5 ms·
That is why the strict, and obviously insane, reading of the law is not the correct reading of the law. The intent element applies to every other element of th
by gamblor956 13y ago
That is why the strict, and obviously insane, reading of the law is not the correct reading of the law. The intent element applies to every other element of the crime--you must intentionally (a) access a computer, (b) without authorization or inxcess or authorized access, and (c) obtain information from a protected computer.
Intent is the most important element of criminal statutes. For example, for homicide intent is the difference between a capital murder and involuntary manslaughter (and all the gradation between).
- rayiner 13y agoRight, it's a basic rule of statutory construction that you have to apply the intent requirement to every element of a crime. As a practical matter, the CFAA has not been applied to situations where it was unclear whether the person violated the law. With 3taps and Swartz, it's pretty clear that the defendants knew they were kicked off the site and tried to access the, anyway. The debate in those cases is about the punishment, which at least in Swartz's case was disproportional to the crime.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>With 3taps and Swartz, it's pretty clear that the defendants knew they were kicked off the site and tried to access the, anyway. I don't know. It seems like you could still make the argument, e.g. if your account gets disabled but nobody tells you why, you might have to assume something you did wasn't allowed, but why would you assume that to mean you can never create another account even if you behave differently in the future? And if you can do that then how are you supposed to know what specific subset of the things you did are the ones you aren't supposed to do again? So there was the argument in the Swartz case that, for example, getting kicked off for downloading too quickly just means they want you to slow down rather than stop because they don't want you to degrade performance for others. And the fact that we have to argue about it is the problem. Also, I think the OP was really referring to Auernheimer more than these others anyway, which gets more to the heart of the issue. He obviously intended to change the number at the end of the URL. The problem is that we don't know whether doing that is classified by the law as unauthorized access, but unless the courts are willing to throw out the statute or adopt a narrow interpretation, he still gets convicted for doing the thing he intended to do, not because he intended to violate the law, but because the judge decided after the fact that the thing he intended to do was a violation of the law. That seems extremely problematic because the judge is doing the clarification on what the law means ex post facto but then still subjecting the defendant's prior conduct to that new ruling, but that's the situation the statute leaves courts in unless they're willing to throw it out as a result of that.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>That is why the strict, and obviously insane, reading of the law is not the correct reading of the law. That's the whole point. The clear interpretation is clearly wrong and the remaining interpretation has undefined behavior because of the lack of any obvious demarcation point for authorized access. In addition to that, we have the "ignorance of the law" issue. If you don't know what "unauthorized access" means but you intentionally do something that a judge subsequently decides was unauthorized access, are you (or the hypothetical security researcher, for example) going to be willing to bet your freedom that the fact that you subjectively didn't intend for your access to be unauthorized is going to keep you out of prison? Chilling effects.
- rayiner 13y agoI think "unauthorized access" is like porn. You know it when you see it. As for chilling effects for security researchers, I don't think they're an inadvertent result of vague statutory language. I think Congress clearly intended to make that sort of tinkering around illegal. After all, back in meat space, you can't pick my lock, burst into my living room, and say: "hey, your lock sucks, buy my security service!" I don't think it's necessarily a good idea to create such a rule, but there is a certain internal logic to it. Laws create social norms. When it comes to private property, the laws create a social norm wherein you're expected to give peoples' private property a very wide berth except according to certain clearly-defined, socially-accepted conventions. I.e. you can come onto someone's property if you're invited, or if the property seems to be a public venue and you have no reason to think you're banned, but generally you stay the fuck away. The end result of that norm is that people don't go and buy the best possible locks. The social norm enforces the owner's right to exclude, not technology. I don't even lock the door to my apartment because I know that nobody is going to come into my apartment and just look around because they found the door unlocked. And I know that if a neighbor sees someone do it, they'll call the cops because it's such an egregious violation of the social norm that it's per se suspicious. I don't think that trying to create that norm for internet sites is the best model, for various practical reasons, but like I said there's a certain internal logic to it.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago