4 ms·
I think a counter point (which I don't agree with) might be a question of slippery slopes - and a problem of many rules based systems. They deliberately avoid
by cwan 17y ago
I think a counter point (which I don't agree with) might be a question of slippery slopes - and a problem of many rules based systems. They deliberately avoid allowing for exceptions in an attempt at sending a message to everyone / meeting the needs of the aggregate thinking that it's a true trade off in allowing for individualized approaches/exceptions.
I don't know what the environment is like in Oakland - never been, don't have any reason to think I will, but let's say that it's a very difficult environment, while some of their measures may seem extreme, it's sort of like the broken windows/fences approach to teaching. The thinking would be that by clamping down on the small offences, no one even thinks to commit to the big ones. Personally however, I don't think that that should have been considered an infraction or that it should be considered a broken window.
- smanek 17y agoI don't think it's a school's place to decide what constitutes a legitimate reason to miss school - it should be the parent's prerogative. If the parent says it's alright for a kid to miss a day of school - I really don't think the school should be questioning it.
- jonsen 17y agoI don't think it's a parent's place to decide what constitutes a legitimate reason to attend school - it should be the school's prerogative. If the school says it's imperative for a kid not to miss a day of school - I really don't think the parents should be questioning it.
- smanek 17y agoHeh, I see what you did there. I don't think that holds because society (and the law) hold the parents to be responsible for a child's well being - not the school. With that responsibility also comes the right to make decisions affecting the child's well being. That's why the state (which a public school is an instrument of) doesn't question how a parent raises their child (unless the parent's conduct rises level of abuse, of course).
- jonsen 17y ago;-) Neither point holds. Of course parents are ultimate responsible. But the school parent relationship is better off building on mutual professional respect and a certain division of power. Edit: and a sound amount of questioning from both sides of course.