7 ms·
Playing devil's advocate, isn't it fair to remove the ability to discharge student loan debt and in term the default risk due to the fact that there is no colla
by slg 13y ago
Playing devil's advocate, isn't it fair to remove the ability to discharge student loan debt and in term the default risk due to the fact that there is no collateral? Unlike a car loan or a mortgage, a bank can't repossess your education.
- nether 13y agoNot really when other types of unsecured debt are wiped out by bankruptcy. Your credit card debt can be erased by chapter 7 bankruptcy even if you used it to fund an awesome vacation that no one can take back.
- sliverstorm 13y agoYes, but a credit card requires credit. Student loans are specifically crafted to be obtainable by people with no income and no credit.
- RougeFemme 13y agoI know the credit cards companies have cut back on this, but. . .credit cards for students don't require credit. . .and are specifically crafted to be obtainable by students with no income or credit. Students with income and/or credit can get better deals with "non-student" credit cards.
- jlgreco 13y agoI believe that the Credit CARD Act of 2009 changed much of that. IIRC if you are a student with no income then you need to give them a collateral the size of your credit limit.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIndeed, and when I was a student I got my first credit card with a modest job (< $10k). What was my initial credit limit? $400.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoIt is pretty impossible and probably unreasonable to expect your average college freshmen to have a good credit rating.
- sliverstorm 13y agoNo one expects them to. The point is the credit card company accepts the risk of default on no-collateral loans in part because they have confidence (credit report) in the chances of being paid back, while a student typically has no such supporting evidence to back their case.
- lmartel 13y agoI'm a college student. I have two credit cards with credit limits of $500 and $1700. My tuition (with room and board) is $58,000 per year. That's the difference.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoThose cards generate lots of fees. How can the CC have confidence in the credit report when they issue cards to people with virtually no credit. They are wildcatting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcatter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcatter
- sliverstorm 13y agoRight, but just imagine the fees you'd need to establish on student loans to wildcat them! Late billing fee: $10,000 Processing fee: $1,500 (Etc)
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoAre you assuming that every college student who is issued a $600 credit limit is a deadbeat? I don't think that's the case. edit: My point in the post above was simply that _if_ it is possible on average for an 18 year old to have a 'good' credit rating, _then_ credit ratings are practically without meaning.
- jlgreco 13y agoI assume a bank cannot reposes my liver either. What happens if I go into debt from medical expenses? Is there an exemption for medical debt as well?
- jussij 13y agoFrom what I've read about the US health system, I thought you don't get much in the way of medical treatment unless you have medical insurance. In other word the insurance covers the cost. If that is the case, where is the debt?
- jlgreco 13y agoAll I know is that many people go bankrupt from medical expenses. I don't know the specifics of how they get into that sort of situation. Perhaps it happens when hospitals first treat people, then bill them afterwards.
- Smirnoff 13y agoThey go broke for many reasons: 1. US Healthcare is too expensive. Two weeks after I first came to the states, my wisdom teeth (all 4) started growing. I had to pull them out. That was a $2,000 bill and a good lesson to get insurance asap. If you get into a car accident and you don't have insurance, your bill might be about $25K. More if you need continuous care and more surgeries. 2. Doctors are doing unnecessary tests and operations. Sometimes, I feel like they just want you to test for every single disease with a similar symptom. What a joke. 3. Some patients are stupid. Why on earth do some people need to call ambulance for flu. Even if they don't have a ride, just find it, use a cab, or use a bus if you are that broke. Common sense is like deodorant. People who need it most, never use it.
- bronbron 13y ago> 2. Doctors are doing unnecessary tests and operations. Sometimes, I feel like they just want you to test for every single disease with a similar symptom. What a joke. Probably because you would rightfully have a slam-dunk malpractice suit if they didn't test you for diseases with similar symptoms and missed a diagnosis.
- msandford 13y agoYeah that's a really good point. I'm not sure it really matters, though. The law allowed you to shed college loan debt through bankruptcy up until 1976/1978 and people went to college for at least 100 years prior to that law. Furthermore a cheap college degree might be so inexpensive that the hit to your credit isn't worth the expense dodged. Banks can loan on cars worth as little as $5k even though their cost to repossess and auction it might approach the cost of the car. For small debts the shame factor can't be underestimated. From this what can we conclude? Prior to the change in the law college had to be fairly cheap so that banks could make uncollateralized loans for people to go. Because students could only afford so much, colleges had to figure out how to deliver an education for that amount. If a college wanted to charge more, it had to pull risk out of the loan to the student so that a bank would issue it.
- comicjk 13y ago> people went to college for at least 100 years prior to that law. This is the fallacy of comparing the upper classes of one period with the masses of another. A far smaller fraction of people went to college in the century before 1976, and those who did go from lower-class origins often did so through direct scholarships like the GI bill. The college loan market was not very viable at this time. None other than Milton Friedman discusses the problem in his 1962 book Capitalism and Freedom. Actually, he proposes some form of legally undischargeable debt as a solution.
- msandford 13y agoYeah that's a really good point! I've heard plenty of people talk about working their way through school by having a summer job to pay for room and board and tuition and that it was possible to do it that way, even if it was uncomfortable. That really sounds great but maybe a little bit too great: it's a good narrative about how things were better back in the olden days when things were still good and not fucked up. I WANT to believe it but I'm not sure that I should. And it's all anecdote, no data. I did some searching for pricing and I found this: http://www.collegeview.com/admit/?p=1858 http://www.collegeview.com/admit/?p=1858 It looks like a decent summary. In 1960 the minimum wage was $1.00/hr and the cheapest tuition I'm seeing is $960 for the University of Texas. If you made minimum wage for three months of summer that's a total of 40 * 4 * 3 * $1 = $480 pre-tax. So definitely not enough to pay for a whole year of school from just the summer job. At an Ivy League school you're at about 1/4 of your yearly total. Today if you work a minimum wage job for a whole summer you'd get 40 * 4 * 3 * $7.25 = $3480 (pre-tax of course) which wouldn't even pay for your tuition (nevermind room and board and other expenses, that's another $5k per year at least) at the University of Florida, arguably the best deal in college tuition in the last decade. Comparing it to an Ivy League these days, it's not the 25% it used to be but rather about 10% if you go to one of the cheaper schools.
- RougeFemme 13y agoA lot of credit card debt has no collateral either, but that can be discharged in bankruptcy; why not student loans? And I suppose credit card companies could try to re-possess the goods purchased with credit cards (obviously not the services), but they don't. (And it makes sense not to; not worth it financially). FWIW, I have no student loan debt so I'm relatively neutral on this.
- ChrisBland 13y agoThe issue is at the end of a normal Bankruptcy proceeding, assets are sold to repay the note. Lets say you go out and buy a rental property for $500k, if you never make a payment the bank can repossess the rental property and sell it to recover their loan. Your asset is gone, you have no way of making any kind of income from it after it has been repossessed. With student debt its different, if you went to undergrad at MIT then did an MBA at Standford - you are probably looking at north of $100k in debt. If one year after college you defaulted and it was discharged, you would still retain the 'asset' (your education). You could go out the next day and get a nice job at google and continue to earn income from your asset. The bank has no recourse to prevent you from continuing to use the asset they loaned you money for. This is one of the main reasons that you can't discharge student loan debt. No one is going to come take your degree away from you if you don't pay.
- 001sky 13y agoThis is retarded (pardon my french). Assets are only relevant with respect to security interest held by the lender. Slavery is illegal, and it is not legal to attach security interests to peoples lives. Of course, by making the discharge of debt itself illegal, the lenders have placed their security interests in a default position aking to the states right to tax all future income. Which is a hillarious (although not funny) abdication of government authority in a democracy (as its unaccountable, not to mention opaque and non-transparent).
- noise 13y agoI'm not advocating this, but why couldn't they take your degree away? They can't take your education away, but the degree is just an agreement/contract that says you upheld your part of the bargain - passed tests, etc, and paid the university, and they in turn give you a certificate of achievement. If you default on the loan which was a substantial portion of the payment clause of that contract, why can't they revoke the degree? I realize the loan in these cases is not directly from the university.
- randyrand 13y agonot only that but students usually have negative wealth upon graduation. Declaring bankruptcy is way more attractive than it is supposed to be at that stage.
- consonants 13y agoNo. Also, I believe they can garnish wages and repossess property to pay off loans if it looks like the client won't ever be able to pay the debt back. In carrying out its fiduciary duty the firm that issued the loan came to the conclusion that the person would be reasonably able to pay the loan back with interest. Of course, since the risk of default is off the table with student loans, why not hand out a bunch of money that will get paid back with some accrued interest before it is discharged, if it ever is at all? In a world where fake private schools didn't accelerate the loan bubble, and one that probably treats student loans like any other debt, it would be a different story. Boils down to whether or not they think the prospect of their client finding gainful employment after school is worth taking on the risk of the client defaulting.