4 ms·
Daniel Kahneman's "Thinking, Fast and Slow" doesn't get the mention it deserves; it's alluded to, together with an interview of the author, and then back to "Bl
by bambax 13y ago
Daniel Kahneman's "Thinking, Fast and Slow" doesn't get the mention it deserves; it's alluded to, together with an interview of the author, and then back to "Blink".
But if you're interested in these subjects, Kahneman is a much better read than Gladwell, if only because he did most of the research himself (and got a Nobel for his efforts).
One takeaway is that so-called "System 1", the intuitive, immediate and "blinking" operating mode of our brain is usually super-effective, but takes shortcuts that can can result in flawed conclusions. Those shortcuts are consistent and can be highlighted by research.
"System 2" is the slow, rational operating mode where we analyze and weight all available evidence; System 2 is expensive to operate and takes a long time to produce results, so for most tasks it usually doesn't even start.
One example from the book that struck me is the famous observation that 90% of people think of themselves as "above average" in driving ability. This is usually quoted to show that people think highly of themselves.
But when asked a different question, such as, for example, "do you think you're above average or below average in your ability to initiate a conversation with a complete stranger", a great majority of people evaluate themselves as "below average".
The actual explanation has nothing to do with self-esteem; it's just a "System 1 shortcut". Answering the question of how one's ability relates to the "average" performance is extremely difficult (for a start, it would imply measuring said average). So what System 1 does, it substitutes a simple question to the difficult one.
System 1 doesn't even attempt to answer the initial question; it changes the question to "am I good or bad at this task". Most people think they are okay drivers, and most people think they're not good at starting a conversation with a complete stranger, hence the answers.
The relation to the average that was part of the original question has disappeared.
The problem is that the substitution is silent and unconscious, and that we still think we're answering the initial question when in fact we are not.
- VLM 13y ago>But when asked a different question, such as, for example, "do you think you're above average or below average in your ability to initiate a conversation with a complete stranger", a great majority of people evaluate themselves as "below average". >The actual explanation has nothing to do with self-esteem This is a bad selection of questions for a conclusion that may none the less be true, because a stranger is the one bugging them for an answer. The short, polite, version of my response is "below average". The longer version would be something like "that is the worst pickup line I've ever heard and I'm married anyway, now go away I don't talk to strangers with weird pickup lines". Claiming to have a talent and refusing to express it by continuing the conversation would be considered pretty rude, its more polite just to blow off the questioner and claim not to be an expert. I do this with home computer stuff all the time. Sorry, I don't have a computer like yours I mostly work on bigger business related stuff so I don't know which key is the "any key". Oh you have yet another virus, I'd love to spend the next eight hours trying to remove it and giving up and reinstalling everything, but I unfortunately don't know how, so just buy a mac next time, mkay? What computer should I buy, well I don't know anything about that other than you should get a mac; why yes, I don't have any personal mac experience at all; so that won't be any problem (for me).