3 ms·
I am beginning to turn to Praxology: economics is just psychology under conditions of scarcity. Because most discussion on economics and minimum wage is a pea
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
I am beginning to turn to Praxology: economics is just psychology under conditions of scarcity. Because most discussion on economics and minimum wage is a peak behind people's own perceptions and prejudices.
So peak behind my veil. It may not be a coherent argument, but it is trying to form from a different direction I usually see on here.
1. Welfare payments (paying people not to work) are about avoiding the human cost of moving from one equilibria to another. We do not have an ethicall acceptable way to judge if one person is deservedly poor and another is a scrounging parasite. So we pay everyone.
2. Welfare payments are getting really expensive. Partly because of their complexity, partly because we fiddle with it too much.
2.a. Welfare payments act as insurance for society. You have a bad year its not worth forcing you and your family onto the streets.
2.b. Forever welfare payments (benefits scroungers, 13 kids and never had a job etc) may be a reflection of a persons true economic worth. see below
3. Paying everyone a minimum guaranteed income is not so crazy - it is merely a monetary reflection of the value and utility derived from other public goods like medicine, science, roads, clean air. I get a lot of value from these things. The NHS means I don't monetarily pay a US level insurance. So I can put a pretty accurate number on a minimum payment already made to me.
For me the situation now is paying people who are not currently econmically productive enough to survive, and turn into productive citizens. It is messy, it has problems, but for my ethical point of view it beats not having a welfare system and seeing people starve. Thats why we brought it in and thats why we want to keep it.
However we are seeing demographic changes (which is what the article is about) that may well negate a lot of this - more and more human beings, with moral value, may find they are no longer economically in the black.
So we might have a future that is golden, of robots growing food, houses built from nanostructures in days, of the human basics for 10 bn provided for tiny effort or cost.
But getting there is not a clear road. And for my money holding the people who will fail to cross that bridge to the future, and giving them a decent life with the bounty of new productive technologies, is a moral duty. And also a sensible hedge for hubris.
In short, we pay for welfare because it is the right thing to do, it is usually short term for each individual, we might need it personally, and as we transition into a new world, we have no idea how bumpy it will get - so safety nets are a good idea. But is the current system(s) perfect, desirable or sustainable. Almost certainly not, and we shall see wide experimentation with different variations before settling on something similar to Singapore.
But that is a long way off and I am late.
- drcode 13y ago> we pay for welfare because it is the right thing to do Or, it might be "the right thing" to give funds to fight poverty in some other way and welfare is counterproductive. Making such a claim a-priori is the crux of the problem.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoFairy Nuff Perhaps then i should rephrase it as We pay for welfare because protecting the weakest and must vulnerable is the right thing to do and so far history has taught us that market forces can take a generation to come round and Workhouses are inhumane. In short welfare is the economic equivalent of Churchill's "democracy is the worst form of government - apart from all the rest"
- drcode 13y agoAgain, I ask, why do you automatically assume paying for welfare "protects the weak and vulnerable"? If you've ever been to a strong welfare state like any country in Europe, etc, you'd know they also have homeless, broken people, as we see in the US. Where, I ask you, is the evidence that "lots of guaranteed welfare"->"better off poor people"? I'm just saying that by making these a priori assumptions we're arguing past each other- I can't respond to an argument that says "Anyone against welfare is a morally inferior person" because I am not arguing against the moral aspects of welfare, I'm just saying that poverty can't be solved by handing poor people a check every month.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI'm not calling you a morally inferior person (I set a very low bar anyway :-). I agree that "ending poverty" cannot be achieved by handing people a cheque each month. Ending poverty is (or should be) a long term cross governmental policy issue. How it is achieved is an important, possibly the most important question in economics. However "welfare" (note not the purely US term but a wider more European term) is in my view a smaller usually short term provision. IIRC The majority of non-retired welfare recipients recieve help for less than 14 months, and by far the biggest portion of welfare spend goes on retirees. I am suggesting that welfare is mostly either a short term handout to prevent a vicious spiral of debt / problems or is a long term care for elderly. Welfare is not a means to cure poverty but is a means to prevent the unlucky or vulnerable from falling into poverty. I see the "scrounger" as a cost to be paid for such a system. Perhaps means testing can remove that cost, or perhaps not. But I know we shall not fix poverty this way but then a surgeon will operate to save me from a heart attack, even if he knows the real solution is better diet and exercise. Edit: as for European countries having broken people, yes it's very true here in the UK as well as elsewhere. I also know from personal experience (and lots of well done studies) that the majority if the broken are either I eligible for help (often migrants) or far more common mentally unstable and often having substance issues. Giving them a cheque helps far far less then the same cheque to a welder and his family who just got made redundant after his wife fell ill. Lots of welfare in his case gives time to find new jobs or retrain and prevents a family joining the ranks of outcasts. That helps. We could even reduce the impact by extending welfare to immigrants (despite the likely consequences). But far and away, the biggest visible poor in our society are mentally challenged - and we have no fixes or cures there. Handing out welfare or withholding it is not going to help if the reason you can't hold down a job is the voices in your head.