7 ms·
'Titstare' app at TechCrunch: women in tech deserve better
- chris_wot 13y agoI am absolutely amazed that these got anywhere near the stage. I'd always considered TechCruch to be about tech, not sexism. Frankly, to the two arseholes from Sydney: you're not a larrikin pair. You're two arseholes. No love, a Sydneysider.
- nichodges 13y agoAs an Australian, I was disappointed to see the team attempt to use "Aussie humour" as a shield. What would have been more Australian would be to harden up and apologise.
- chris_wot 13y agoI also want to point out the amazing app to schedule in kids play dates, made by Alex Jordan who is 9! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6352061 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6352061
- Grue3 13y agoWhat is sexist about CircleShake? It's not about women at all.
- Argorak 13y agoIt is a very manly gesture that implies a mental image of the someone else being the subject of the gesture. But first of all, it is very immature and tasteless and shouldn't be done on stage.
- Grue3 13y agoYour comment is incredibly hetero- and cis-normative, and also slut-shaming to boot. For shame!
- toyg 13y agoThe pictured "other sex" could as well be the "same sex" for all you know -- OMOPHOBIA! CHECK YOUR PRIVILEGE! I'm just joking, of course, and I agree that this app was immature and not deserving of any space at Disrupt (and goes doubly for Titstare, horrifying). Still, this whole PC thing sometimes can feel like walking on eggshells, as I've just demonstrated to you.
- chris_wot 13y agoIf it was about the same sex, would it make it any worse?
- Argorak 13y agoEdited to "someone else". In any case, "walking on eggshells" is what you do on stage anyways.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- JonnieCache 13y ago>Still, this whole PC thing sometimes can feel like walking on eggshells Important stuff is rarely easy or simple.
- sambeau 13y agoIt's not about women at all. sigh In an already male-biased community the non-inclusivity of demos like these put out a very specific message to women: this is not for you. The tit staring demo puts out a worse message: this is not for you—you are just a sex object to us. If you were a female hacker how would that make you feel your work will be judged by your male peers? Turn it around in your head, if you can, to a position where all industry and powerful roles are controlled by women and an important industry is dominated by women. It holds a conference where there are demonstrations of things that are women-only and where a man's role is reduced to that of sex object. Add to that a lot of cliquey female sex jokes where men are often the but but you are expected to laugh along and shrug it off. Is that a conference you would want to attend? What if you felt you had to to further your career? If that doesn't work turn it around to Jocks vs Geeks. Imagine you had to go to a Jock conference to further your career. Where the demos were all about football and the jokes were about weedy geeky types. Now imagine that you had to go to conferences like this if you wanted to further your career and you had to put up with an undercurrent of secret sexuality where jocks joked about having sex with geeky boys and demonstrated technology to spy on their genitalia. Even if I was gay I'm sure I'd find that intimidating. The world of tech needs to move away from this stupidity and be at the forefront of gender equality like it is at the forefront of a lot of new thinking. Technology can only bring about a better world if the people who create it understand what a better world looks like.
- Grue3 13y ago>In an already male-biased community the non-inclusivity of demos like these put out a very specific message to women: this is not for you. It's just one demo. And it's ok for an app to be not for any specific sex, not that there's any reason why women can't play CircleShake. Not every app should be for everyone. And I agree that TitStare is terrible. I just don't understand why the completely unrelated app is brought up in the article.
- sambeau 13y agoThe problem with CircleShake was not the App itself but the sniggeringly-schoolboy manner in which it was presented. Schoolboy humour is something that boys (and men) do when they get together in all-male environments. It is reasonably harmless in that context. As soon as you engage in this sort of behaviour in a public context like this you give the signal that this is an all-male environment. Hacking is not an all-male environment and it should strive to be inclusive. To do that we need to remove the all-male pack behaviour and to do that we need to start by cleaning up our public spaces — conferences, keynotes, demos etc.
- jnardiello 13y agoFrankly, TitStare was quite funny. In despite of being tits-related, i can't see how a woman could find it offensive (maybe because she has tits too? i can't see the correlation). It's more about lonely developers staring at tits. It's funny to see how the tech industry is passing thru its "feminist" age and just can't understand that THERE ARE differences between men and women, which doesn't mean anyhow that one is better than the other. They are just different. Liking tits is completely normal for a man, joking on it is too. Sexism is something different, a much bigger and subtle problem, against which (too often) women themselves do not react.
- iMark 13y agoYou're playing devil's advocate, right?
- jnardiello 13y agoNot really. Just expressing a point of view.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoA devil's advocate expresses a point of view. Specifically, they express a point of view that they do not agree with.
- WayneDB 13y agoIt's more than that. Playing devil's advocate means you're expressing the opposite point of view when you don't really hold that point of view, but you're doing it to prove a point.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoIndeed. jnardiello was asked if that is what they were doing, or if they genuinely hold that view; and they haven't given a definitive answer.
- cliveowen 13y agoI'm tired of seeing everything linked to sexism in tech. Moreover, sexism isn't a female only problem: try (as a male) to get a job in a kindergartn or a nursery school.
- chris_wot 13y agoNot everything is. Sexist things in tech get linked to sexism.
- WayneDB 13y agoThere was no "prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex" here though. Obviously not everyone agrees what is sexist.
- ericb 13y ago> try (as a male) to get a job in a kindergartner or a nursery school. Problems in other industries are no justification for ignoring our own--is this an argument you are seriously making? Really?
- cliveowen 13y agoI do not justify sexism in the tech industry, I'm trying to resize and put into perspective the phenomenon. If you add up all the jobs that are the preserve of women (mostly retail, where face-to-face communication is needed) you can actually see that sexism in the tech industry, in the grand scheme of things, is a pretty small matter. If you think I'm being hyperbolic just take a look at job ads for common jobs like barista, sales rep., PR, call centers operator, etc.
- illumen 13y agoAgreed. There are definitely sexism problems in education. Especially kinder, pre-school, and primary school levels. This also has flow on effects to the IT sector. 80% women teachers is a common amount in countries like UK/Australia. Not sure of the stats in other countries. The IT sector is doing better in addressing the problems compared to Education sector. The IT sector has made some good progress in the last few years. Some companies are going from 0%-20% to 40% women. There are outreach programs at many conferences and in many open source groups. If you look at the conference websites for teachers you don't see the same efforts. Lots left to do though. I think the IT industry can take pride in it has accomplished in comparison to education in recent years. IT is doing well compared to the journalism industry too (male dominated). Still lots left to do, and just because some industries are doing badly it doesn't mean we can't do better. But we also shouldn't ignore the good progress we have made.
- ealexhudson 13y agoDisappointing to see apologists for their behavior here. At least they have apologised: http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/08/an-apology-from-techcrunch/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/08/an-apology-from-techcrunch/
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jballanc 13y agoThe Hacker Community's greatest flaw -- a total disregard for predecessors -- may also be its saving grace. On one hand, we guffaw at those "old timers" who worked in assembler, Fortran, C, or even Perl. "They could never have even imagined what they were missing," we might think to ourselves as we re-discover continuation-passing style while coding our latest, greatest node.js-based file server. On the other hand, I think there's a good chance that Alexandra, and the rest of the next generation of programmers, will one day think that "rockstars", "ninjas", and "brogrammers" are as ridiculous and outdated as talking sock-puppets or anthropomorphic paperclips.
- laichzeit0 13y agoSo.. "TitStare" - sexist "DickStare" - not sexist Got it.
- objclxt 13y agoWho's saying that? Certainly not the article this post links to.
- MattBearman 13y agoGenuine question: Is there a dickstare app? And if so, is it not also considered sexist?
- laichzeit0 13y agoI don't know if there exists such an app, but it would probably not be considered sexist. Just like affirmative action / employment equity is not considered racist.
- eli 13y agoI don't know, but I sure wouldn't think it appropriate to present at a TechCrunch event.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zamalek 13y agoThe presenters should not get a response such as "the audience laughed at the numerous tit-related puns." or "The audience found it hilarious." Instead they should have instead met deadly silence, not booing, nothing. Don't feed the troll. Yes, they had inappropriate ideas, yes, they should not have been let near the stage - but why did we give them the response they were after? Respecting women doesn't start with pointing fingers at other people, it starts with the individual doing so.
- Alex3917 13y agoJust wait until the guardian learns about shake weight.
- frank_boyd 13y agoWhen I see such developments, I conclude that society does not feel the pain enough yet. The pain that inevitably will catch up with us, for all the real problems we create but do not solve.
- Argorak 13y agoThis is actually a good example why you should have a code of conduct as a conference. Bad things on stage happen. As an organizer, you can now write an apology that sounds like the one techcrunch wrote: http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/08/an-apology-from-techcrunch/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/08/an-apology-from-techcrunch/ Or, if you had a CoC, it could sound like this: * "Sorry, we had people on stage that violated the rules we agreed upon beforehand. <list of rules from CoC> They were expelled from the conference immediately."
- pstack 13y agoAnd that would actually seem to be a really reasonable progression for this whole thing. The presenters say "we made an unfortunate judgement call and we apologize" and the conference says "so from now on, here's our short list of rules to avoid uncertainties in the future" and then we all grow up and move on with our lives. Unfortunately the tech industry seems to be enamoured with not merely being offended, but being offended by the potential that they could have been offended. So we'll circle the drain with everyone beating the drum in support of their own personal agendas for awhile more before this is over. By that time, someone else will have done something dumb and we'll be ready to have another go.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hexscrews 13y agoThis was both a massive waste of time and effort. A truly interesting app would be one that measures facial symmetry. Humans tend to appreciate symmetrical features, same length of arms, legs, eye alignment, etc. I can see where this too could be abused, sadly. But at least it would have a marginally better chance to have a market. And it would provide a interesting technical challenge.
- pstack 13y agoWhile I agree with your point, I don't see how being physically attracted to a person's symmetry is any different than being attracted to the dimensions of their hips or the size of their breasts other than being more presentable to an audience. It would be more sensible from the standpoint of the presentation, but any of those people pitchforking over focusing on physical attraction to physical attributes of human beings in this thread would have to maintain the same incredulity over one measuring each body part for symmetry.
- cubsink 13y agoHow can people be angry about this? I thought it was quite funny. It's quite sexist to say that this app is sexist. I come from the feminist extreme country Sweden and are well known with the feminist agenda. This article makes me angry, not the pleasant, funny guys presenting just a for-fun app. This whole debacle is so not necessary and could be avoided. I, like many guys in Sweden are very tired of being called sexist when you're not and tired of the feminists altogether. I guess the US / UK haven't had enough of feminism yet.
- gregd 13y agoWhen you gear an entire industry to the immaturity of male youth, what do you expect? I'm a 46 year old male with almost 20 years of various IT experience (systems administration to .net coding to sql server) and the terms rockstar, ninja, brogrammer don't apply, nor appeal to me. I would argue that the entire IT industry is to blame for this bullshit. Stop, just for a moment, to think about the culture you're manifesting in the words you use to describe your workforce. Rockstar? Really? Because most "rockstars" wash up, burn out, fade away or simply die and the fall is as quick as the rise.
- pstack 13y ago//"rockstars" wash up, burn out, fade away or simply die and the fall is as quick as the rise."// So exactly as most of us have come to know the industry over the last two decades. :/
- liedra 13y agoAs a woman in tech, I'd like to thank the men in this thread who obviously get what the problem is here. This sort of stuff can only change with a concerted effort from both men and women to change the culture. And it's small steps like standing up to sexist jerks and calling out people who engage in activities like this that will get us closer to our destination.
- vinceguidry 13y agoReally, men in tech need to stop thinking that they're somehow not part of the problem and are therefore free to make jokes about it. You become part of the problem when you do stuff like this. You don't see white people going around using the word "nigga" lightly, why should it be OK for this sort of joke to be made at a tech conference? It's not OK. It may never be OK. So just stop doing it. You're not Louis CK, you didn't make a career of comedy. Don't think you can tread the line of these social issues and not have it blow up in your face.
- xobitz 13y ago> You don't see white people going around using the word "nigga" lightly, why should it be OK for this sort of joke to be made at a tech conference? Because people who think these are the same thing are delusional.
- pcerioli 13y agoI am also a woman in tech, and I have been writing code for a living in the last 15-20 years. I didn't find titstare presentation offensive or demeaning. In fact I laughed quite a bit when they presented it. Even if women are not included in the brogrammers club, I don't find much discrimination in the work environment either. If you are great at what you do, you have the same chance as anybody else. My 2 cents.
- sambeau 13y agoThis highlights major problems our community suffers while the comments here clearly demonstrate a few more. It's all very disappointing. We are not doing ourselves any favours here. 1. Many male developers assume that they are in an all-male environment and behave as if they are. Sniggering schoolboy humour, edgy jokes, sexual jokes are a part of young male pack behaviour that is relatively harmless in all-male environments. In mixed environments they are not only inappropriate but they send the signal to other people that this is a young, male environment. Only. To be inclusive we need to drop the male pack mentality. It is right to call out this behaviour, especially in public environments: conferences, keynotes, hacker sessions. It is also right to call-out all-male speaker-panels for the same reason. 2. Something 'sexy' is not automatically 'sexist' — it all depends where the power is. A tits-tracking app is (apart from being male-pack humour) an example of those with the power in the room making fun at the expense of those less powerful in the room. It is also 'objectification' — the reinforcement of a women's place as being an object to look at or to have sex with, rather than being an intellectual equal. The women in the room are expected to laugh it off or be subject to more ridicule: "it's just a bit of fun" — This is classic bullying behaviour. As long as these rooms are mostly full of men, women will be powerless to do anything about it. It's no surprise that the fight-back starts only once these incidents hit the internet: our community is bullying women. 3. A group of women ironically creating a pack-track app that tracks penises wouldn't automatically be sexist. It would almost certainly be funny and ironic for two reasons: 1) the balance of power is against the women 2) they would be shining a light onto male-pack behaviour. Men, still holding the balance of power here, should be able to laugh such a thing off. Sadly many of you here wouldn't. 4. Commentators here have a fundamental misunderstanding of what Feminism and Sexism is. They are confusing equality with uniformity. Feminism is a civil rights movement. It is about equality of power and opportunity for women. Much like anti-racism it isn't about people making jokes about each other: it is about segregated jobs, inequality of opportunity, economic discrimination. Seeking equality is not the same as seeking uniformity. Just because you can find an example where women have more jobs in a sector doesn't mean that it is sexism against men. It is often the opposite: low-paid caring jobs around cleaning and child-rearing. The low-pay & low-power is the result of years of sexism, as is the usual case where men who get into these roles quickly rise through the ranks and far more likely to become bosses (despite their under-representation). Some women protect these environments as all-women precisely to give them a chance at promotion. While I don't condone this behaviour I can at least understand it. Equality is the big picture; the balance of the scales. Men still hold the top jobs, the powerful jobs: Judges, Police Chiefs, Prime Ministers, Presidents, Board Members. Equality of opportunity is the ability to rise through the ranks based on ability not sex. 5. Most sexism is silent. We do it without knowing we are doing it. Men appoint men because the other men are men like themselves. Men know how to talk to men; Geeky men more-so. We fill our conferences with men, our panels with men, our keynotes with men because it is an easy thing to do. We promote bright young men because they remind us of ourselves. We tell ourselves that we are simply picking the best. Combating this silent sexism is hard. As long as all we see is men everywhere then we will continue to be silently sexist and women will continue to silently vote with their feet. 6. It is sexist to say that men are better at programming than women. Unless you have scientific proof that I haven't seen: women are perfectly good at hacking. Any woman who has chosen a career in IT despite the discrimination stacked against her (see above) is already extraordinary yet we will generally treat her less than an ordinary hacker. Women make up 51% of the population, they are out-performing men in school & university here in the UK and they should therefore be over 50% of our community. But they are not. This is somebody's fault and it is most probably ours. We have created an environment that is hostile to these bright young women and it is lunacy: we are throwing away half of the talent. If we are throwing away half the talent how can we possibly be hiring the best? Half of whom we hire must be sub-standard! Which brings me to: 7. Positive discrimination is the only way to go for our industry. We need to adjust our gender-balance by removing our obvious gender-bias. We are currently clearly discriminating against women so we should address this positively.