4 ms·
Ask HN: Why would a company with stellar employees pay salaries?
Why not pay employees for significant achievements only and in proportion to those achievements? If they create nothing worthwhile, they would receive zero income.
Everyone at the company would be aware of who is getting how much and for what. If they are not happy with the results, then could just leave.
Presumably stellar employees would have enough confidence in their abilities to consider such an arrangement.
If they need money in the short term, then they can work on something that they can finish in a month or two.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoHow do you measure the achievement of a groups of employees, some of whom have worked on more than one project? Why should they trust you to pay them appropriately from the profits? How do you entice employees to work on less glamorous projects? How do you entice programmers to work on risky projects that may not pay off at all? How do you get a better employee to work with rather than against a less stellar employee? Contractors offering fixed-price contractors do this, but they don't do the grunt work that underpins much of the continuing work.
- aristus 17y agoRisk has to be proportionate to authority and reward. Responsibility without authority is a recipe for disaster -- any overworked assistant or salesperson can tell you that. So... the greater the risk you ask other people to take, the more reward and authority you must give them. At the extreme you are talking about ("they would receive zero income.") the "employees" would basically be cofounders.
- amichail 17y agoBut consider a company that works in the way I mentioned that employs 10,000 people. They would share IP and infrastructure. And employees can change teams very easily.
- ErrantX 17y agowhere are you going to find 10,000 stellar people willing to work in this way? anyone willing to work for no collateral at insane risk either know what their doing and wont be working on this risk, or are probably not really that stellar ;)
- aristus 17y agoI think I get what you're talking about, a kind of Randite All-Star team. It's doable at a small scale -- that's what a startup is. But some models do not scale to 4 orders of magnitude. There's the measurement problem. With 10,000 salespeople or 10,000 artisans, sure, you can directly measure the value they create. With everyone else? How about the truck driver? The receptionists? HR?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- barry-cotter 17y agoMaybe you've heard of Coase's theorem? It's relevant to this discusion. Anyway, above a very small number you can't reliably value someone's true contributions, because there are feedback effects and problems of assymetric information. If you've heard of Dunbar's number that is probably teh absolute maximum anything remotely close to this could work at, and I'd actually be surprised at it working with more than 15 people. But that isn't a company (stocks) it's a partnership. BTW, good on you for doing an app, but the screen is too wide, there's no reason for the scroll bar along the bottom. Also the discussion link is pointless, no activity, no point. Add a highscore thing and ask people if they want to phone home when they get their personal high score.
- ram1024 17y agoanyone really good at doing something will be able to find much better terms to work in other than "we'll pay you what we think you're worth" which carries the negative connotation every time you receive a paycheck that "i'm only worth this much to the company" no one would stay very long unless they are consistently receiving more than they think they're worth.
- stonemetal 17y agoIf I am shouldering 100% of the Risk and getting 100% of the rewards then I am not an employee I am a business owner. If I am shouldering 100% of the Risk and getting less than 100% of the reward then I am a business owner who has been conned out of my fair share. Also what sort of portion does the receptionist get? They need to be paid something and yet I don't believe anyone considers answering the phone a "significant achievement".