they're reversible as they get their money back. I've worked in banking on international payments; they aren't reversible in the sense that (a) it's not always possible to do so; (b) there's no well-agreed way to do it, (c) the administrative fees of everyone involved can be quite large and (d) you can't guarantee anything; but in practice we could reverse most of international transactions if a day or two has passed (while money is "in transit", so to speak), and occasionally even long after it's been credited to beneficiary. Of course, there have to be valid reasons, but it can be done.
- anologwintermut 13y agoBitcoin is not anonymous. Maybe if ran through mixes, but other wise transactions are public and linkable. In fact, if it were anonymous, you wouldn't care as much about interacting with a money transmitter since they'd only learn that you had money, not where it came from or was going. As to fraud. No, a licensed money transmitter doesn't have to allow charge backs (as far as I know western union doesn't), it's just that it's a competitive advantage for customers if they do.
- PeterisP 13y ago"Public and linkable" transactions are not enough - typical mandatory 'know your customer' regulations would require a proper ID of your customer (not, say, an email+alias); and some indication of who the other party is - enough to identify a specific person/company. Plus you'd need a reasonable (externally audited) process to identify which of your customers are lying about their IDs or the beneficiary names and stop dealing with such customers - so you can't just put some small print and ignore violations. Western Union doesn't have to allow chargebacks in the creditcard meaning (where USA laws allow chargeback for even ridiculous reasons IMHO); but if, say, credentials of some EU citizen are stolen and fraudulent payments made, then Western Union would need to return most of the money even if they can't reverse it.